Concept
A Party's Own Statements
Statements attributable to party-opponent
A Party's Own Statements
Rule 801(d)(2)(A) is the simplest of the five categories of opposing-party statements, because it reaches a statement that “was made by the party in an individual or representative capacity.”1 The speaker and the litigant are the same person, so no one stands between the words and the party they are offered against. In a suit by or against an individual, the doctrine reaches that individual’s own statements offered against him.2 The proponent’s burden is light: the proponent must show only that the opposing party once made the statement and that it is relevant in the trial.3
The word “admission” misleads, because the statement need not confess anything. “I forgot to make last month’s child support payment” is admissible against the speaker, and so are “I get paid under the table” and “My monthly income is $10,000.”4 The only requirement about a statement’s damaging quality is that the statement be offered against the party’s case, in some relevant way, so the hearsay term differs from the lay meaning of “admission.”5
The subsections below take the statement in order: the capacity in which the party spoke, the form the words took, and whether the party really said them. They end with a party’s formal acts in court and the line between a statement and mere conduct.
Individual or Representative Capacity
The rule covers a party who speaks for himself or herself and a party who speaks in a role, such as a trustee, a person who manages property for the benefit of others.6 The two capacities are interchangeable. A trustee who is a party may have a statement used against him even though he made it in an individual capacity.7 Relevance does the only sorting: the statement must bear on the trustee’s representative duties or conduct.8
A statement that reaches its speaker may also reach the speaker’s employer, but only through a category that attributes the words to the employer. Suppose Jane drives for Taxi Co. and makes a statement in her capacity as one of its drivers. The statement is admissible against both the company and Jane, though still not against Jill, who did not make it.9 The step from Jane’s words to the company rests on category (D), which asks whether an agent or employee spoke “on a matter within the scope of that relationship and while it existed.”10
Spoken, Written, and Posted Words
The form of the statement does not matter. A party’s own words, written or oral, are admissible against the party, and the source’s examples run from a spoken remark about a missed child support payment to a party’s tax return.12 Postings to a party’s own Facebook page count as well, and State v. Inkton is a reported example.13
Digital media change the form of proof but not the rule. Emails, text messages, and social media pages are now offered in virtually every motion, hearing, or trial.14 What digital proof adds is a sharper question about who wrote the item, which the next subsection takes up. The bank fraud prosecution in United States v. Sprick shows the rule at work on a defendant’s own email, which the court admitted against him.
Meeting the party-statement rule does not end the inquiry in a criminal case. “Involuntary” confessions are barred under the Fifth Amendment, though only where a state agent plays some active role.15
A friend’s or relative’s words fall outside category (A), even when they match what the party might have said, because the friend is not the party. Those words need another route, such as proof that the party manifested that he adopted them or believed them to be true.16
Did the Party Make the Statement?
Deuce is prosecuted for possessing controlled drugs. He pleads not guilty and says the drugs belonged to a former roommate who has returned to his native country. Anita, Deuce’s estranged girlfriend, will testify that Deuce once told her he “made a hell of a good living moving drugs right under the nose of the cops.”18 Deuce objects that the statement is irrelevant and that he has not testified and probably will not. The objection fails, because the proponent need show only that the party once made the statement and that it is relevant,19 and the statement bears on whether the drugs were his. Anita’s account comes in under category (A) even if Deuce never takes the stand.
The analysis changes if Deuce denies saying it. Suppose he claims that the estrangement made Anita vengeful and that she invented the statement. The objection then puts the foundation in issue, and the judge decides it as a preliminary question under Rule 104(a). To admit the statement, the judge must find by a preponderance of the evidence that Deuce actually made it. If the judge thinks it more likely that Anita invented it, the jury never hears it.20 If the judge admits the statement, the jury is not told of the finding. Deuce may offer the same evidence of estrangement and revenge, and the jury decides whether to believe that he said it and how much weight it deserves.21
Authorship is the foundation for every form of statement. If the government offers an email it says the defendant sent, and someone else wrote it, the email is irrelevant and inadmissible. Authenticity is a question of conditional relevance, because the item is relevant only if it is what the proponent says it is.22 The judge’s Rule 104(a) role therefore extends to posts, emails, and any other proffered words attributed to a party, since they prove something about the party only if the party wrote them. The same preliminary question arises under the other four categories of Rule 801(d)(2).23
Pleadings and Judicial Admissions
A party’s formal allegations in a pending civil case carry more weight than an ordinary remark. An averment in a pleading filed in the pending civil suit is a judicial admission: the party is foreclosed from offering evidence to the contrary, and under FRCP 8(d) what an answer does not deny is admitted.25 An out-of-court statement offered against the party is different. It is not “binding” in the sense of foreclosing the party from taking a conflicting position at trial, and the party may explain away or reject what he said before.26 A party who takes such a position often induces the adversary to offer the earlier statement.27
The two kinds of admission differ in what the party may do afterward. After a judicial admission, the party may not contradict the pleading with evidence. After an ordinary statement, the party may testify, explain, or deny, and the trier weighs the competing accounts.
Guilty Pleas
A guilty plea is the defendant’s own statement of the facts essential to the conviction, and a party-opponent may offer those facts against him under Rule 801(d)(2)(A).29 The facts come in as an evidentiary admission, as distinguished from a judicial admission, so the defendant’s reason for pleading, if any, may also be introduced.30 A majority of decisions admit the plea with that explanation.31
Offering the conviction itself is a second route. When a conviction on a plea of guilty is offered against a party, the effect of proceeding under Rule 803(22) or under Rule 801(d)(2)(A) is identical.32 Whether a plea can be used at all may also turn on rules outside the hearsay rule, which a later section collects.
Conduct Is Not a Statement
Rule 801(d)(2) exempts statements, so the first question about any act is whether it is a statement at all. Article VIII proceeds by definition: Rules 801(a) through (c) define hearsay, and Rule 802 excludes it, subject to exceptions.34 Nonverbal conduct falls inside the definition only if the actor intended it as an assertion.35 Conduct the actor did not mean as a message is therefore not hearsay, and no exemption or exception is needed to admit it.36
Flight shows how this works. Offered to show consciousness of guilt, flight asks the jury to infer from the act that the suspect believed himself guilty, and from that belief that he was guilty. Under Rule 801, nonassertive conduct offered for that two-step inference is not hearsay.37 Calling flight an “admission” mislabels it, because the party-statement exemption is never reached when nothing was stated.
Classification is only the first filter. The hearsay problem is usually overcome either by the party-admission exemption or by the conclusion that the conduct is not an intended statement, but rules outside the hearsay rule can still keep party conduct out. Rules 407 (remedial measures), 408 (settlement and compromise), and 409 (payment of medical expenses) are examples. The concern behind them is to avoid discouraging socially desirable behavior by making it evidence against the person who engages in it.38
A question that calls flight an “admission” has skipped the threshold step. Ask first whether the conduct is a statement under Rule 801(a). Only a statement, meaning an assertion in words or in conduct intended as an assertion, moves on to the categories of Rule 801(d)(2).