Concept
Working a Problem
Statement under the belief of imminent death
Working a Problem
An exam problem applies Rule 804(b)(2) one clause at a time. The Rule reaches a statement that the declarant, "while believing the declarant's death to be imminent," made "about its cause or circumstances," and it operates "[i]n a prosecution for homicide or in a civil case."1 The lead-in to Rule 804(b) adds one more condition: the declarant must be unavailable as a witness.2 Each condition was taught separately above. A problem demands them together and seldom says which exception is in play, so the work starts with finding the issue and then runs the elements in an order that shows where a statement stops and which fallback remains.
Most open-ended hearsay questions end with a ruling. A witness starts to repeat what a dying victim said, defense counsel objects that the words are hearsay, the court overrules, and the question asks whether the court was right. The call of the question does not name the issue, so work backward from the ruling. A court that admitted the testimony over a hearsay objection must have found either that the words were not hearsay or that an exception admitted them.3 The facts then point to the exception. A speaker who has just been told that an injury is life-threatening, and whose last words describe how it happened, invites the dying-declaration exception, and the issue becomes whether the court was correct to find the statement a dying declaration and therefore admissible.4 A working outline needs only two headings at this stage, the general rule against hearsay and the dying-declaration exception, with the exception's elements to follow. Naming the exception early keeps the analysis on the one exception the facts raise and spares the reader a survey of every exception.
The order follows cost. The type of case is read from the charge or the pleading and does not turn on anything the declarant said, so it is the cheapest gate and can end the analysis before any fact is disputed. Belief and subject matter raise questions of fact for the judge, and they precede the basis inquiry because a sincere speaker can still be guessing. Unavailability comes last among the elements because it is measured at trial: the Rule asks whether the declarant "cannot be present or testify at the trial or hearing because of death or a then-existing infirmity, physical illness, or mental illness."6 Belief is judged earlier, "while" the declarant speaks, so the two inquiries run on separate clocks.
Gates that open easily do not carry a problem by themselves. Nancy Neville sues Oscar Ordway, claiming that she caught a sexually transmitted disease from him and that he negligently failed to tell her he was infected when they had sexual relations; Ordway answers that she probably caught it from Steve Stoner, a man she was involved with before meeting Ordway and who is unavailable to testify at trial.7 The suit is civil, so the type-of-case gate is open, and Stoner's being unavailable supplies the condition in the lead-in to Rule 804(b).8 Suppose a witness now offers something Stoner once said. Nothing in the stated facts shows that Stoner spoke while believing his own death imminent, or that his words concerned the cause or circumstances of that death, and without both the exception stays closed however easily the other conditions are met.
Sam's case shows the full sequence. Cindy runs into Sam and knocks him down, and Jerry calls an ambulance. Sam insists that Jerry come along, and since Jerry will not leave his dog Spot, all three ride to the hospital together. There the doctor tells Sam, who is conscious, that the fall caused bleeding in his brain, that his condition is serious, and that he needs immediate surgery. Just before losing consciousness, Sam thanks Jerry and Spot, tells Jerry that the woman who knocked him down was Cindy, a woman he once dated, and says, "The doctor said my condition is serious, and surgery is necessary to save my life. Don't let Cindy get away with this." Sam dies later that night despite the surgery. Cindy is prosecuted for homicide in his death, and over a hearsay objection the court lets Jerry repeat Sam's words.9
Working backward from the ruling, the court must have treated Sam's words as a dying declaration, and the elements run in order. The prosecution is for homicide, so the type-of-case gate opens.10 Belief is where the argument lives. A conscious patient who hears that he has a serious brain bleed and needs immediate surgery, who loses consciousness moments after speaking, and who dies within hours can reasonably be found to have believed death imminent, and Sam's own last words repeat the doctor's warning that surgery is necessary to save his life. The defense answers that surgery offered a chance of survival and that a speaker who hopes for rescue has not given up hope. The judge must weigh the two inferences, and a strong answer commits to one. Sam's identification of Cindy as the woman who knocked him down concerns the cause of the injury that killed him, so it meets the subject-matter limit; his thanks to Jerry and Spot do not, though no one has a reason to offer them. Sam knew Cindy and was the person she knocked down, so the identification rests on what he perceived and not on guesswork. His death supplies unavailability, because a declarant who cannot testify because of death is unavailable.11 The last step is the Confrontation Clause. Sam spoke to a bystander and not to an official gathering evidence, which points to the nontestimonial side of the line drawn in the preceding section.
An examiner who wants to test the belief element rewrites the doctor's part of the story. What happens to the analysis if the doctor tells Sam the injury is minor?
The charge, the identification, and the death are as before, and the statement now fails on belief alone. A death two days later shows what happened and says nothing about what Sam expected when he spoke, so homicide and unavailability cannot repair the missing belief. A failure at one step does not end the problem, though. Jerry's account may still be tested as an excited utterance if the facts show Sam was still under the stress of the collision, and the residual exception remains a last resort once the specific exceptions have been tried.
A single statement can also qualify in part, and the problem then calls for sorting it into portions and running steps 5 and 6 on each. The next scene adds a survivor, so the type-of-case gate and the unavailability step both need attention.
The charge is the murder of Lena Voss, so the prosecution is one for homicide. The Rule's text asks only that, and it does not say the charged homicide must be the declarant's own, so the gate opens even though Rowan is not the victim named in the indictment.12 Whether the shooting of Rowan bears on any issue in the trial for Lena's killing is a separate relevance question that the exception does not answer. The physician gave Rowan reason to expect death within hours, so the judge can find the belief, and the fact that Rowan did not die does not show that he lacked it when he spoke. His condition matters at a different step. A declarant who cannot testify at trial because of a then-existing infirmity or illness is unavailable, so an unrecovering coma satisfies the condition although Rowan is alive.13 Had Rowan recovered and been able to take the stand, the statement would have failed on unavailability however sincere his belief.14
The sorting happens at the subject-matter step. The first half, that Dray shot Rowan that night, identifies the person responsible for the death Rowan expected, and it fits the phrase "about its cause or circumstances."15 It also needs a basis in Rowan's perception. The facts do not say whether he saw the shooter, and a shooting victim who faced the attacker would ordinarily have one, so a graded answer should flag the gap. The second half, that Dray killed Lena Voss the month before, is an assertion about a different death. The word "its" points back to the declarant's own expected death, so the statement about Lena qualifies only if it explains the circumstances of Rowan's shooting, for example by supplying a reason Dray had to silence him. As worded, it supplies no such link, and the facts do not say how Rowan knew what he asserted about Lena. The proponent must establish both the link and the basis, while the opponent argues that the second half is an accusation about a separate crime. A graded answer should commit to a side and argue it.
In every criminal problem in which the prosecution offers the statement, finish by asking whether it is testimonial, because a statement that clears Rule 804(b)(2) must still be checked against the Confrontation Clause.