Concept
Why the Exception Exists
Past recollection recorded
The Recorded Recollection Exception
Why the Exception Exists
A witness takes the stand to describe a collision, and the details have faded. Months ago, while the event was fresh, she wrote down what she saw, and the proponent now wants the jury to hear that account. Federal Rule of Evidence 803(5) allows it, but only for a record that meets three conditions:1
- The record is on a matter the witness once knew about but now cannot recall well enough to testify fully and accurately.2
- The witness made or adopted the record when the matter was fresh in the witness’s memory.3
- The record accurately reflects the witness’s knowledge.4
Those conditions raise a question: why does a system that distrusts out-of-court accounts make room for this one?
The writing is hearsay, and hearsay carries a recognized cost. Dayan v. McDonald's Corp. upheld the admission of portions of the huissiers’ reports as past recollection recorded, and it named that cost: “the inherent testimonial infirmities of hearsay occasioned by the inability of the opposing party to effectively cross-examine.”5 The court accepted the cost because a recorded recollection prepared at or near the time of the event, while the witness had a clear and accurate memory of it, carries circumstantial guarantees of trustworthiness. In its words, the reliability of that evidence is “perceived to outweigh” the infirmities.6
Two justifications support that trade. The first is need. A witness who cannot testify fully and accurately leaves the jury without information she once had.7 The second is superiority. Demby v. State puts it this way: “a contemporaneous record is inherently superior to a later recollection subject to the fallibility of human memory.”8 The Advisory Committee Note finds the guarantee of trustworthiness in the same place, in the reliability inherent in a record made while events were still fresh in mind and accurately reflecting them.9
The witness’s presence narrows the cost of admitting the record. She can describe when and how she made it, and the opposing party can question her about it. How sharply that questioning bites depends on the witness, because the usual picture of a cooperative witness on direct and a hostile one on cross does not always hold.10 Many witnesses have no strong allegiance to either party, and a party sometimes must call a hostile witness or finds itself cross-examining a friendly one.11 The opponent still cannot probe a memory that has faded, so the record’s freshness and accuracy carry the weight.
One condition looks out of place. If freshness and accuracy supply the trustworthiness, a failing memory adds nothing to a record’s reliability, and the rule could admit fresh, accurate records from witnesses who remember the event perfectly well. The Advisory Committee Note explains why it does not: without the condition, the exception would encourage statements carefully prepared for litigation under the supervision of attorneys, investigators, or claim adjusters.12 The rule therefore requires that the witness lack sufficient recollection to testify fully and accurately, and that has been the position of the federal courts.13 A witness who remembers the event testifies to it directly, and the exception stays reserved for the witness who cannot.
Every condition is phrased in terms of “the witness,” who once knew the matter and now cannot recall it well enough to testify. That wording builds in the premise that the author is present and testifying. Zenith Radio Corp. v. Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Ltd. read the rule that way, concluding that it reaches only the recorded recollection of a witness who is present and testifies, not that of an absent declarant.
Once the foundation is laid, the record itself is the evidence. An admitted record may be read into evidence, but it may be received as an exhibit only if an adverse party offers it.14 Because the witness usually reads the memorandum to the court or jury before it is admitted, putting the writing itself in evidence adds little or nothing. One court preferred to say that its admission is no error at all, rather than error that does no harm.15
The sections that follow take the conditions in turn: the witness’s prior knowledge, her insufficient present memory, the freshness of the record and its adoption by the witness, the proof of accuracy, and the limits on how the record reaches the jury.