Concept
Purpose of the Rape Shield
Past sexual conduct of a victim
Victim's Past Sexual Conduct
Purpose of the Rape Shield
Rule 412 bars evidence offered to prove that an alleged victim engaged in other sexual behavior or has a particular sexual predisposition, in any civil or criminal proceeding involving alleged sexual misconduct.1 The rule makes sense only against the practice it replaced. Under the common law tradition, a woman who brought a rape charge was fair game for cross-examination about her sexual behavior, on the theory that it bore both on her credibility and on whether she had consented.2 In the first half of the twentieth century, judges would usually have admitted evidence that the complainant had consensual sex with other people, and would usually have allowed reputation evidence that she was “unchaste” or promiscuous.3
The first objection to that tradition is relevance. Suppose V has consensual sex with A. On another occasion V has intercourse with D, and V says D raped her. D answers that V consented, and he offers evidence of V’s relationship with A to show that, because V consented with A, she probably consented with D.4 The inference is weak. V’s consensual sex with A usually tells us little or nothing about whether her sex with D was consensual, because V did not accuse A of rape and she has accused D.5 The logical premise of Rule 412 is that a person’s past sexual conduct is rarely relevant to how that person acted sexually on a specific occasion.6 The credibility theory fares no better. The old tradition never thought a woman’s sexual history bore on her credibility when she testified in other kinds of cases, and rape trials allowed the questioning even where clinical evidence made any suggestion of consent ridiculous.7
The second objection is what factfinders do with evidence that proves so little. Juries, as well as judges and commentators, tended to overvalue it and to treat it as more probative of consent than it was.8 The evidence was also apt to be misused as grounds for not worrying much about the rape, even if it did occur.9 Jurors might conclude that the victim “asked for it” or is simply not worthy of protection.10 Culture compounds the danger. Men who have a lot of sex are admired and women who do are shamed, so an attack on a woman’s sexual character will likely devalue her character and her testimony, while similar evidence against a man will likely bolster his sexual character.11
The third objection concerns the person on the stand. Admitting this evidence tended to transform rape trials into trials of the victim, brutalizing her and powerfully discouraging other rape victims from coming forward.12 Reformers therefore saw two separate harms to guard against whenever the victim’s sexual history comes in: unfair prejudice to the case, and psychological harm to the victim.13
Legislatures responded in the 1970s. Most states and the federal government adopted “rape shield statutes,” which vary in their terms but broadly ban the use of character evidence to prove the victim’s consent, and Rule 412 is the federal version.14 The rule aims to safeguard the alleged victim against invasion of privacy, potential embarrassment, and sexual stereotyping, and against the infusion of sexual innuendo into the factfinding process.15 By protecting victims in most instances, it also encourages victims of sexual misconduct to institute and take part in legal proceedings against alleged offenders.16
The premise behind Rule 412 sits uneasily beside Rules 413, 414, and 415. Those rules require admission of a defendant’s past sexual offenses as relevant to the defendant’s sexual conduct on a specific occasion.17 Rule 412 is essentially exclusionary as to a victim’s sexual behavior or predisposition, while Rules 413 through 415 are essentially inclusionary as to a defendant’s.18 Keep the two groups apart, because they run in opposite directions.
The structure of the rule follows from these purposes. Subdivision (a) sets the broad bar. Subdivision (b)(1) permits three narrow categories of evidence in a criminal case, and subdivision (c) supplies a protective procedure of motion, in camera hearing, and sealing.19 In a civil case, subdivision (b)(2) replaces the criminal exceptions with a balancing test: the court may admit the evidence if its probative value substantially outweighs the danger of harm to any victim and of unfair prejudice to any party.20 The sections that follow take the bar, its reach, the criminal exceptions, the civil standard, and the procedure in that order, and then apply them to problems.