Concept
Analyzing a Problem
Statements against interest
Analyzing a Problem
A statement-against-interest problem is solved by running the rule's conditions in sequence, because each condition screens out a different kind of weak statement. Rule 804(b)(3) admits a statement that a reasonable person in the declarant's position would have made only if believing it true, because when made it was so contrary to the declarant's proprietary or pecuniary interest, so tended to invalidate the declarant's claim against someone else, or so tended to expose the declarant to civil or criminal liability.1 In a criminal case, a statement that tends to expose the declarant to criminal liability must also be supported by corroborating circumstances that clearly indicate its trustworthiness, judged on the totality of circumstances and any evidence that supports or undermines it.2 Three more requirements surround those provisions: unavailability under Rule 804(a), the reading of a narrative remark by remark that Williamson requires, and the Confrontation Clause. That makes five stages, and this section arranges them in the order a court takes them.
The order runs from the cheapest question to the one that needs the fullest record. Rule 804's first preference is for the declarant to appear and testify, so the court first asks whether the declarant is unavailable under Rule 804(a).3 Next comes the cost of the statement to the declarant when made, which usually can be answered from the statement and its setting. The later questions need more of the record: whether each remark inside a longer narrative was itself self-inculpatory, whether independent circumstances corroborate the account, and whether the statement is testimonial. Admissibility under Rule 804(b)(3) is a preliminary question for the judge under Rule 104(a). Because the answer depends heavily on the circumstances of the particular case, the district judge, who is close to the facts, has wide discretion.4 The Confrontation Clause comes last because it applies its own test, whether the statement is testimonial, whatever the hearsay analysis concluded.5
The five stages, in order, are these:
The stages do not all apply to every problem. A civil case never reaches the fourth or fifth stage, because the corroboration requirement is written for statements offered in a criminal case and the Confrontation Clause protects an accused. Even in a criminal case, the fourth stage applies only when the statement tends to expose the declarant to criminal liability, so an admission of a debt skips it.11
The dispute between Duran and Baez over Duran's belts shows the stages working on a statement that survives. Over Baez's objection, the trial court let Duran and some of his family members testify that Iglesias had apologized in their presence for stealing the belts, reasoning that the apology described an existing state of mind under Rule 803(3).12 Duran had also offered the testimony as a statement against interest by a declarant unavailable at trial. The court of appeals reached that alternative ground, because it would not find an abuse of discretion where the trial court reached the correct result, even if for the wrong reason.13 It held that the part of the apology in which Iglesias admitted stealing the belts was a statement against interest, because it would subject him to civil or criminal liability.14 The court's attention to that part of the apology is the remark-by-remark stage in its simplest form. The dispute was between private claimants, so no accused was confronted and the corroboration requirement for criminal cases was not in play.
Harris's confession in Williamson fails at the stage the belts apology passed easily. Some of Harris's confession would clearly have been admissible,15 but his statements to an agent after his arrest that the drugs belonged to the defendant and that he was only carrying them for the defendant pointed at someone else. Remarks of that kind do little to expose the speaker and may help him, so they are not against his penal interest. The inquiry in such a case turns on what he said and why he said it, not on the fact that he spoke to the police.16 What separates the two confessions is the cost of each remark to the speaker. Iglesias's admission of theft put his own wrongdoing on the line, while Harris's accusations moved responsibility elsewhere.
Ellen's statements in Illustration (1) fail twice. She made them to a law enforcement official after agreeing to testify against Harvey, which suggests she may have been currying favor, and she appears to have tried to shift most of the blame to him. On that analysis her declarations are inadmissible because they are not sufficiently disserving to her interest.17 They also fail at the fifth stage, because statements made to law enforcement that implicate the accused are testimonial and violate both the hearsay rule under Williamson and the Confrontation Clause under Crawford.18 Changing the listener changes the analysis. Had Ellen said the same things to a friend, the interrogation setting that makes a statement testimonial would be gone, and so would the circumstances suggesting she was currying favor. The remark-by-remark and corroboration stages would still have to be run on what she actually said.