Concept
Why Unavailability Comes First
Declarant unavailable as a witness
Unavailability of the Declarant
Why Unavailability Comes First
Every exception in Rule 804(b) stays locked until the proponent, the party offering the statement, proves that the declarant, the person who made the out-of-court statement, is "unavailable as a witness" under Rule 804(a).1 Five exceptions wait behind that lock: former testimony, statements made under belief of imminent death, statements against interest, statements of personal or family history, and forfeiture by wrongdoing.2 Until the judge finds the declarant unavailable, the content of the statement never comes up, however trustworthy it looks.
The Rule 804 exceptions work in two steps. The proponent first shows that the declarant is unavailable, and then shows that the statement fits one of the five exceptions.3 The order tracks a ranking of preferences: testimony given on the stand beats hearsay, and hearsay of the specified quality beats losing the declarant's evidence altogether.4
Unavailability supplies the necessity that makes second-best evidence acceptable. The Court's discussion of former testimony in United States v. Inadi states the logic plainly. When two versions of the same evidence are available, the law of hearsay favors the better one; when the declarant is unavailable, no better version exists, and the weaker one may stand in for live testimony.5 Live testimony is preferable, but the out-of-court statement is accepted when the declarant cannot be had.6
Rule 803 rests on the opposite theory, which is why it has no unavailability condition. Its exceptions, such as excited utterances and business records, cover statements regarded as at least as reliable as in-court testimony, so producing the declarant would add only delay and inconvenience.7 The Rule 803 exceptions therefore apply whether the declarant is available, unavailable, or actually testifying.8 Rule 801(d) works the same way: the Rules define those statements as "not hearsay" even though they fit the hearsay definition, so unavailability never arises.9 Certain prior statements of a testifying witness, such as the prior consistent statements that some jurisdictions, California among them, admit, likewise come in without any showing of unavailability.10 When a statement fits Rule 803 or Rule 801(d), Rule 804(a) is never consulted.
"Unavailable" describes the declarant's testimony, not the declarant's whereabouts. Practice speaks loosely of an unavailable witness, but the critical factor is the unavailability of the witness's testimony, and a witness may sit in the courtroom while the testimony stays out of reach.11 A declarant who is in court is unavailable if he cannot remember, refuses to testify, or successfully claims a privilege.12 Rule 804(a) lists five grounds:
- The court rules that a privilege exempts the declarant from testifying about the subject matter of the statement.13
- The declarant refuses to testify about the subject matter despite a court order to do so.14
- The declarant testifies to not remembering the subject matter.15
- The declarant cannot be present or testify because of death or a then-existing infirmity, physical illness, or mental illness.16
- The declarant is absent from the trial or hearing, and the proponent has not been able, by process or other reasonable means, to procure the declarant's attendance or testimony, as the particular exception requires.17
Two proponents show how the test works.
The two scenes come out differently because of what each proponent has shown. In the first, the court has ruled that the privilege applies, so the testimony cannot be had even though the witness is present.18 In the second, distance proves nothing by itself. The Rule asks whether the proponent has been unable to procure attendance by process or other reasonable means, and a proponent who never asked has shown no inability.19 Treating absence as the end of the inquiry is the common mistake; under the Rule, absence is where the proponent's showing begins.
The judge, not the jury, decides whether the declarant is unavailable, because the answer determines whether the hearsay may be heard at all. It is a preliminary question of admissibility under Rule 104(a).20 The proponent carries the burden of showing unavailability.21 The placement fits the parties' positions: the proponent prefers the hearsay version of the evidence and is the one who knows what efforts were made to secure the declarant's testimony. A reversed burden would force the opponent to prove a negative about efforts the opponent never saw.
One limit qualifies all five grounds. Under the last sentence of Rule 804(a), a proponent who procured or wrongfully caused the declarant's unavailability in order to prevent the declarant from attending or testifying cannot rely on it.22 The limit answers a real temptation. A party may prefer the hearsay to an available declarant who would communicate badly on the stand or say something inconsistent with the hearsay, and may think about "making" the witness unavailable. The Rule disentitles that party from using the hearsay.23
When hearsay is offered against a defendant in a criminal trial, the Sixth Amendment adds requirements of its own, taken up in a later section. If the declarant is unavailable, the statement is testimonial, and the defendant had no opportunity to cross-examine, the Confrontation Clause makes the evidence inadmissible even though a hearsay exception applies.24