Concept
Not Hearsay by Definition
Statements attributable to party-opponent
Opposing Party's Statements
Not Hearsay by Definition
A machine shop owner tells an insurance adjuster that an employee was badly hurt because his machine had no safety shield. The employee later sues, the owner insists at trial that the machine was safe, and the employee calls the adjuster to repeat what the owner said.1 The owner objects that the adjuster's account is hearsay. The objection fails, and the reason is a rule that defines the statement as not hearsay.
Rule 801(d)(2) takes a group of out-of-court statements that fit the ordinary definition of hearsay and defines them out of the category. When a statement is offered against an opposing party and falls within one of five listed categories, the rule treats it as not hearsay.2 The result looks odd at first, because the statements it covers are exactly the ones the ordinary definition catches. Hearsay is a statement the declarant did not make while testifying at the current trial or hearing and that a party offers to prove the truth of the matter asserted.3 The owner's words meet both parts of that definition: he spoke outside the courtroom, and the employee offers his words to prove the shield was missing. Rule 801(d)(2) leaves that fit untouched and removes the hearsay label anyway, because the employee offers the statement against the very person who made it.
The hearsay doctrine protects parties against statements they had no chance to cross-examine, and that protection has nothing to guard when the declarant is the party. A litigant can hardly complain that it could not cross-examine itself.4 The deeper explanation is the adversary system, in which each party is responsible for making or breaking its own lawsuit by its conduct both in and out of court.5 A party's opponent may use what the party has said, and the party remains free to answer it.6
The rule offers no objective guarantee of trustworthiness. The party need not have had firsthand knowledge of what it declared, and the statement may have been self-serving when made.7 Admission therefore settles little. The statement is admissible for its truth but is in no way conclusive, and the party may offer rebuttal evidence, such as a benign explanation for what was said or done.8
Lawyers long called these statements party admissions. The Federal Rules call the same thing an opposing party's statement, and the two terms are identical.9 The new title was not meant to change how the rule applies.10 The older word still misleads, because it suggests a confession. Nothing in the rule requires the statement to concede anything, a point taken up below.
Common-law judges applied these rules as exceptions to the hearsay rule. The drafters of the Federal Rules saw that the two classes in Rule 801(d) had characteristics that set them apart, and they converted them from hearsay under Rule 801(c) to nonhearsay under Rule 801(d).11 The choice of label changes no outcome, because a statement within either an exemption or an exception is admissible for its truth despite the hearsay objection.12 The Advisory Committee on Evidence Rules rejected a proposal to relabel the exemptions as exceptions for that reason, adding that the exemption label had become ingrained.13 The other definitional family, a testifying witness's prior statements under Rule 801(d)(1), does carry a condition: the declarant must testify and be subject to cross-examination about the statement.14 Rule 801(d)(2) has no such condition. Admissibility under it does not depend on whether the declarant is unavailable, available, or actually testifies.15
In a problem, then, the classification debate matters less than two questions asked in order. Is the statement offered against an opposing party? And what ties the speaker to that party?16 The next scene shows why the second question carries the weight.
The words about the shield are identical in the two scenes. What changed the result is the speaker's link to the party against whom the statement is offered. Because reliability is not the premise of the rule, each category is defined by that link. The rule recognizes five, and each anchors a section that follows. In the order the rule states them, the statement is:
- The party's own, made in an individual or representative capacity.17
- One the party manifested that it adopted or believed to be true.18
- Made by a person whom the party authorized to make a statement on the subject.19
- Made by the party's agent or employee on a matter within the scope of that relationship and while it existed.20
- Made by the party's coconspirator during and in furtherance of the conspiracy.21
Fitting one of these categories answers only the hearsay objection. The statement must still be relevant, and it can still be excluded to avoid undue prejudice or under an overriding policy such as the exclusion of character evidence.22