Concept
Purpose of the Exception
Business records
Business Records Exception
Purpose of the Exception
Rule 803(6) removes a record of an act, event, condition, opinion, or diagnosis from the hearsay bar when the record meets conditions about how it was made and kept.1 The need for the rule is plain. A ledger page, an invoice, or a computer log offered to prove what it recites is an out-of-court statement offered for its truth, so without an exception it would be excluded. The rule answers with foundation requirements covering the source of the information, the regularly conducted activity that produced the record, and the proof of those facts. It also lets the opponent defeat an otherwise qualified record by showing that it is untrustworthy. Later sections take those pieces one at a time. This section asks why the law relaxes the hearsay bar for this kind of statement at all.
The first answer is scale. In Palmer v. Hoffman, the Court quoted a Senate report describing a criminal case in which the Government could not make out a prima facie case. A ruling had barred entries in a bank's books, made in the regular course of business, unless the specific bookkeeper who made the entry could identify it. The bank employed eighteen bookkeepers, and bookkeeping machines made the entries, so identification was impossible.2 The report called such proof exceedingly difficult, if not impossible, for an institution with a large bookkeeping staff.3 A composite record presents the same problem. A clothing store's statement of current inventory is built from many underlying entries, yet the witness who authenticates it need not have personal knowledge of each transaction. That witness must know the store's record-keeping procedures well enough to confirm that each entry behind the statement was made in the regular course of business.4
The common-law rule demanded far more. The record maker and each human link in the chain of information had to testify, if living and competent, that the entry was made in the regular course of business. If a necessary witness was incompetent or absent from the jurisdiction at trial, other witnesses had to identify the record and explain how and by whom it was kept.5 Courts came to see the cost. Calling a series of participants only to hear that the record did not refresh their memory, or to hear rote testimony that it was their practice to be accurate, wasted the court's time and disrupted the business with no corresponding benefit. The record's reliability could be shown by evidence other than the participants' testimony, as courts had already done when a participant could not be found. Unavailability as a requirement therefore virtually disappeared, and Rule 803(6) does not require it.6
Dropping the testimony requirement is safe because routine entries carry their own assurance, and the explanations for that assurance reinforce one another. The business relies on its books to run its affairs, so it has a financial interest in keeping them accurate.7 The person who makes an entry has a duty to be accurate as part of a continuing job or occupation. Regularity and continuity build habits of precision, systematic checking catches errors, and the business's actual experience in relying on the records confirms their value.8 The presumption of trustworthiness attaches to a particular sort of record: one regularly made during the ordinary activities of the business by someone with knowledge of the event, at the time of the event.9 A one-off statement about a disputed event has none of this support. No routine produces it, no regular checking tests it, and its writer may care more about winning than about accuracy.
State v. Acquisto shows the foundation at work. The court applied the standards of Rule 803(6) and held the foundation for the payroll exhibits adequate. Mrs. Judge, the custodian, was responsible for administering payroll. The claims for payment submitted by the two senior companions and approved by their supervisor were the kind of information on which her payroll records and authorization for payment were based. That is the familiar situation in which a custodian makes entries on information supplied by others.10
Recorded recollection under Rule 803(5) works on a different logic, and the two exceptions should not be confused. It requires a witness who once had personal knowledge of the matter, who made or adopted the record when it was fresh in memory, and who now cannot recall well enough to testify fully and accurately.11 The business-records exception asks neither whether the entrant remembers nor whether the entrant can be found.
A stem that hands you a business's own writing is asking whether the writing belongs to the routine. A document does not become a business record merely because a business wrote it.