Concept
Proponent-Caused Unavailability
Declarant unavailable as a witness
Proponent-Caused Unavailability
A party cannot manufacture a declarant's absence and then profit from it. The last sentence of Rule 804(a) enforces that principle: the definition of unavailability does not apply if the statement's proponent procured or wrongfully caused the declarant's unavailability as a witness in order to prevent the declarant from attending or testifying.1 The sentence qualifies the entire subdivision, so a witness is not unavailable under any of its grounds when the proponent engineered the condition.2 Rule 804(a) otherwise accepts many reasons for treating a declarant as unavailable, and this sentence is the counterweight that keeps that generosity from being exploited.3 The judge decides whether the declarant is unavailable under Rule 104(a), and the party offering the statement carries the burden of showing it.4
The counterweight is needed because a proponent may prefer the hearsay to the live witness. A declarant who is actually available might communicate poorly on the stand, or might say something inconsistent with the earlier statement. A party in that position may think about making the witness unavailable and then offering the hearsay on the ground that the declarant cannot be had. Rule 804(a) answers that such conduct disentitles the party from using the hearsay at trial.5 Without that answer, the exceptions in Rule 804(b) would reward the maneuver. With it, the proponent who caused the unavailability for that purpose must produce the live witness or do without the statement.
The fact that separates the two plaintiffs is the one the Rule names: the proponent must have acted in order to prevent the declarant from attending or testifying. That purpose element confines the carve-out to deliberate maneuvering. The provision requires a specific purpose to render the witness unavailable, but it does not require that the means used be wrongful in themselves.6 A proponent whose conduct merely precedes an absence, or whose declarant leaves for the declarant's own reasons, has not gamed anything, and an exam stem that shows only an act followed by an absence has not yet triggered the carve-out. Look for facts of aim: a payment to leave the country, a warning to stay away, a stated wish that the declarant not testify.
Rule 804(b)(6) works from the opposite side. Rule 804(a) denies a benefit to the proponent who caused the unavailability, while the forfeiture exception, added in 1997, admits otherwise inadmissible hearsay against a party who wrongfully secured the declarant's unavailability.7 The same maneuver can therefore engage both rules, and which one applies depends on who is offering the statement. The party who stayed clean may gain the statement, and the party who caused the absence cannot use that absence for itself.
Purpose does the work in such disputes. In one case, Hale asserted spousal privilege at trial and thereby prevented Reed from testifying. The trial court held that Hale had entered into the marriage intending to cause Reed's unavailability as a witness, and Hale challenged that ruling as an abuse of discretion.8
The forfeiture rule carries its own purpose element. Giles v. California described the federal rule as applying only when the defendant engaged or acquiesced in wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the declarant's unavailability as a witness.9 The two rules therefore differ in what they require beyond purpose: the carve-out in Rule 804(a) asks for a specific purpose without requiring wrongful conduct, while forfeiture is framed around wrongdoing intended to procure the absence. The elements of forfeiture receive their own treatment. For present purposes the point is direction: the last sentence of Rule 804(a) disables the proponent, while Rule 804(b)(6) lets the proponent's opponent hold the wrongdoer to account.