Concept
Electronic Compilations
Market reports and similar commercial publications
Electronic Compilations
Rule 803(17) defines its coverage by function: "[m]arket quotations, lists, directories, or other compilations that are generally relied on by the public or by persons in particular occupations." Nothing in that language mentions paper.1 Rule 101(b)(6) supplies the link: a reference to written material includes material in electronic form, so a compilation posted on a website is treated like a printed one.2 Courts have applied the exception to commercial websites that furnish interest rates and Blue Book prices for used cars, and the reasoning reaches the exception's traditional contents as well: tables of stock, bond, and currency prices, real estate listings, and telephone books.3 The medium changes how a page reaches the courtroom. It does not change the test the page must meet once it arrives.
A web page offered in court raises three distinct questions, and students tend to run them together. Each question guards against a different risk, so a page can satisfy one and fail another. Ask them in order and answer them separately.
The first question raises no hearsay problem. A witness who logged on and reports what appeared on the screen describes the witness's own perception of the page, and nothing in that testimony asks the factfinder to believe what the page says. The difficulty begins when the proponent wants the court to accept the content as true, because every out-of-court statement drawn from a website must satisfy a hearsay exception or exemption when it is offered for its truth.7
Authentication and hearsay stay separate because they ask different things. Authentication asks whether the exhibit is what it purports to be. Hearsay asks whether the assertion inside the exhibit may be believed without the person who made it on the stand. A page can be perfectly authentic and still need an exception, as when a witness proves that a page really appeared on a site but the proponent offers its contents for their truth. A proponent who clears one gate has not cleared the other.
The exception treats a website like a printed page because it turns on how a compilation functions in the world. The source of a published compilation usually has an incentive to be accurate, and those who rely on the data are likely to detect falsity. That combination of a disinterested source and public or occupational reliance is what justifies the exception, and it is indifferent to whether the figures arrive on paper or on a screen.8
Not every page on a commercial website is a market report, because the exception attaches to the kind of compilation and not to the fact that the page is online.
Both pages are authentic and both came from a website, so the third question separates them. The Blue Book table has a disinterested publisher and an audience of dealers and lenders who would notice a wrong value. The seller's feature list has an interested author and readers who are prospective buyers, not checkers of the figures. A different doctrine would govern if the buyer offered the same page against the seller: a statement by a corporation's agent, offered against the corporation, is exempt from the definition of hearsay under Rule 801(d)(2), as an agent's email would be.9
A related boundary concerns an organization's own documents posted on its site. If website data constitute business or public records, they are tested under the records exceptions and not as published compilations, and they do not lose that character because the printout offered in court was generated for litigation.10 The sorting question is what the document is. A county office's posted payment records are the office's own regularly kept records. A third party's published table of mortgage rates is a reference compilation relied on by an outside audience. The later comparison of the nearby exceptions develops that contrast.