Concept
Admissible but Not Conclusive
Market reports and similar commercial publications
Admissible but Not Conclusive
A compilation that satisfies Rule 803(17) gets in, and getting in is all it gets. The rule reaches "[m]arket quotations, lists, directories, or other compilations that are generally relied on by the public or by persons in particular occupations," and it says nothing about whether the figures inside a qualifying compilation must be believed.1 Qualifying removes the hearsay objection, and the compilation comes in as evidence of the facts it reports. Whether a particular figure is right stays open. The opponent may challenge the accuracy of the compilation, and admission is not conclusive as to the accuracy of the reported data.2
Two questions arise whenever a compilation is offered, and the exception answers only the first. The first is whether the factfinder may hear the compilation at all, which turns on whether it falls within the exception. The second is how much the factfinder should rely on what it hears, a matter of weight, meaning the persuasive force the evidence carries once it is in the record. The exception can settle the first question without the second because of what it rests on. It rests on a generalization: a disinterested publisher has every reason to be accurate, and an audience that uses the figures will notice falsity.3 A generalization describes what is usual, and a particular page can depart from it. A misprint, a stale table, or a figure from the wrong market can survive in a publication that is dependable overall. If admission were conclusive, that one bad entry would bind the factfinder even against records showing the true figure, and a presumption of dependability would harden into proof. Leaving accuracy open lets the compilation serve as a starting point that contrary evidence can move.
The quotation did its work by getting past the hearsay objection, and the seller's records did theirs by competing on the merits. Neither side's evidence ended the dispute, because the factfinder resolves the conflict. The opposite instinct is the one to watch for on an exam. A proponent who argues that a directory admitted under Rule 803(17) establishes the address it lists has treated admission as a finding. Admission settled the hearsay objection and nothing more. The entry remains one item of evidence about where the person lived, and anything the opponent offers to the contrary goes to the factfinder alongside it.
Two neighboring exceptions show what Rule 803(17) leaves out. The business-records exception admits a record only if "the opponent does not show that the source of information or the method or circumstances of preparation indicate a lack of trustworthiness."4 The public-records exception sets a parallel condition: "the opponent does not show that the source of information or other circumstances indicate a lack of trustworthiness."5 In each of those rules the opponent can defeat admission by making the showing the clause describes. Rule 803(17) has no clause of that kind. Its text names the compilations, states the general-reliance condition, and ends there.6
With no trustworthiness clause to invoke, an opponent must fit an attack on accuracy to the parts of the rule that do exist. The general-reliance condition already screens for reliability, since it asks whether an audience depends on the publication for the kind of fact offered, and the opponent may contest it. Whatever accuracy challenge remains goes to weight. The sorting is easiest to run as a short sequence.
The third step is where contrary trade records, a published correction, or proof of a misprint do their work. None of them needs a trustworthiness clause, because a factfinder weighs competing evidence on any fact in dispute. The first two steps explain why a proponent must still prove reliance after the hearsay objection has been answered.