Concept
Death or Infirmity
Declarant unavailable as a witness
Death or Infirmity
Rule 804(a)(4) makes a declarant unavailable when death or a then-existing infirmity, physical illness, or mental illness prevents the declarant from being present or testifying at the trial or hearing.1 Death is the clearest case. No subpoena, sanction, or recess can bring a dead declarant to the stand, so Rule 804's preference for live testimony cannot be honored, and the choice narrows to the earlier statement or nothing from this source.2
Clay v. Johns-Manville Sales Corp. shows both what death accomplishes and what it leaves undone. The plaintiffs offered a deposition that a company physician had given in an earlier asbestos case. He had died before trial, so unavailability was settled, and the court turned to the remaining requirements of the former-testimony exception. Death proves unavailability and nothing more. The statement must still fit an exception, and the exceptions are rigid: commentators have described the hearsay rule as a rigid rule mitigated by numerous rigid exceptions.3
Illness and infirmity raise a question that death answers automatically: does the condition actually keep the declarant from being present or from testifying at the proceeding? The Rule's words present and testify are alternatives. A declarant in a hospital bed may speak well yet be unable to travel. A declarant brought into the courtroom may be unable, because of severe mental illness, to give coherent testimony. Either declarant qualifies. Rule 804 prefers that the declarant appear and testify, so the label "ill" settles nothing by itself; the condition must put live testimony out of reach.4 The judge therefore needs facts about what the condition is and how long it will last.
The words "then-existing" fix the moment of inquiry at the proceeding itself.5 A declarant who was gravely ill when the statement was made, or last spring, but who has recovered by trial can testify, so the ground fails. Where the condition is temporary, the ground has soft edges. Ailments run from a fatal diagnosis to a passing cold, and the question becomes whether the condition will last long enough to defeat live testimony.6 A short recess or continuance costs the court little, while admitting hearsay gives up the oath, the cross-examination, and the demeanor evidence that live testimony supplies. A judge facing a temporary condition therefore has good reason to wait for the declarant rather than read the statement.
The two scenes differ in how long the condition will last, and that fact decides whether live testimony remains obtainable. The usual exam error is to treat any mention of illness in a stem as enough. The stem must show that the condition prevents the declarant from being present or from testifying when the trial is held.
Child witnesses in abuse prosecutions show how far the ground reaches beyond ordinary sickness. Courts have often found a young declarant unavailable when they determined that testifying would cause the child serious emotional trauma. That finding fits this ground because it describes a present condition of the particular child that prevents testimony at the trial. Ordinary reluctance or nervousness describes no such condition. Courts that find a child unavailable under the hearsay rule have usually found any Confrontation Clause requirement of unavailability satisfied as well, a point the last part of this chapter develops.7
Like every ground in Rule 804(a), this one fails if the proponent procured or wrongfully caused the death or illness in order to prevent the declarant from attending or testifying.8 Death or illness is also the first of two grounds in which the declarant's physical situation is the problem. The second, absence under Rule 804(a)(5), looks similar but is harder to establish.9 A declarant who is alive and healthy but somewhere else is not unavailable under the death-or-infirmity ground. The proponent must instead show that process or other reasonable means failed to bring the declarant in, which the next sections explain.10