Concept
Applying the Exception
Judgment of a previous conviction
Applying the Exception
Rule 803(22) admits a prior conviction only when the judgment clears every condition in the rule, and the conditions are cumulative: a judgment that fails one falls outside the exception however well it satisfies the rest.1 The judgment must be a final judgment of conviction, entered after a trial or a guilty plea but not a nolo contendere plea, for a crime punishable by death or by imprisonment for more than a year. The proponent must offer it to prove a fact essential to the judgment. And when a prosecutor offers it in a criminal case for a purpose other than impeachment, the judgment must have been entered against the defendant.2
That cumulative structure makes the rule easy to run under exam pressure. Test the conditions in a fixed order, stop at the first failure, and name the requirement that defeated the offer. Each condition was taught above, so this unit supplies the method and then alters one fact at a time to show which requirement each alteration reaches.
Step four does the most work on exams because it alone operates fact by fact. The other steps ask about the judgment or the setting of the offer, and each gives one answer. Step four asks about a stated proposition, so a single exhibit can pass for one proposition and fail for another.
Step one screens out exhibits that never reach the other conditions. An acquittal fails because it implies only that some factual element necessary to a conviction was not found beyond a reasonable doubt.3 A bare charge fails because no judgment of conviction has been entered. A pending appeal screens out nothing, as the Lindqvist judgment shows: the appeal may be shown, but it does not affect admissibility.4
A nolo contendere plea defeats the offer at step two even when everything else is in order. Suppose a battery prosecution ends in a nolo plea, producing an exhibit that looks just like the Lindqvist judgment: a final judgment of conviction under a five-year statute, resting on a fact essential to it. The offer fails, because a nolo plea is not an admission of guilt and the rule excludes any judgment entered on it.5 The identical judgment entered on a guilty plea passes, since the rule treats a conviction after trial and a conviction on a guilty plea alike.6
Lloyd v. American Export Lines, Inc. supplies a statute that shows step three at work on a foreign offense. Alvarez was charged with inflicting injury on Lloyd under Article 204 of the Japanese Penal Code, which punishes a person who inflicts bodily injury on another with imprisonment at forced labor for up to ten years or with a fine.7 An offense with a ten-year maximum clears the one-year line whatever sentence a particular judge imposes, because the question is what the crime is punishable by, and the code answers it. Foreign convictions are taken up in their own section above.
The Lindqvist judgment fails when the plaintiff stretches it to prove motive. Suppose Okafor also wants it to show that Lindqvist attacked out of anger over a failed business deal. Motive is not an element of battery, so the verdict could have been returned with no finding about it, and step four fails for that proposition.8 The same exhibit remains admissible to prove that Lindqvist struck Okafor, because the verdict could not stand without that finding. Step four is therefore always applied to a stated fact and never to the exhibit in the abstract.
Step five decides the outcome in a prosecution for receiving stolen stamps. The government offers a final judgment, entered after trial, convicting X of felony theft of those stamps, to prove that the stamps were stolen. Steps one through four are met, yet the judgment is excluded: it runs against X and not against the defendant, who had no chance to confront and cross-examine the witnesses at X's trial.9 The Confrontation Clause accounts for the restriction.10 The Fifth Circuit applied the same qualification in United States v. Diaz, 936 F.2d 786 (5th Cir. 1991), rejecting an attempt to use Rule 803(22) to establish the status of third parties as illegal aliens in a prosecution for transporting undocumented aliens.11
Step five is easy to over-apply, because the same third-party judgment comes in when the setting changes. In a civil suit claiming that B negligently shot and killed A on a hunting trip, B may offer C's conviction for the involuntary manslaughter of A.12 An accused may likewise offer another person's conviction against the government to prove that someone else committed the crime.13 Step five restrains only a prosecutor in a criminal case.14
Step five also has a built-in exit. The party condition reaches only offers made for a purpose other than impeachment, so a prosecutor who offers a conviction of someone other than the defendant to impeach a witness is not blocked by this step.15 A separate rule, Rule 609, governs impeachment by conviction, as covered above.