Concept
The Rule 803(19) Exception
Reputation concerning personal or family history
The Rule 803(19) Exception
Rule 803(19) admits "[a] reputation among a person's family by blood, adoption, or marriage—or among a person's associates or in the community—concerning the person's birth, adoption, legitimacy, ancestry, marriage, divorce, death, relationship by blood, adoption, or marriage, or similar facts of personal or family history."1 Two clauses do the work. The first names the circles of people whose shared belief counts as a reputation; the second lists the facts that belief may concern.
Reputation evidence is older than the hearsay rule itself. When the general doctrine excluding hearsay began to take form in the late 1600s, reputation was already so well established in certain areas that exceptions for those areas were soon recognized.2 Rule 803(19) is one of the well-developed reputation exceptions in the Federal Rules.3 It sits in Rule 803, whose exceptions apply regardless of whether the declarant is available as a witness, so it carries no unavailability requirement.4
The subsections below take these questions in turn, beginning with the circles of people whose reputation the rule recognizes.
Who Holds the Reputation
The first question is whose belief the witness describes. The rule names three circles: the person's family by blood, adoption, or marriage; the person's associates; and the community.5 Relevant reputation may therefore come from within the family, from within the community, or from associates who know the person.6 The circle matters because it identifies the people whose repeated talk, and whose power to correct one another, gives a reputation its worth.
Family is the narrowest circle. Relatives live with the facts of births, marriages, and kinship, and a belief that has settled among them has been repeated before people able to contradict it. The rule defines the family broadly, covering blood, adoption, and marriage, so a reputation among a person's in-laws or adoptive relatives counts as much as one among siblings.7
The federal text names associates and the community in the same sentence as the family, so a proponent need not stretch the family circle to reach them.8 The broader circles rest on the same logic. People who see a person regularly hear, repeat, and sometimes dispute what is said about that person's history, whether or not they are kin.
Associates are the people who deal with a person regularly outside the family: coworkers, business colleagues, and fellow members of a club or congregation.
The community is the widest circle. In the standard illustration, a witness testifies that the reputation throughout the village is that she was Bert Grant's illegitimate daughter.9 The community must be one in which the person lived or was known, because a town that never heard of the person has no reputation to report.
Whatever the circle, the witness must describe what the group believes, not what one member said. The exception requires reputation among family members or members of the community, and an individual's bare assertion does not qualify.10
The cousin's testimony may still have a route in. A relative's statement about family history can qualify under Rule 804(b)(4), which, unlike the reputation exception, covers an unavailable declarant's statement.11 Whether the testimony reports a group's belief or one declarant's statement therefore decides which exception applies. The section on related family-history exceptions takes up the single-declarant side.
Covered Subject Matter
Once the circle is settled, the next question is what that circle's reputation may be about. Rule 803(19) answers with a list (birth, adoption, legitimacy, ancestry, marriage, divorce, death, and relationship by blood, adoption, or marriage) followed by a catch-all for "similar facts of personal or family history."13 The list falls into three groups, a grouping that helps in remembering it and in testing an unlisted fact:
- Origin facts (birth, adoption, legitimacy, and ancestry) describe how a person came to belong to a family.
- Status facts (marriage, divorce, and death) describe milestones that change a person's legal and family condition.
- Relationship facts (relationship by blood, adoption, or marriage) describe the connection between one person and another.
Families and communities announce, discuss, and remember these things. A wedding or an adoption is talked over for years, so a settled belief about it has passed before many people able to correct it. The theory offered for the family-history exceptions fits: statements about family history are likely to be either accurate or corrected when they are made where others can inspect them and regard them as important.14
The closing phrase, "similar facts of personal or family history," takes its meaning from the items before it.15 A court asked to admit reputation about an unlisted fact therefore compares it with the listed ones: is it a milestone in family life or a link between two people? A reputation that a relative was a gifted musician or drove hard bargains concerns the details of a life, not a milestone or a kinship fact, and it resembles nothing on the list.
Death appears in both family-history exceptions, but not in the same way. Rule 803(19) lists death as a subject of reputation without qualification.16 Rule 804(b)(4), which governs an individual declarant's statement, covers the declarant's own birth, adoption, legitimacy, ancestry, marriage, divorce, and family relationships, and it adds death only for statements about another person made by a relative or by someone closely associated with the family.17 A declarant cannot report his own death as a completed fact, so the omission follows from the subject. A death can therefore be proved by group reputation under Rule 803(19), but by an individual's statement under Rule 804(b)(4) only when the statement concerns someone else.
The neighboring reputation exceptions cover other subjects. Rule 803(20) reaches boundaries and general history, and Rule 803(21) reaches personal character; the character rule is what allows reputational proof of character for certain substantive and credibility purposes.18 Character testimony is likewise built on what others say,19 but the rules treat it as its own category with its own subject. One witness can therefore give testimony that sits partly inside one exception and partly outside it.
Reputation about land boundaries and general history concerns the community's shared knowledge of a place or an event, not a family's knowledge of its own milestones. A matter of general history must be one of general interest, so that it probably underwent general scrutiny as the community reputation formed. When the navigability of a river was at issue, for example, newspaper accounts and histories describing its use during the nineteenth century were admissible to prove its reputation for navigability.20
Statute or local law also sometimes admits reputation to prove miscellaneous matters such as ownership of property, financial standing, and the maintenance of a house as an establishment for liquor-selling or prostitution.21 Those matters draw their authority from outside Rule 803(19), which is why wealth and property ownership do not ride in on the family-history exception merely because a family is involved.
Foundation for Reputation Testimony
The word reputation in Rule 803(19) sets the foundation a witness must lay.23 A reputation is a composite of what many people have said, so the witness relays a generalized version of many out-of-court statements. The witness's job is to summarize what the group says. That job yields two requirements that students often run together: the witness must know the reputation, and the witness need not know the fact the reputation reports.
The first requirement is personal knowledge of the reputation, which means the witness has been part of the family, workplace, or community circle where the reputation circulated.24 The court cannot question the many people whose talk produced the reputation, so the witness's contact with them is the only assurance that the testimony reflects a real group belief and not a single voice, a stray rumor, or the witness's guess. A person who has lived among the family, worked beside the associates, or joined in the community's conversation has heard the matter raised repeatedly and can say what the circle generally holds. A person who never heard the talk has nothing to summarize.
The second requirement follows from the first. The personal-knowledge requirement attaches to the reputation, not to the birth, marriage, or relationship it reports.25 A person usually learns kinship facts only from what others say, so a demand for firsthand knowledge would exclude nearly every witness the exception exists to admit. The rule tests the witness's knowledge of the reputation and leaves the reliability of the reputed fact to the many people whose scrutiny shaped it. A witness who describes what was commonly understood in the witness's own household can therefore testify even if the witness learned it from conversations with parents.26
The forty-year resident and the newcomer know equally little about Mae's birth. What separates them is whether either has heard the village talk. The newcomer's belief cannot qualify however sincerely it is held, because the exception requires reputation among the family or community and does not reach individual assertions.27 The same defect appears when a witness knows only what one relative once said. That is one declarant's statement, and it belongs, if anywhere, under the individual-declarant exception discussed below.
Courts have policed the qualifications of reputation witnesses most often in character cases, and one such decision offers a comparison if the difference in subject stays in view. In Michelson v. United States, a criminal defendant called witnesses to his good reputation. The Court explained that such a witness may summarize what has been heard in the community but may not testify to specific acts or give an independent opinion drawn from personal observation.28 The witness must also show enough acquaintance with the defendant, and with the community and circles in which he moved, to speak with authority about how he is generally regarded. A witness who has "heard nothing against" the defendant qualifies only if his knowledge of the defendant's surroundings is intimate enough that silence means no rumors were afloat.29 Both ideas carry over to family history: the witness reports the circle's belief, and the witness's acquaintance with the circle is what makes the report worth hearing. A witness who says no one ever questioned the family's account deserves the same scrutiny of how closely the witness stayed in touch with the circle. Michelson concerned character reputation, which Rule 803(21) now covers,30 and it decides nothing about family history, so it serves only as an analogy.
An objection that the witness never saw the birth or the wedding misreads the exception. The objection that works is that the witness never heard the family's or community's talk, because that witness has no reputation to report.
Availability and Timing Issues
Rule 803(19) sets two conditions on its face: the reputation must be held among the person's family, associates, or community, and it must concern a listed fact of personal or family history.32 The text contains no requirement that the people behind the reputation be unavailable and none that the reputation have formed before the dispute began. Students tend to import both conditions from neighboring doctrines, because the individual-declarant exception for family history demands unavailability and the boundary exception demands a pre-dispute origin. This section takes the two features in turn.
Rule 803 lists exceptions that apply "regardless of whether the declarant is available as a witness."33 That lead-in settles the availability question: a proponent offering reputation need not show that anyone is dead, absent, or ill. Rule 804 works differently. The proponent must first establish that the declarant is unavailable and then fit the statement into one of five exceptions, one of which is the declaration of personal or family history in Rule 804(b)(4).34 The theory behind that requirement is that the declarant's live testimony is better than the hearsay, but the hearsay is better than nothing from that declarant at all.35
That preference for live testimony presupposes a particular person the proponent could have produced instead, and reputation has no such person. It is a composite of what many speakers, most of them unidentifiable, have said over the years, so there is no single declarant whose absence the proponent could prove and no community that could be brought to the stand. A demand for unavailability would be impossible to satisfy and would protect nothing, since a reputation draws its reliability from the group's scrutiny and not from any one speaker.
The timing question has a similar answer, but the contrast comes from a different neighbor. Rule 803(20) admits community reputation about land boundaries and customs affecting the land only if it arose before the controversy.36 The evident concern is that a boundary reputation formed after a dispute began may simply echo the dispute, since the people discussing where a line runs are often the owners and neighbors with a stake in the answer. The drafters knew how to write a timing limit when they wanted one, and they left it out of Rule 803(19). A family-history reputation that formed late is therefore not excluded on that ground alone.
Late formation still matters, but as an argument about weight. A reputation about a marriage or a parentage ordinarily forms over years of family conversation, long before anyone opens an estate. When it forms late, the opponent can prove that fact and argue it to the jury and, in an extreme case, can ask the judge to exclude the evidence under Rule 403.
Admissibility under Rule 803(19) does not end the contest. The opponent can cross-examine the reputation witness about when the reputation arose, who first spread it, and whether the people repeating it stood to gain from the claim. An objection that family members are available, or that the reputation is too recent, is therefore not a hearsay bar. The objections that can defeat the testimony at the threshold are the ones the text supplies: the wrong circle, a subject outside the list, or a witness who never heard the reputation.