Concept
Rule 804(b)(4) in Context
Statement of personal or family history
Personal and Family History
Rule 804(b)(4) in Context
Rule 804(b)(4) lets a court hear what a declarant, the person who made an out-of-court statement, once said about birth, marriage, ancestry, and other facts of personal or family history. It works only when that declarant cannot testify. Rule 804(b) collects the hearsay exceptions that apply only if the declarant is unavailable as a witness,1 and Rule 804(b)(4) is one of them.
Each exception in the group rests on the same bargain: live testimony from the declarant would be better evidence, but hearsay is better than hearing nothing from the declarant at all.2 Five exceptions share that bargain: former testimony, dying declarations, declarations against interest, forfeiture by wrongdoing, and the one studied here, a minor exception for statements of personal or family history.3 The numbering has a gap. The old Rule 804(b)(5), the residual exception, was transferred to Rule 807, and forfeiture by wrongdoing now sits at (b)(6).4
The text of (b)(4) begins "A statement about" and then divides its subject matter by whose history the statement describes.5
- Subdivision (A) covers the declarant's own birth, adoption, legitimacy, ancestry, marriage, divorce, relationship by blood, adoption, or marriage, or similar facts. It applies even though the declarant had no way of acquiring personal knowledge of the fact.6
- Subdivision (B) covers another person's history on those same facts, and the other person's death as well. The declarant must have been related to that person by blood, adoption, or marriage, or so intimately associated with the person's family that the declarant's information is likely to be accurate.7
Because the exception sits inside Rule 804(b), a statement must pass two gates, and the analysis runs in this order.
The next section takes up the first stage, and the sections after it take the second apart subdivision by subdivision. The stages fail independently. A statement can fit the subject matter perfectly and still stay out because the declarant can be called. An unavailable declarant's statement can still be excluded because it falls outside both subdivisions. When a lineage question appears on an exam, check unavailability before you read the statement for content.
The federal rule follows the liberal view of the common-law exception and admits statements by intimate associates of the family. It drops two traditional requirements: that the statement have been made ante litem motam, before the controversy arose, and that it have been made without motive to misrepresent. Those matters now go to weight, or to exclusion under Rule 403 in extreme cases. The rule keeps the narrow view of what counts as family history.10
Expect to meet the exception rarely in federal court. It is seldom invoked in federal cases, since family-law issues tend to be litigated in state courts.11