Concept
Criticisms of the Exception
Present sense impression
Criticisms of the Exception
Rule 803(1) admits "a statement describing or explaining an event or condition, made while or immediately after the declarant perceived it."1 Courts name the "substantial contemporaneity" of event and statement as the primary guaranty of trustworthiness behind the rule.2 Critics attack that guaranty. Their attack is worth learning because it shows which hearsay risks the exception leaves open, and so what an opponent can still argue about a statement the judge has admitted.
Circuit Judge Posner made the sharpest attack in a concurrence. He agreed that the district court should be affirmed and disagreed with nothing in the court's opinion, but he wrote separately to express concern with Rules 803(1) and (2).3 His objection goes to the premise: "Even real immediacy is not a guarantor of truthfulness." It is "not true that people can't make up a lie in a short period of time," he wrote, and "[m]ost lies in fact are spontaneous," a point he supported with a study reporting that planned lies were rarer than spontaneous lies.4
He illustrated the point with an everyday case. An acquaintance with a new dog, "a little yappy thing," asks him, "Isn't he beautiful?" He answers yes, though he is a cat person and considers the dog hideous.5 The lie needed no preparation. If a falsehood can be spoken as fast as the truth, speed can protect against faulty memory without protecting against insincerity.
The facts in Boyce show the setting in which the exception operates. The opinion observes that either party could have called Portis to testify and that her testimony would not have been hearsay. Neither did. The government did not, because she had recanted her story that Boyce had a gun after he wrote her several letters from prison asking her to lie. Boyce did not, because her testimony would likely have reinforced the evidence that he tried to suborn perjury.6 The declarant stays off the stand, and not always for neutral reasons. The sequence also matters: she recanted only after the letters, so whatever she said earlier came before that pressure.
The exception's defenders do not claim that it removes every hearsay danger. A court applying Rule 807 acknowledged that statements of this kind can still suffer from the remaining risks of insincerity and faulty narration. It defended the exceptions on the Advisory Committee's theory that such statements "possess circumstantial guarantees of trustworthiness sufficient to justify nonproduction of the declarant in person at the trial even though he may be available."7 From that theory the court concluded that a hearsay statement need not be free from all four categories of risk to be admitted under Rule 807.8 The standard is sufficiency. A critic who shows that one danger survives has therefore identified the exception's limit, and has not yet shown that the exception fails.
The elements of Rule 803(1) do real work, though they bear on timing and perception more than on sincerity. The statement must concern what the declarant is perceiving, not something that happened at a remote earlier time, and a statement about when a gym bag was placed in a trunk could not qualify for that reason.9 The declarant must also have perceived the event. In another decision the record held no circumstances from which the trial court could infer, by a preponderance, that the declarant saw a driver "cut in." The trial judge reasoned that the declarant would have spoken only if positioned to observe the collision, but the court held that the reported words, "the bastard tried to cut in," did not alone show more likely than not that the declarant saw the event.10 A statement cannot establish its own foundation.
The companion exception that Posner also questioned, Rule 803(2), rests on the same kind of gatekeeping. Whether the speaker was under the stress of excitement caused by the event, and whether the statement relates to it, are questions the judge decides under Rule 104(a), not the jury.11 Everything that sheds light on the speaker's emotional state counts, including the nature of the event, the speaker's relationship to it, tone of voice, demeanor, and the content of the statement.12 A recording can make the finding easier. One commentator notes that on tape an agent's voice is exultant after he has completed a successful arrest.13
Defenders also point to a practical check that works outside the declarant's head. The statement is usually made to a third person who was present at the time and scene, so the witness who later testifies will in most cases have observed the situation and can check the declarant's accuracy and furnish corroboration. The declarant will often be available for cross-examination, which lets the trier of fact test his or her credibility.14 Posner's dog shows where that check fails. A listener cannot contradict a polite falsehood about taste, but a misdescription of an event the listener is also watching invites correction on the spot.
That check belongs to the usual setting and is not a condition of admission. When the Advisory Committee expanded Rule 804(b)(3) to admit statements exculpating another person, it required corroboration. The present sense impression exception presents no such general need, because its rationale offers sufficient assurances without the extra requirement, and the Federal Rule and most courts have not required it.15 The limits on time and subject matter usually mean that the reporting witness perceived the event or observed circumstances strongly suggesting it. That is an added assurance, but a general justification for admission is not the same as a requirement.16
The same limits answer much of the worry about new technology. Some fear a wholesale admission of "social media hearsay" from tweets and status updates, but that concern appears overblown. The event or condition described must be shown to have occurred, the declarant must have personal knowledge of it, and the assertion must come while the declarant perceives it or immediately thereafter.17
A statement that clears Rule 803(1) can still face a second screen, the Confrontation Clause. Calls to 911 often raise problems under Crawford because the operators who receive them are connected with law enforcement, but some are admitted under the emergency doctrine. In one Seventh Circuit decision, a 911 caller's report of a shooting, a present sense impression, fit that doctrine.18
Posner's own vote shows how the criticism operates in practice. He voiced concern with Rules 803(1) and (2) yet joined the result, disagreeing with nothing in the court's opinion.19 A judge who finds the rationale thin still asks whether the statement describes what the speaker perceived and came within the time the rule allows. A statement that meets the elements comes in, and the doubts go to how much it should be believed. The checklist below puts those doubts to work.