Concept
Covered Subjects
Reputation concerning boundaries or general history
Covered Subjects
Rule 803(20) admits community reputation on three subjects and no others: "boundaries of land in the community or customs that affect the land, or ... general historical events important to that community, state, or nation."1 Reputation about anything else falls outside this exception, however many people hold it and however long ago it arose. The earlier sections taught that the evidence must be a true community reputation and, for land, must predate the controversy. Subject matter is the third working part of the rule. Even a genuine, timely belief qualifies only if it concerns one of the three.
The three subjects share a profile. Each involves facts that are old, public, or spread across many people. A boundary set a century ago, a practice neighbors have followed for generations, and an event that shaped a region are facts whose eyewitnesses have usually died or moved away. Yet many people have a stake in where a line runs or what happened to their region, so the community discusses these matters repeatedly, and neighbors who remember differently correct a mistaken version. Need and dependability justify the exception as a whole, and the list confines it to the places where both are present. A proponent need not prove that every eyewitness is gone, because the Rule 803 exceptions apply "regardless of whether the declarant is available as a witness."2
That confinement does real work. If a proponent could prove any fact by showing that "everyone says so," the hearsay rule would give way whenever a few neighbors could be found to repeat a story, and cross-examination would be lost on exactly the matters where it counts. Recent private events do not fit the pattern, because the people who saw them can usually be called and questioned.
For any proposed reputation, then, ask first what it is about. The sections below take the three subjects in turn, beginning with the oldest and most familiar use: proof of where a boundary lies.
Land Boundaries
Rule 803(20) names "boundaries of land in the community," and proof of where a line between parcels runs is the use the exception fits most naturally.3 A boundary dispute asks the court to locate a line on the ground: the edge of a field, the corner of a lot, the course of a fence. The admissible evidence is the community's settled understanding of where the line lies, offered to prove that it lies there. The rule ties the land to the talk. The community whose reputation counts is the locality where the land sits, and the neighbors there are the people positioned to know the line and to discuss it.
Boundaries suit the exception because of how they come into being. A line between two parcels is usually fixed once, long before anyone quarrels over it. A surveyor sets stones, an owner plants an oak at the corner, neighbors build a wall, or everyone agrees to treat a creek as the divide. By the time a dispute reaches court, the people who chose those markers may be dead, the deeds may be lost or vague, and no living witness may have watched the line being established. Reputation is then often the best evidence left, and it is dependable on this subject. The neighbors beside the line plant, fence, graze, and sell up to it for years, they talk about it whenever a gate moves or a parcel changes hands, and a neighbor who remembers the line differently will say so.
The timing limit applies with full force. The rule places "arising before the controversy" in the same sentence as "boundaries of land."4 Boundaries show why. The neighbors whose lasting stake makes the reputation reliable are the same people who take sides once two of them sue, and talk that forms after the quarrel begins reflects the partisans' preferred line, not years of untested agreement. A proponent therefore needs the witness to show that the understanding was current before the dispute, by describing how long the talk has circulated and who repeated it. How many people repeat a version now proves nothing about when the version began, and exam stems set that trap by piling up voices after the argument starts.
A stem about a fight over a strip between two farms will turn on what the testifying neighbor actually reports.
Two facts moved the answer between those scenes. The first was breadth: the second set of witnesses reported an understanding shared across the neighborhood, while the first reported one neighbor's comment. The second was timing: the shared understanding predated the dispute, and the comment was made within it. Neither fact is enough alone. A remark made long ago by a single person is still one declarant's statement, and a broad consensus that formed after the lawsuit began is still a reputation the exception excludes.
Customs Affecting Land
Rule 803(20) names a second subject beside boundaries: a reputation in a community concerning "customs that affect the land."6 A custom in this setting is a practice that the people of a locality follow regularly and treat as the accepted way of doing something. Examples include which neighbors may cross a tract to reach a stream, where livestock may be turned out to graze, and how a shared lane is used. The words "affect the land" supply the limit. The practice must bear on how land is used, reached, or worked, so that it is tied to the ground in the community the way a boundary line is. A practice that is old, common, and well known still falls outside this subject when it has nothing to do with land.
Reputation is a natural way to prove a custom of this kind because customs of land use usually live only in the habits and talk of the people who follow them. Few appear in a deed or any record, and none has a single declarant who announced it. A neighbor learns that a tract may be crossed to reach the stream by hearing it from other neighbors and watching them cross, then repeats the same understanding to the next newcomer. When a dispute asks a court to decide whether the custom exists, the community's shared understanding is the form the proof takes, and a witness who knows that understanding can report it without naming any speaker. People who rely on a custom also discuss it often enough that a wrong version tends to be corrected.
The supper and the stream crossing have the same age and the same breadth. Both are widely held and have been repeated for years, and the single fact that separates them is the subject of the custom. The common exam error is to reason that a long-standing local custom is covered simply because it is a custom, when the rule asks whether the custom affects the land. In a closer case, the question is whether the practice concerns the use of land or access to it. Admitting the reputation removes only the hearsay objection. What the custom means for the parties' rights remains a matter for the substantive law of the case.
The pre-controversy limit applies here as it does to boundaries, because the rule's timing phrase sits ahead of both land subjects.7 The owner of a tract and the neighbors who want to keep crossing it each have something at stake, so once a gate goes up and a dispute begins, talk about what the community has always allowed tends to follow the interests of the people repeating it. A witness therefore needs to show how long the understanding has been current, as the stream witnesses did by placing it well before the dispute. A reputation that took shape only after the owner blocked the way formed inside the controversy, and the number of people now repeating it does not cure that.
General Historical Events
The third subject Rule 803(20) covers is a community's reputation "concerning general historical events important to that community, state, or nation."9 A general historical event is a happening of broad public consequence, such as an earthquake that leveled part of a city, a war that reached a region, or a flood that reshaped a river valley. The rule's wording tracks the subject closely. The reputation may be held in a community, a state, or a nation, and the event must be important to whichever of those holds the belief. The witness again serves as a conduit, reporting what people there commonly say about the event without having seen it.
The reason for admitting this proof is that events of broad public importance live on in shared memory and retelling, and by the time one matters in a lawsuit, few or no living people may have witnessed it. Those who did saw only their own corner. A person who watched one street burn cannot honestly testify from sight about how far the damage reached across a whole city, yet the extent of the damage may decide whether a particular building survived. A flat hearsay exclusion would leave the factfinder with nothing on a point that may control the case. The same feature that creates the need also supplies a check on accuracy, since an event important to a whole region is discussed by very large numbers of people over many years, and others' memories tend to correct a wrong version. A widely held belief about such an event is usually as good as proof gets.
The foundation still matters, as it does for every reputation. The witness must be positioned to know what people in the region say, through long residence there or through familiarity with how the event is spoken of. A witness who simply announces that "everyone knows" has offered a conclusion with nothing behind it. The earthquake testimony also shows how the relevant community scales with the subject. The event mattered to northern California as a whole, so the community is the region, and a belief held across that area has been tested against the recollections of a very large number of people.
The limit the rule itself imposes is that the event must be of general importance to the community, state, or nation. An exam question will test it by offering talk that is widely repeated but concerns something small.
The two scenes differ in what the event is, and breadth of belief does not close the gap. The test looks to the event's importance to the community, state, or nation that holds the reputation, which is why a regional earthquake qualifies and a single burglary does not. An event can be local and still qualify when it belongs to the shared history of that locality. The question is whether the community treats it as part of its own story or as a private episode that merely got talked about.
The pre-controversy requirement needs care on this subject. The rule's text places "arising before the controversy" ahead of the whole list of subjects10 and does not say in so many words which subjects it governs. A common reading applies the requirement to reputation about land and imposes none on reputation about general history. The reasoning is that a land dispute gives neighbors a reason to shade their stories once they take sides, while the memory of a regional earthquake is rarely shaped by anyone's private lawsuit. That reading is an interpretation and not the text, so state it as one. A proponent who can show that the belief was current before the dispute loses nothing by saying so.