Concept
Rule and Rationale
Statement under the belief of imminent death
Dying Declaration Exception
Rule and Rationale
Rule 804(b)(2) excepts from the hearsay rule, “in a prosecution for homicide or in a civil case, a statement that the declarant, while believing the declarant's death to be imminent, made about its cause or circumstances.”1 That sentence holds three conditions. The proceeding must be a homicide prosecution or a civil case. The declarant must have believed death imminent while speaking. The statement must concern the cause or circumstances of that death. The lead-in to Rule 804(b) adds a fourth condition, because the listed statements escape the hearsay bar only “if the declarant is unavailable as a witness.”2 The dying declaration therefore joins four other exceptions that demand unavailability: former testimony, declarations against interest, declarations of personal or family history, and forfeiture by wrongdoing.3 Lawyers also call it a deathbed declaration.4
Two questions must both be answered yes before the statement comes in. Is the declarant unavailable under one of the grounds listed in Rule 804(a)? Does the statement fit the exception as Rule 804(b) defines it?5 Two ideas, reliability and necessity, justify this double test, and each accounts for a different part of the rule's text.
Reliability comes first, because no exception in Rules 803 and 804 depends on cross-examination at the time of the statement. Each exception instead specifies requirements considered sufficient guarantees of trustworthiness to justify admission without it.6 For the dying declaration, the guarantee rests on a premise about motive. The common law held that people's religious beliefs make them highly reluctant to lie at the moment of death.7 The classic formulation is that no one would falsify before meeting her Maker, and that a speaker in that position has abandoned all hope of worldly gain.8 The Supreme Court expressed the thought in terms of the oath: the sense of impending death is presumed to remove all temptation to falsehood, and to enforce as strict an adherence to the truth as an oath would.9 A secular argument arrives at the same place, since a person who believes death is near has nothing to gain from a falsehood.10 Idaho v. Wright lists the dying declaration among the exceptions built on the belief that speakers in that position are highly unlikely to lie.11
The premise is contestable, and the narrowness of the rule answers the doubt. A dying speaker may feel free to lie precisely because no worldly consequence can follow.12 Atheists, vengeful people, and people who hope to benefit their survivors may keep every ordinary motive to shade the truth.13 Because the argument for trust is strongest in only one situation, the rule confines the exception to that situation. At common law, the exception applied only in criminal homicide prosecutions in which the declarant was the alleged victim. The declarant had to be in extremis, had to know it, and had to have abandoned hope of recovery. The declarant also had to have died of the very injury the accused was alleged to have inflicted.14 The federal text opens the exception to civil cases, but it keeps the requirement of a belief in imminent death and the focus on cause or circumstances. Two practical features further reduce the usual hearsay danger of faulty memory. The time between the events and the statement is likely to be short, and the restrictions placed on dying declarations help in many cases.15
Necessity explains why the exception sits in Rule 804 instead of Rule 803. The Rule 803 exceptions operate whatever the availability of the declarant. The Rule 804 exceptions require unavailability, which recognizes that live testimony is preferable but that the hearsay is better than no evidence from the declarant at all.16 The Supreme Court said of dying declarations that they are admitted not under any general rule on testimony but as an exception, “simply from the necessities of the case, and to prevent a manifest failure of justice.”17 A victim who has died cannot testify, and that is the paradigm case. The rule's text, though, asks only that the declarant be unavailable on one of the grounds listed in Rule 804(a).18 Excluding a victim's last words about the cause of death would leave the factfinder without evidence from the person who knew most. A declarant who can walk into court creates no such need.
Each element examined in the following sections traces to one of these two ideas. The judge, not the jury, decides whether the elements are met, including whether the declarant believed death imminent.19
The two scenes share the accusation, the civil suit, and the speaker's unavailability. They differ only in what the speaker expected while talking. In the first, the premise behind the exception is present, and the physicians' statements in the decedent's presence are the kind of circumstantial evidence from which the belief may be shown.20 The words come in once the other conditions are met. In the second, the patient expected to live, so every ordinary reason to shift blame remained, and Rule 804(b)(2) does not reach the statement. A problem that supplies the injury, the accusation, and the lawsuit but says nothing about the declarant's expectation is testing for exactly this missing condition. A statement that fails here may still qualify under another exception, a possibility taken up in a later section.