Concept
Related Routes to Proof
Reputation concerning boundaries or general history
Related Routes to Proof
Rule 803(20) admits a reputation in a community, “arising before the controversy,” concerning “boundaries of land in the community or customs that affect the land, or concerning general historical events important to that community, state, or nation.”1 That list of subjects marks the edge of the exception, and other provisions of Rule 803 pick up where it stops. A witness who says “everyone in town says so” may not be relying on Rule 803(20) at all. The question that sorts the problem is what the talk is about.
Five neighboring routes matter on an exam:
- Rule 803(19) admits reputation about personal and family history.
- Rule 803(21) admits reputation about a person’s character.
- Rule 803(23) admits a judgment on boundaries or history when the matter was essential to it.
- Rules 803(16) and 803(15) admit statements in certain documents.
- Judicial notice, treated in its own topic, may establish a fact with no hearsay exception at all.
The four hearsay routes share a purpose with Rule 803(20): each lets a party prove a fact from a settled view, a court’s decision, or an old record when no eyewitness may be available. Because they share a purpose but not conditions, they are easy to confuse. A proponent who cites Rule 803(20) for a reputation about a person’s marriage has named a rule that does not cover the evidence, and a proponent who forgets the alternatives may give up proof that another route would have admitted. The closest neighbor comes first.
Family History Reputation
Rule 803(19) admits “a reputation among a person’s family by blood, adoption, or marriage—or among a person’s associates or in the community—concerning the person’s birth, adoption, legitimacy, ancestry, marriage, divorce, death, relationship by blood, adoption, or marriage, or similar facts of personal or family history.”2 Rule 803(20), by comparison, reaches only a reputation “in a community” about land boundaries, land customs, or general historical events.3 Both sit among the exceptions that apply whether or not the declarant is available as a witness, so neither requires a showing of unavailability.4 What separates them is the subject. Facts about one person’s life and family belong to Rule 803(19), and facts about land and a place’s shared history belong to Rule 803(20).
Each rule pairs a subject with the people who talk about it. Who is whose child, who married whom, and who died when are matters that relatives and close friends discuss among themselves, so Rule 803(19) counts a reputation held in the family, among associates, or in the community. Family history has long been provable by reputation in the family and sometimes in the community, and the federal rule carries that pattern forward.5 Where a line runs, or what a flood did to a valley, is something the people who live there come to know, so Rule 803(20) speaks of a community. The need behind both is the same: the facts are old or private enough that no eyewitness may be found.
The word “community” appears in both rules, and it misleads students who stop reading there. A whole town’s settled belief that two people were married is a reputation in the community, but it concerns a marriage, so Rule 803(19) governs it and Rule 803(20) never enters the analysis. The witness need not have seen the wedding, because the evidence is the town’s belief and not an account of the ceremony. A student who reaches for Rule 803(20) because the witness says “everyone in town” has matched the group and skipped the subject.
The two rules also differ on timing. Rule 803(20) requires that the reputation arise “before the controversy,” and Rule 803(19) states no such limit.6 The federal rule goes further and eliminates the traditional requirements that the statement have been made ante litem motam, before the controversy arose, and without motive to misrepresent. Those concerns now go to weight, or to exclusion under Rule 403 in extreme cases.7 A student who imports the pre-controversy limit into a family-history problem therefore adds a condition the text does not contain. A family account that grew up only after a quarrel over an inheritance may deserve little belief, but that is an argument about weight.
Character Reputation
Rule 803(21) applies the same device to a different subject. It admits “a reputation among a person’s associates or in the community concerning the person’s character.”9 Rule 803(20) admits reputation only on land boundaries, land customs, and general history.10 Both rules answer the same hearsay problem, a pooled belief that no single declarant can be cross-examined about, and both apply whether or not the declarant is available.11 The subject divides them. A witness who reports that the neighbors say a creek marks the line relies on Rule 803(20), and a witness who reports that the neighbors call a person honest, peaceable, or violent relies on Rule 803(21).
Character needs its own exception because of how character is proved. Evidence of a pertinent trait is admitted both to prove conduct in conformity with the trait and to impeach a witness’s credibility, and in modern evidence law a trait may be proved by reputation or by opinion.12 Proof by reputation raises a hearsay issue, because the witness repeats what others say. Without an exception, the character rules would allow the proof with one hand and the hearsay rule would take it away with the other. Hearsay law has traditionally resolved the conflict with an exception that readily admits the evidence, and Rule 803(21) continues that tradition.13 It counts a reputation among a person’s associates, such as coworkers or a social circle, as well as one in the wider community, and its text contains no pre-controversy phrase.14
The usual exam error treats Rule 803(21) as if it made character evidence admissible. It does not. The rule deals only with the hearsay aspect of the issue.15 Whether character may be proved at all in the case before the court, and for what purpose, remains a question for the separate rules on character evidence. A proponent of character reputation must clear two hurdles: the hearsay exception, and the rule that permits character evidence for the purpose offered.
The hearsay analysis is identical in the two scenes, because each witness reports a community’s reputation about a person’s character. What differs is the purpose for which the trait is offered. The character rules that govern that purpose are a separate hurdle, and no hearsay exception removes it.
Judgments on Boundaries
Rule 803(23) gives a second way to prove subjects that Rule 803(20) reaches through community talk. It removes the hearsay bar from a judgment admitted to prove “a matter of personal, family, or general history, or boundaries,” when the matter “was essential to the judgment” and “could be proved by evidence of reputation.”19 The subject list echoes the two reputation exceptions that precede it: personal and family history belong to Rule 803(19), and boundaries and general history to Rule 803(20).20
An earlier judgment is an out-of-court statement of what a court found, so a party who offers it to prove the finding runs into the hearsay rule. In a boundary case the usual source is a quiet-title action, which asks a court to declare who owns land and where its limits lie. If an earlier quiet-title judgment fixed the line between two tracts, a party in a later suit can offer that judgment to show where the line runs, without calling a witness to report what the neighbors believe.
The exception rests on a comparison of reliability. A reputation is a belief that neighbors have tested only through ordinary conversation. A judgment is a conclusion a court reached after parties with opposing interests presented evidence and the court weighed it. Because a judgment is at least as dependable as reputation on the same subject, the rule lets it prove the matter itself, as a parallel route to facts that reputation can establish. Like the reputation exceptions, it sits in Rule 803, so the proponent need not show that a declarant is unavailable.21 The two rules thus reach the same territory by different proof: Rule 803(20) offers a witness who reports what a community believes, and Rule 803(23) offers a court’s decision.22
The first condition, that the matter was essential to the judgment, confines the exception to findings the court had to make. The parties had every reason to contest a finding on which the outcome depended, and the court had every reason to decide it with care. A remark made along the way, on a point the result did not turn on, has none of that behind it. The question to ask of an earlier judgment is whether the court could have reached the same result without deciding the boundary.
Both judgments mention a boundary, and a boundary is a listed subject, so the subject does not separate them. What moves the answer is whether the earlier outcome depended on the line. The exam trap is reading any judgment that mentions a boundary as proof of the boundary, when the rule asks whether the court had to decide it.
The second condition, that the matter could be proved by evidence of reputation, ties the judgment exception to the reputation exceptions. It keeps the exception from becoming a rule that any finding in any judgment proves what it found. A finding that a driver ran a red light is not a matter of personal, family, or general history, or a boundary, and a community’s reputation could not prove it, so Rule 803(23) does not reach it. Reputation is accepted on boundaries and history because those facts are old or widely shared and no eyewitness is likely to be found, and the second condition keeps the judgment exception inside the same territory.
The exception lifts only the hearsay bar.23 On an exam, the cue words point the way. A stem that mentions an earlier lawsuit that fixed a line or settled a historical question points to Rule 803(23), and a stem built around what the neighbors have always said points to Rule 803(20).
Documents and Judicial Notice
A fact that Rule 803(20) would prove through what a community believes can sometimes be proved from a piece of paper instead. Rule 803(16) reaches “[a] statement in a document that was prepared before January 1, 1998, and whose authenticity is established.”25 A newspaper account of a historical event is a written out-of-court statement, so a party who offers it to show that the event happened runs into the hearsay rule, and the ancient-documents exception removes that objection when its two conditions are met. The rule names no subject matter, so unlike Rule 803(20) it is not confined to boundaries, land customs, or general history.
A document of this kind freezes what someone said at the time, long before the present lawsuit existed, and the page preserves the statement as it was first made. The second condition addresses the one risk that age does not cure: an old-looking page may not be what it claims to be, so the proponent must establish its authenticity. Students most often misstate the date. The text fixes a calendar date, so the test is when the document was prepared and not how old it seems today, and a page prepared on or after January 1, 1998 falls outside the exception however distant the event it describes.
The preparation date alone moved the answer between those two proponents. The 2010 writer, like the 1906 reporters, may never have seen the event, but only the older papers were written when the event was fresh and before any present controversy gave anyone a reason to shade the account. The second proponent still has an option: if the conditions of the reputation exception are met, a witness who knows what the community says about the earthquake offers a separate route to the same fact.26
A different document exception fits when the paper is a deed, mortgage, or other instrument dealing with land. Rule 803(15) covers “[a] statement contained in a document that purports to establish or affect an interest in property if the matter stated was relevant to the document’s purpose,” and then adds a limit: “unless later dealings with the property are inconsistent with the truth of the statement or the purport of the document.”27 People who sign a document that transfers or burdens land have a practical interest in describing the land and the parties’ rights accurately, because the document will be relied on afterward. A statement on a point that matters to the transaction is therefore likely to be correct, and the relevance condition keeps the exception to statements of that kind. An incidental remark on a point the transaction did not depend on has no such backing. The text contains no date requirement, so a recent deed can qualify even though it could not use Rule 803(16).
The inconsistency limit is the check on this exception. The way the parties and their successors actually treated the property afterward records what they believed the document meant, and when that conduct contradicts the statement, the statement loses the presumption of accuracy that justified admitting it. Both document exceptions sit in Rule 803, so neither requires the proponent to show that the declarant is unavailable.28
Some facts may need neither a hearsay exception nor a witness. Judicial notice, which belongs to a separate topic, can sometimes establish a fact without evidence, and a proponent who spots that option may avoid the hearsay question entirely.
Each of these routes is an alternative to Rule 803(20), and none is part of it. A proponent who offers an authenticated 1906 newspaper need not show a community reputation or that any belief arose before the controversy, because the questions for that document are its preparation date and its authenticity. A proponent who offers a reputation witness needs no old document, and the 1998 date has no place in a Rule 803(20) analysis. The usual exam error is running the wrong rule’s conditions against the evidence. Identify first what kind of proof is offered, and then apply the conditions of the rule that governs that kind.