Concept
Unavailability First
Former testimony; depositions
Unavailability First
No exception in Rule 804(b) opens until the proponent shows that the declarant is unavailable, and Rule 804(a) defines what that means.1 The Rule supplies a list, not a standard. A declarant is unavailable if the court rules that a privilege exempts the declarant from testifying about the subject matter; if the declarant refuses to testify about it despite a court order; if the declarant testifies to not remembering it; if death or a then-existing infirmity, physical illness, or mental illness keeps the declarant from being present or testifying; or if the declarant is absent and the proponent cannot procure attendance by process or other reasonable means.2
The list shares one idea. The Rule asks whether the declarant's testimony can be obtained, and it does not ask whether the declarant's body can be found.3 A declarant seated in the courtroom is unavailable if she cannot remember, refuses to testify, or successfully claims a privilege. A declarant who is merely elsewhere is not unavailable if reasonable means could bring her in.4 The reason lies in what Rule 804 is: hearsay admitted in place of a witness who cannot be had, with live testimony preferred whenever it can be obtained.5
Some grounds have soft edges. A declarant may be only temporarily absent or ill, and a prosecutor may have been able to secure a witness's presence but failed to take the step that would have done it. In criminal cases, unavailability also carries a constitutional dimension.6
The subsections below start with the declarant who is in the courthouse but will not give usable testimony. They move to the declarant who is dead or too ill to appear, then to the declarant who is absent and must be sought, and they end with the limit that follows every ground: a proponent cannot rely on unavailability that he created to keep the declarant off the stand.7 Proving unavailability only opens the door. Former testimony must still satisfy its own elements, which the later sections take up.
Present but Not Testifying
Three grounds reach a declarant who may be sitting in the courthouse: a ruling that a privilege exempts the declarant from testifying about the subject matter, a refusal to testify about it despite a court order, and testimony that the declarant does not remember it.8 In each, the declarant can be reached, but the testimony cannot be extracted. Each also demands that something happen in court: a ruling, an order followed by defiance, or sworn testimony of forgetfulness. A lawyer's prediction that the event would occur does not stand in for the event.
Under Rule 804(a)(1), the court must rule that a privilege applies, and the privilege against self-incrimination is the usual example.9 The ordinary sequence is that the declarant is called, claims the privilege, and the court sustains the claim. A party generally cannot skip those steps by representing that the declarant would claim a privilege if called.10 The ruling carries the weight because a claim is only an assertion. Until the judge decides that the privilege covers the questions, the proponent has not shown that the testimony is out of reach.
United States v. Salerno supplies the model. The defendants subpoenaed DeMatteis and Bruno in the hope that they would repeat the exculpatory testimony they had given a grand jury. Both invoked the Fifth Amendment and refused to testify, and the defendants asked the district court to admit the grand jury transcripts under the former testimony exception in Rule 804(b)(1).11 The parties agreed that the two were unavailable under Rule 804(a)(1), provided they had properly invoked the privilege and refused to testify.12
That concession cleared only the first hurdle. The Court held that the defendants had no right to introduce the grand jury testimony under Rule 804(b)(1) without showing a similar motive, and it declined to alter the evidentiary rules because litigants might prefer different ones.13 The similar-motive requirement is taken up below. For now the point is that satisfying Rule 804(a)(1) did nothing toward satisfying Rule 804(b)(1).
Exam facts often tell you that counsel is sure a co-participant would take the Fifth if called, and then offer her testimony from an earlier proceeding. The tempting answer is that she is unavailable. The better analysis notices that nobody has called her, no privilege has been claimed, and no judge has ruled, so Rule 804(a)(1) is not yet met. One setting relaxes the sequence. When one defendant offers another's statement as a declaration against interest, the declarant's privilege against self-incrimination entitles him not even to be called as a witness, and he may be treated as unavailable without a ruling from the stand.14
The second ground covers a declarant who refuses to testify about the subject matter despite a court order to do so.15 This witness has no privilege to claim and simply will not answer. The Rule contemplates an actual refusal on the stand, where the declarant declines to answer and does not cooperate when ordered to. An effort to secure cooperation is essential, and the Rule contemplates a threat of contempt.16 The sequence matters because testimony stays obtainable until compulsion has failed. A witness who tells counsel in the hallway that she will say nothing has not yet defied an order. A witness who still refuses after all appropriate judicial pressure is practically and legally unavailable.17
The third ground applies when the declarant testifies to not remembering the subject matter.18 The verb is testifies. The declarant must be sworn as a witness and cross-examined to show that she can no longer remember the matter, and only then may her statement come in under Rule 804(b).19 Lost memory is a claim that only the witness can make, so the Rule requires that she make it under oath, where the opponent can test it. If the claim proves false, the witness is subject to contempt, though perhaps less effectively than in a case of simple refusal.20
The forgotten material must be the subject matter of the earlier statement. In United States v. DiCaro, Brown had described a robbery to a grand jury, but at trial he testified that he could not remember it. The robbery was the subject matter of his grand jury testimony, so he was unavailable at trial.21 Where the forgetfulness is only partial, the sensible course is to take the witness's present testimony to the extent of her recollection and supplement it with the hearsay only for the remainder.22
The contradictory witness belongs on the available side of the line because the testimony has been obtained. A declarant who now tells a different or contrary story has never counted as unavailable.23 The proponent's remedy lies elsewhere. Former testimony can be used to impeach a witness with a prior inconsistent statement, and Rule 801(d)(1)(A) provides the basis for receiving it, so that route does not depend on Rule 804 at all.24
Death and Illness
Rule 804(a)(4) makes a declarant unavailable when death or a then-existing infirmity, physical illness, or mental illness keeps the declarant from being present or testifying at the trial or hearing.26 Death is the easy case, and determining unavailability from death has not posed problems.27 No step the proponent might have taken could produce a dead declarant, so the Rule asks for nothing beyond the fact.
The plaintiffs in Zenith Radio Corp. v. Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. relied on a declarant, Mr. Yajima, who had died in 1968, before the litigation began. The defendants conceded that death made him unavailable, and the court found any discussion of Rule 804(a)(4) unnecessary.28 The date of death did not matter. All that counted was that he could not testify at the proceeding where his statement was offered.
When unavailability is beyond dispute, the contest moves to the next hurdle. In Clay v. Johns-Manville Sales Corp., the court examined the record of an earlier case, DeRocco, and was satisfied that the defendants there had a similar motive in confronting Dr. Smith's testimony, through appropriate objections and searching cross-examination, to that of the party now opposing it.29 The elements that follow unavailability, taken up in the next sections, are usually where such cases are decided.
Illness is harder than death because of the phrase then-existing, which ties the condition to the proceeding at which the statement is offered. A minor ailment from which speedy recovery is expected should not satisfy the requirement, even if the declarant cannot attend on a given day, because the proceedings can be adjourned to allow time for recovery. A serious illness of uncertain prognosis is likely to be enough.30 The logic follows from the preference for live testimony. A witness who will recover in time is delayed, not unobtainable, and live testimony is preferred when it can be had.31 For that reason, temporary absence or illness is one of the soft-edged grounds.32
The Rule's wording reaches mental as well as physical conditions, and it speaks of a declarant who cannot be present or testify. A declarant who could be wheeled into court but whose mental condition prevents usable testimony is as unobtainable as one confined to a hospital bed. The condition that counts is the one existing at the proceeding where the statement is now offered. A declarant who was sick when the earlier testimony was given is beside the point. A proponent who relies on a temporary condition takes the risk that the judge will prefer a short delay to a transcript.
Absent Declarant
Rule 804(a)(5) makes a declarant unavailable when the declarant is absent from the trial or hearing and the proponent has not been able, by process or other reasonable means, to procure the declarant's presence.34 The ground has two parts. Absence comes first and is rarely contested, since the witness is simply not in the courtroom. The proponent's failure to secure that presence by legitimate means is where cases turn, because it asks what the proponent actually did.
Absence alone cannot carry the showing, because live testimony is preferred if it can be obtained.35 Unavailability is not established unless the attorney tried unsuccessfully to subpoena the witness or to use other reasonable means to procure attendance.36 The proponent must demonstrate that effort to the court.37
A proponent who makes no effort fails the showing. Perricone v. Kansas City S.R.R. illustrates the failure side: the witness could readily have been located, and no subpoena had issued. A witness who is merely nearby has not become unavailable, because the proponent has not shown that process or other reasonable means could not produce him.38
The proponent who has tried and failed stands on the other side of the line. In Lloyd v. American Export Lines, Inc., the court held unavailability satisfied where Export and Lloyd's own counsel were unable to obtain Lloyd's appearance in an action in which he had a formidable interest as a plaintiff.39 If the witness's own lawyer cannot bring him in to a case he has a stake in, his opponent can hardly be faulted. The two situations share the fact of absence and differ in effort.
Rule 804(a)(5) also draws a line inside itself, and the line favors the proponent of former testimony. For a hearsay exception under Rule 804(b)(1) or (6), the proponent need show only that the declarant's attendance could not be procured.40 For dying declarations, statements against interest, and statements of personal or family history, the proponent must show that the declarant's attendance or testimony could not be procured.41 The added word matters because testimony includes a deposition. For those three exceptions, a declarant whom the proponent could have deposed has not become unavailable, even if the declarant has since moved beyond reach.42
The difference runs through cross-examination. The preference for a deposition rests largely on the opponent's opportunity to cross-examine, and a dying declaration or a statement against interest has never been cross-examined, so a deposition would add something real.43 Former testimony already carries that opportunity and is almost always preserved in a transcript, so a deposition would duplicate what the proponent already holds.44
Courts disagree about how much effort is reasonable when the witness lives beyond the court's subpoena power, and you should be ready to present both lines. In Zenith, the court held that for former testimony an inability to serve a subpoena satisfies Rule 804(a)(5), and it found no requirement that the proponent first seek the voluntary attendance of witnesses residing abroad. It called the opposite rule anomalous in a civil case, since the Supreme Court has found such a requirement inapposite under the stricter standards of criminal cases.45 It concluded that declarants of former testimony are unavailable if they are outside the court's subpoena power, even if the proponent made no effort to depose them or to request their voluntary attendance.46
Other authorities expect more. On their view, serving process is only the first step. The proponent must also try to contact and persuade the witness to attend, including by paying an expert's fee or travel costs.47 The second view gives independent work to the words other reasonable means, which the Rule places beside process. The first treats a failed subpoena as the end of the inquiry for former testimony.
On an exam, do not assume which line governs. A proponent who served process, asked the witness to attend, and offered to pay expenses satisfies both. A proponent who did nothing beyond noting an address satisfies neither unless the witness is demonstrably outside subpoena range. A criminal case adds a further constraint. Confrontation law requires a good-faith effort to obtain the witness's presence, and the Supreme Court gives constitutional scrutiny to a lower court's finding of unavailability.48
Procured Unavailability
Every ground in Rule 804(a) is subject to one qualification, found in the Rule's closing sentence: the subdivision does not apply if the statement's proponent procured or wrongfully caused the declarant's unavailability in order to prevent the declarant from attending or testifying.51 The qualification reaches the whole definition, so privilege, refusal, lack of memory, death or illness, and absence are each withdrawn from a proponent who engineered the condition. Without a showing of unavailability, no Rule 804(b) exception is open, former testimony included, however well its other elements are met.
The limit answers an incentive that Rule 804 would otherwise create. A party may prefer the hearsay to the live witness, because the declarant may communicate badly on the stand or may now say something inconsistent with the earlier statement. Such a party may think about making the witness unavailable, and the Rule disentitles the party from using the hearsay if it does.52 Without that limit, the party with the most to gain from a transcript would also be best placed to arrange the witness's disappearance.
The Rule also contains a purpose element that keeps the limit from sweeping too far. The proponent must have acted in order to keep the declarant from attending or testifying.53 Causing an absence is not enough by itself. Without the purpose requirement, any ordinary litigation decision that happened to precede a witness's departure would cost the proponent the exception. The forfeiture exception in Rule 804(b)(6) treats the same kind of misconduct from the opponent's side, and the provision discussed here takes the benefit away from the proponent who engineers the absence.54
The owner loses at the first hurdle, which is why the strength of the other elements cannot rescue the offer. The result would differ if the owner had merely done too little. A proponent who never subpoenaed a nearby witness or tried other reasonable means has procured nothing. That proponent has failed to show that attendance could not be obtained, and the offer fails on the absent-declarant ground.55 Procurement asks what the proponent did and why. The absent-declarant ground asks what the proponent tried and failed to do.
Passivity is a different problem from procurement. A prosecutor who could have secured a witness's presence but failed to take the step that would have done it raises the soft-edged question of whether unavailability is established at all, and in criminal cases the constitutional dimension adds scrutiny.56 That is a failure of effort. It is not procurement, which requires conduct aimed at preventing the declarant from attending or testifying.
On an exam, procurement appears when the stem gives the proponent a motive to avoid the live witness and an act aimed at removing that witness. A stem that offers only a missed opportunity, a refused favor, or a routine litigation choice does not describe procurement.