Concept
The Unavailability Threshold
Forfeiture by wrongdoing
The Unavailability Threshold
Forfeiture by wrongdoing cannot begin until the declarant is unavailable. Every exception in Rule 804(b) admits its statements only “if the declarant is unavailable as a witness,”1 and Rule 804(b)(6) reaches a party who wrongfully caused “the declarant’s unavailability as a witness.”2 Rule 804(a) defines that phrase: a declarant “is considered to be unavailable as a witness” when one of the circumstances it lists exists.3
Unavailability supplies the necessity for every Rule 804 exception. The out-of-court statement comes in as a substitute because the live witness cannot be had, and a court that skipped the question would accept secondhand evidence where the firsthand version was within reach. In a forfeiture case, though, unavailability and wrongdoing are separate questions. Unavailability asks whether the declarant’s absence fits a form the rules recognize; forfeiture asks whether the party resisting the evidence is responsible for it. A declarant who dies of natural causes is unavailable, but no one’s misconduct caused the death, so Rule 804(b)(6) gives the proponent nothing. A party who threatens a witness who then testifies anyway has done wrong, yet no one has become unavailable and nothing remains to forfeit. Forfeiture adds a second inquiry on top of unavailability; it does not replace it.
Three questions follow. Which circumstances count as unavailability? What must the proponent show when the declarant is merely absent? And what happens when the proponent itself caused the unavailability?
Criteria in Rule 804(a)
Rule 804(a) lists the circumstances in which a declarant counts as unavailable, and the list governs every Rule 804(b) exception, forfeiture included.4 The drafters wrote the circumstances out to give judicial rulings on unavailability some consistency,5 and each describes a situation in which live testimony cannot be had. Wrongdoing is not on the list. A bribe, a threat, or an act of violence matters under Rule 804(b)(6) only when it leaves the declarant in one of the listed conditions, so a forfeiture argument must land on one of these five:
- A court ruling that a privilege exempts the declarant from testifying about the subject matter of the statement makes the declarant unavailable, as when a spouse successfully declines to testify against a party. Forfeiture then asks whether the party wrongfully produced that result, intending it.6
- A declarant who refuses to testify about the subject matter despite a court order is unavailable. This is the likely endpoint for a witness who has been threatened or paid and chooses silence even in the face of contempt.7
- A declarant who testifies to not remembering the subject matter is unavailable. A pressured witness may reach this condition by professing to recall nothing instead of defying an order.8
- Death, or a then-existing infirmity, physical illness, or mental illness that keeps the declarant from being present or testifying, makes the declarant unavailable. The murdered witness is the paradigm forfeiture case: the killing supplies the unavailability and, if committed to prevent testimony, the wrongdoing too.9
- A declarant who is absent from the trial or hearing is unavailable if the proponent, the party offering the statement, has not been able by process or other reasonable means to procure the declarant’s attendance. A witness who has been hidden, paid to leave, or frightened into flight ends up here.10
The conditions turn on what has actually happened to the declarant, so intimidation that leaves a witness willing to testify produces no unavailability. The refusal criterion shows this most clearly, because it requires a refusal that continues despite a court order.11 Reluctance that gives way once a judge directs an answer leaves the witness available; only a refusal that survives the order meets the criterion.
The privilege criterion depends on a ruling too: the court must rule that a privilege applies.12 For that route, compare State v. Preston. Meeting a criterion opens the forfeiture inquiry without ending it, because the party’s responsibility for the condition must still be shown.
The absence criterion has an effort requirement built in, and proponents most often fall short there.
A witness who sits in the courthouse willing to testify is likewise available, even if the party offering the statement expects poor testimony, because none of the five circumstances exists. Each criterion describes something that has happened to the declarant; a party’s prediction about how the testimony will go is not among them.
Attendance, Not Deposition
The absence criterion comes in two versions, and the exception the proponent invokes decides which one applies. A proponent offering former testimony or forfeiture by wrongdoing, Rules 804(b)(1) and (6), must show only that it could not procure “the declarant’s attendance.”15 That showing concerns getting the person to court: the proponent served a subpoena or tried another reasonable step, and the declarant still did not appear.16 Nothing more about the declarant’s testimony has to be shown.
A proponent offering a dying declaration, a statement against interest, or a statement of personal or family history, Rules 804(b)(2), (3), and (4), carries the heavier burden: it must show that it could not procure “the declarant’s attendance or testimony.”17 Testimony can often be obtained without the declarant coming to trial, most commonly by deposition, so before calling the declarant unavailable the proponent must in effect try to take one.18 A proponent whose subpoena failed has done everything the lighter version asks and only half of what the heavier version asks.
The extra step exists because a deposition gives the opponent a chance to cross-examine a declarant who cannot come to court, and the preference for depositions rests largely on that opportunity.19 Former testimony carries an earlier opportunity to cross-examine. The three heavier exceptions do not, so the rule asks the proponent to supply one when it can.
Forfeiture takes the lighter burden: the deposition provision does not apply when the proponent relies on forfeiture by wrongdoing.20 The policy behind the exception explains the difference. A party should not be able to profit by excluding hearsay that is needed only because that party made the declarant impossible to produce.21 Making the innocent proponent chase a deposition would hand the wrongdoer a procedural benefit from the very absence it caused.
Former testimony takes the lighter showing for a different reason, and the two should not be run together. The opponent has already had a chance to cross-examine the declarant, and the testimony usually sits in a court reporter’s transcript, so a deposition would add almost nothing to what the proponent already holds.22 One exception escapes the deposition step because cross-examination has already happened, the other because of the party’s wrongdoing.
Both versions matter only when absence is the ground of unavailability. If the declarant is dead, ill, privileged, refusing to testify, or claims not to remember, the proponent need not try to obtain alternative testimony, even under an exception that would otherwise call for it.23 The deposition showing bites only on the declarant who is simply somewhere else.
The same effort, a subpoena and nothing more, would have sufficed had the proponent relied on forfeiture.
The lighter showing clears only the unavailability gate. Whether the party resisting the statement caused the absence is the separate forfeiture inquiry, taken up in the elements below. One more limit on unavailability remains, and it concerns a proponent who caused the absence itself.
The Proponent's Own Procurement
The closing sentence of Rule 804(a) withdraws the unavailability definition from one kind of proponent: the party who made the declarant unavailable in order to keep the declarant off the stand. After listing the circumstances that count as unavailability, the rule provides that the definition “does not apply if the statement’s proponent procured or wrongfully caused the declarant’s unavailability as a witness in order to prevent the declarant from attending or testifying.”26 Every Rule 804(b) exception is available only “if the declarant is unavailable as a witness,” and Rule 804(a) says when that condition is met.27 A proponent who engineered the absence therefore cannot show unavailability, and without it no Rule 804(b) exception is open to that proponent.
The limit makes sense once you see why a party might try the maneuver. Rule 804 prefers the live witness. A party may still prefer the out-of-court version, because the declarant may communicate poorly on the stand or may be likely to say something inconsistent with the earlier statement, and so has an incentive to make the witness unavailable.28 An earlier statement is fixed; it cannot waver under cross-examination. If a party could produce the absence and then point to it as proof of necessity, the exceptions would reward the manipulation. The sentence withholds the benefit from the party who arranged it.
Two things must be true before the sentence applies. The proponent must have procured or wrongfully caused the unavailability, and must have done so “in order to prevent the declarant from attending or testifying.”29 The purpose clause confines the sentence to conduct aimed at keeping the witness out of court. Unavailability that arises without the proponent’s hand in it keeps its ordinary effect, and death or a then-existing infirmity remains a recognized ground for any proponent who played no part in it.30
This sentence of Rule 804(a) is the mirror image of forfeiture by wrongdoing; the two provisions work from opposite sides of the same transaction. Rule 804(b)(6) applies to a statement offered against a party that wrongfully caused, or acquiesced in wrongfully causing, the declarant’s unavailability, intending that result, and it removes that party’s hearsay objection.31 Which provision governs depends on whom the declarant’s statement helps. Had Marsh’s statement damaged the plaintiff, and had the plaintiff sent Marsh away to keep it out, the defendant could offer the statement under Rule 804(b)(6) and the plaintiff would have no hearsay objection. Because Marsh’s statement helps the plaintiff, the same act leaves the plaintiff unable to claim unavailability. In both settings the wrongdoer ends up worse off for having silenced the witness.
The contrast, stated compactly:
- Under the last sentence of Rule 804(a), the wrongdoer is the proponent, and the consequence is that the proponent cannot establish unavailability, so no Rule 804(b) exception is open.
- Under Rule 804(b)(6), the wrongdoer is the opponent, and the consequence is that the opponent loses the right to object that the statement is hearsay.
Both provisions apply one principle: a party should not profit from making a witness impossible to produce.32 A wrongdoer on the offering side would gain by turning an absent witness into a favorable record, and a wrongdoer on the objecting side would gain by silencing a witness whose statement would hurt. Each rule closes the door that side would otherwise use, and each requires a purpose: the proponent must have acted “in order to prevent” attendance or testimony, and the opponent must have acted “intending” the declarant’s unavailability.33 Forfeiture strips a right from the wrongdoer and never hands the wrongdoer a benefit, so a party who silenced a witness cannot invoke Rule 804(b)(6) to offer that witness’s statement.