Concept
The Forfeiture Principle
Forfeiture by wrongdoing
The Wrongful Procurement Exception
The Forfeiture Principle
A party who can silence a witness gains twice. The witness never testifies, and if the rule against hearsay applied at full strength, nothing the witness said earlier could reach the factfinder either. Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered for its truth, and the rule excludes it chiefly because the opponent cannot question the person who made it. Rule 804(b)(6) takes that protection away from a party who is responsible for the silence. It admits “[a] statement offered against a party that wrongfully caused—or acquiesced in wrongfully causing—the declarant’s unavailability as a witness, and did so intending that result.”1 The declarant is the person who made the out-of-court statement, so the rule asks one question about the party resisting the evidence: is that party the reason this person cannot testify?
A hearsay objection is, in substance, a complaint that the speaker is not in the courtroom to be questioned. When the objecting party is the reason the speaker is absent, the objection turns misconduct into advantage. A rule that honored it would reward the silencing of witnesses, because silence would erase their earlier statements along with their live testimony. Forfeiture ends the reward. The rule rests on the policy that a party should not profit by excluding hearsay that is necessary only because the party made it impossible to produce the declarant.2 Decisions like United States v. Gray ground the exception in an old maxim, that “no one shall be permitted to take advantage of his own wrong.” Courts add that when a defendant has silenced a witness through threats, violence, or murder, admitting the victim’s prior statements “at least partially offsets the perpetrator’s rewards for his misconduct.”3
The 1997 amendment that added the exception placed it last in Rule 804(b) and titled it “Forfeiture by Wrongdoing.” That title still describes the rule better than its present one.4 Forfeiture is what the rule does: a party who is the reason a witness is absent loses the right to object to that witness’s hearsay.5
Rule 804(b)(6) also belongs to the group of exceptions that apply only “if the declarant is unavailable as a witness.”6 The proponent therefore makes two showings: the declarant must be unavailable under Rule 804(a), and the statement must meet the exception’s own terms in Rule 804(b)(6).7 Necessity explains the group. Live testimony is better than hearsay, but hearsay is better than nothing from someone who cannot be produced.8
What separates forfeiture from its neighbors in Rule 804(b) is the reason for admission. A statement against interest comes in because a reasonable person would make it only if she believed it true.9 A dying declaration comes in because the pressure of approaching death leads the declarant to say what matters most.10 Each gives a reason to trust the statement itself. Forfeiture gives none. The statement is admitted because of what the opponent did, so a statement of doubtful reliability can still clear the hearsay bar.11
Two consequences follow from resting on responsibility rather than reliability. The exception reaches any declaration, whether or not another hearsay exception covers it.12 And it operates only against a party whose conduct it was meant to deter, the party responsible for the absence.13 At a joint trial, a statement may therefore come in against the codefendant who silenced the witness and, absent some other exception, stay out against the one who did not.
The party who forfeits the objection need not be a criminal defendant. Any party who wrongfully acts, or acquiesces in wrongdoing, with the intent to make a declarant unavailable forfeits the objection. A prosecutor who intentionally intimidates a defense witness into refusing to testify loses the right to object to that witness’s hearsay, and the same is true of parties in civil cases. The rule demands “wrongdoing,” but the conduct need not amount to a crime.14 What the rule cannot do is reach an absence that no party’s wrongdoing caused.
The sections that follow take the rule in the order a court applies it. They begin with how unavailability is established, then turn to wrongful conduct, intent, and causation, then to how the proponent proves those elements and which statements come in. They end with the Confrontation Clause overlay that governs in criminal cases.