Concept
Reputation as Hearsay
Reputation concerning boundaries or general history
Boundary and History Reputation
Reputation as Hearsay
A witness who says that everyone in the area has always understood a boundary to run along a certain creek is not describing anything the witness saw. The witness is passing along what many neighbors have said over the years, and that makes the testimony hearsay. Federal Rule of Evidence 803(20) supplies the exception: "A reputation in a community—arising before the controversy—concerning boundaries of land in the community or customs that affect the land, or concerning general historical events important to that community, state, or nation."1
Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of what it asserts, and a reputation is the pooled product of many such statements. Each neighbor who ever said "the line is at the creek" said it outside the courtroom, and the proponent offers the community's collective belief to prove that the line really lies there. The witness cannot trace that belief to a named speaker, so the opponent has no one to question about its source. Without an exception, the hearsay rule would keep the testimony out.
The exception sits in Rule 803, whose exceptions apply regardless of whether the declarant is available as a witness.2 That placement suits reputation evidence. A reputation has no single declarant, so the question whether "the declarant" is available has no sensible answer, and the proponent makes no unavailability showing.
The rule has three working parts, and the rest of this chapter takes them in turn:
- The evidence must be a reputation held in a community. The witness reports what many people believe and does not testify from personal observation.
- The reputation must have arisen before the controversy in which it is offered.
- The reputation must concern a covered subject: boundaries of land in the community, customs that affect the land, or general historical events important to the community, state, or nation.
When those parts are met, the rule against hearsay no longer excludes the evidence. That is all the exception does. It answers the hearsay objection and nothing more, so it does not by itself make the testimony relevant or show that the witness actually knows what the community says.