Concept
Proving the Family Connection
Statement of personal or family history
Proving the Family Connection
Subdivision (B) of Rule 804(b)(4) lets a party offer an unavailable declarant's statement about another person's family history or death, but only "if the declarant was related to the person by blood, adoption, or marriage or was so intimately associated with the person's family that the declarant's information is likely to be accurate."1 That relationship is a condition of admissibility, and the party offering the statement must prove it. The rule's text does not say how. Courts have filled the gap: when a statement is offered to prove facts about someone other than the speaker, they may require independent evidence that the speaker belongs to the family or is an intimate of it.2 Fulkerson v. Holmes, 117 U.S. 389 (1886), and United States v. Eng Suak Lun, 67 F.2d 307, 308-309 (10th Cir. 1933), are the decisions cited for that approach.3
The demand makes sense once you see what the relationship does inside the rule. Because the exception does not require firsthand knowledge, the declarant's tie to the family is what the rule offers as the reason to trust the statement: it is what makes the declarant's information "likely to be accurate." Suppose the only proof of that tie is the declarant's own remark that she was close to the family. A stranger repeating rumor could make the same remark, so it adds nothing. The statement would then vouch for its own foundation, and the argument would run in a circle. Evidence from outside the statement breaks the circle, because it supports the foundation without depending on the words being tested.
The hole in Pedro's showing is a hole in evidence, and argument will not fill it. Testimony from the decedent's relatives, or from someone who knew how Emmett stood with the household, would have supplied the foundation without leaning on Emmett's words. The authorities say courts may require independent evidence, so on an exam say that the court may require it and do not announce a mandatory rule or a fixed standard of proof.
Both declarants are unavailable, both spoke about a listed family-history fact, and both statements are offered under (B). They differ in where the proof of the declarant's relationship comes from. Gloria's tie to William rests on her sister's testimony and the Bible, so the court is never asked to take her word for it. Emmett's tie rests on his word alone, and that is exactly what the court was asked to accept.
The demand for outside proof stops at statements about other people. Under the strict traditional view, the declarant's relationship to the family had to be proved by independent evidence, but that requirement did not apply when the declarant's own family relationships were the subject of the statement.4 Today the line falls in the same place. When a statement is offered to prove facts about the declarant herself, such as her marriage, her children, or her parents, other proof of the relationships is probably not required, and Morgan v. Susino Construction Co. is cited for that point.5 The line tracks the rule's structure. Subdivision (A) covers the declarant's own history, and there the speaker is the person whose family is at issue, so no outsider's standing to speak needs checking. Subdivision (B) conditions admission on the declarant's tie to the person described, and the foundation requirement is how a court confirms that condition. Had Emmett said only that he himself married Dolores in 1988, his statement would speak about his own marriage, and the court would probably not demand separate proof that he belonged to any family.
Two mistakes recur on exams. The first treats the foundation as automatic because the exception dispenses with personal knowledge. That waiver concerns how the declarant learned the fact, and the family tie is a separate matter. The second demands outside proof of a family tie for every statement under the exception, when the demand attaches to statements about other people. If a stem tells you only that the declarant described himself as a cousin or a close family friend, with nothing else in the record, it is testing the first mistake.