Concept
The Rule and Its Rationale
Excited utterance
The Excited Utterance Exception
The Rule and Its Rationale
Rule 803(2) lifts the hearsay bar for “a statement relating to a startling event or condition, made while the declarant was under the stress of excitement that it caused.”1 That sentence sets three requirements, and the sections that follow take them in turn: a startling event or condition, a statement made while the stress of that event lasted, and a statement that relates to the event. Nothing in the rule asks whether the declarant can testify. Rule 803 prefaces its exceptions with the instruction that they apply “regardless of whether the declarant is available as a witness,”2 so the proponent of an excited utterance never has to show that the declarant is unavailable.
The Rules sort their hearsay exceptions into two groups: those usable whether or not the declarant is available, and those usable only when the declarant is unavailable.3 The sorting reflects a judgment about risk. Where the risks are minimal, the statement comes in either way. Where the case for the exception rests on necessity rather than on likely truthfulness, the proponent must first prove unavailability.4 Excited utterances sit in the first group.5 The exception draws its reliability from the circumstances in which the words were spoken, and those circumstances were fixed at that moment. If excitement suspended the declarant's powers of reflection and fabrication then, testimony from the stand, given when those powers are working, is no more reliable than the earlier outburst and perhaps less.6
The theory itself rests on common experience. Courts explain the exception, as in Lambrecht v. Schreyer, by observing that when a person is under physical or mental shock, a stress of nervous excitement may be produced such that the mind is for the time being controlled by the event, considerations of self-interest are eliminated, and words are forced out without will and without fair opportunity to mould or modify them.7 Another often-quoted formulation adds that such an utterance is made under “the immediate and uncontrolled domination of the senses, and during the brief period when considerations of self-interest could not have been brought fully to bear by reasoned reflection,” and so may be taken as “particularly trustworthy (or, at least, as lacking the usual grounds of untrustworthiness).”8 Study guides compress the point into two halves: any motive to lie is overcome by the shock, and memory is no problem because the statement is made close in time to the event.9 Courts of appeals still say much the same thing, that the excitement of the event limits the declarant's capacity to fabricate and so offers some guarantee of reliability.10
The theory has critics. Psychologists would probably concede that excitement reduces the chance that reflective self-interest colors a declarant's words, but they question whether that gain is outweighed by the distorting effect of shock and excitement on the declarant's observation and judgment.11 A judge writing separately in a case that involved two hearsay exceptions was blunter. He quoted the Advisory Committee's justification, that circumstances “may produce a condition of excitement which temporarily stills the capacity of reflection and produces utterances free of conscious fabrication,” and said the words “may” and “conscious” drain it of any content. Even if a person is so excited that he loses the capacity for reflection, he asked, how can anyone be confident that his unreflective utterance is reliable? He added, quoting a commentator, that “one need not be a psychologist to distrust an observation made under emotional stress; everybody accepts such statements with mental reservation.”12
Despite these questions, the exception is well established.13 The doubts do their work in two other places. They explain why courts apply the requirements with care. One court of appeals found the record empty of any circumstances from which the trial court could have inferred, by a preponderance, that the declarant had seen the event the statement described, and the declaration itself did not say so. The court stressed that the declarant of an excited utterance must personally observe the startling event, and it quoted authority that a statement drifting from the exciting event into past facts or the future takes on a reflective quality and deserves closer scrutiny for true spontaneity.14 The doubts also feed argument about weight. For admissibility, the law is satisfied once the reflective, deliberative, fabricative capacity is stilled, and whatever weaknesses remain are grist for counsel arguing to the jury.15 A hearsay objection that attacks the psychology of the exception, instead of its elements, therefore misses the target.
Exam questions present the doctrine in a recognizable form: a statement that opens with “Oh my God” or “Oh, no” and closes with an exclamation point.16 Those marks help you spot the exception, but the rule's own words set the test, and the same sentence can pass or fail depending on when and why it was spoken.
The difference between the two scenes lies in the speaker's state, not in the words. The later sections on stress and elapsed time ask how courts decide whether the excitement had in fact ended.
Older cases, and some student answers, invoke “res gestae,” Latin for things done, to admit statements made around the time of an event. The Federal Rules carefully avoid the term. At common law it was defined so broadly and loosely that its main effect was to forestall rational analysis of whether a challenged hearsay statement should come in, and Professor Morgan counted seven distinct concepts packed inside it.17 One thing the term can mean is not an exception at all. Out-of-court utterances that themselves carry legal significance, such as words forming a contract or a gift, or that are offered for a purpose that does not depend on the speaker's credibility, are not hearsay in the first place.18 For every other statement, the proponent must find a home in a specific rule. Name Rule 803(2), or whichever exception applies, and walk through its requirements.