Concept
Applying the Exception
Reputation concerning boundaries or general history
Applying the Exception
Rule 803(20) states its conditions in a single sentence: a reputation in a community, arising before the controversy, concerning boundaries of land in the community, customs that affect the land, or general historical events important to the community, state, or nation.1 Every condition must be met, so the efficient way to handle a fact pattern is to test the proffered evidence against them one at a time. Each condition screens out a different weakness. The community requirement screens out a private belief or one speaker's remark, the timing requirement screens out talk that the dispute itself produced, and the subject list screens out reputation on topics the rule does not name. An answer that skips a step admits something the exception was never written to reach.
The timing phrase sits ahead of the whole list of subjects, so step two needs care. The land clauses follow it directly, while general historical events arrive under a second 'concerning,'2 and that break in the text is why the commonly stated reading confines the pre-controversy limit to land matters and leaves general history outside it. Because the grammar alone does not compel that reading, treat it as the common interpretation, and apply the limit without hesitation whenever the subject is land. No step asks whether a declarant is unavailable. The exceptions in this group apply whether or not the declarant is available as a witness,3 and a reputation has no single declarant to produce in any event.
An exam stem that offers what the neighbors say is best answered by walking those steps in order. The clearest demonstration holds the subject and the claimed breadth constant and varies only the timing.
The two scenes share a subject and a claimed breadth, and the one fact that separates them is when the belief took shape. That is why the timing question follows the community question: it tests whether the belief grew up among people with nothing at stake or among people already taking sides. The community question has its own one-fact contrast. A neighbor who reports that the farm families have always treated the creek as the line passes step one, and a neighbor who reports only that an uncle once said so does not, however old the remark is.
Step three turns on what the belief is about, and widely shared talk on an unlisted subject fails there however many people hold it.
In the flood scene, step two raises no obstacle on the commonly stated reading, which ties the pre-controversy limit to land matters and not to general history, and a belief about an event a century old will almost certainly have formed long before the lawsuit anyway. The tenant scene shows why the subject list matters. If talk could prove a recent private act, the hearsay rule would give way for exactly the facts that eyewitnesses can still be called to describe.
Step four is the one students most often drop. Passing the first three steps means only that the hearsay rule does not exclude the reputation,4 and the opponent may still object on other grounds. A witness who moved to the township last month and has never heard a neighbor discuss the ridge fence has no community belief to report, so a foundation objection succeeds even though the subject is a boundary and the opponent concedes that the belief predates the dispute. The evidence must also bear on a fact that matters in the case. The usual exam error is to treat a satisfied exception as a finding that the testimony comes in, when it is a finding only that the hearsay rule does not keep it out.