Concept
Near-Miss Statements
Residual hearsay exception and notice
Near-Miss Statements
Some hearsay statements come close to an exception without quite fitting it. A bystander describes an event a few minutes after it happened, too late to be a present sense impression. A mother says that her own failings explain why her son killed so many people; the remark harms her social standing, not her pecuniary or penal interests, so it misses the exception for statements against interest in Rule 804(b)(3).1 Lawyers call these statements near misses, and Rule 807(a) speaks to them directly: a hearsay statement is not excluded “even if the statement is not admissible under a hearsay exception in Rule 803 or 804.”2 The question carries weight because almost every hearsay declaration is addressed, at least peripherally, by one or more of the specific exceptions.3 If resemblance to an exception disqualified a statement from Rule 807, the residual exception would have almost nothing left to do.
Until 2019, the opening condition of Rule 807 reached only hearsay “not specifically covered” by a Rule 803 or 804 exception.4 That phrasing gave the near-miss theory its footing: a statement that an exception addressed, even one that failed a condition of that exception, could be treated as covered and shut out of Rule 807. Most courts rejected the theory, and for good reason.5
Two reasons stand behind that rejection, and both come from what Rule 807 is for. The first is flexibility. The exceptions describe types of statements, and the residual exception lets a judge admit a reliable statement that falls between the types; yet that flexibility vanishes if courts automatically exclude a reliable statement that comes close to, but does not fit, a standard exception.6 The second is the growth of the law. Rule 807 gives courts room to develop patterns of response that could lead to a new specific exception, and the near-miss theory leaves little or no room for that experimentation. Applied uniformly, it would make the price of recognizing a new exception a steady run of statements that should have been received under Rule 807 being rejected as near misses.7
The amendment effective December 1, 2019, settled the matter by replacing “not specifically covered” with “not admissible under.”8 The change makes clear that a statement nearly missing a specific exception can come in under Rule 807 so long as it is trustworthy.9 It also tells the court what to do with the near miss. A court assessing guarantees of trustworthiness “may consider whether the statement is a ‘near-miss’ of one of the Rule 803 or 804 exceptions,” and if it does, it should, in addition to evaluating all relevant guarantees of trustworthiness, “take into account the reasons that the hearsay misses the admissibility requirements of the standard exception.”10 The amended rule thus forecloses two shortcuts. A near miss is not ineligible, which was the pre-2019 error, and it is not admitted automatically, which is the overcorrection.
The reason for the miss matters because an exception’s elements are proxies for reliability. The old test of “equivalent circumstantial guarantees” measured a statement against the guarantees in Rules 803 and 804, but those guarantees vary in strength and nature, and forfeiture by wrongdoing under Rule 804(b)(6) has none at all.11 Immediacy in the present sense impression exception leaves little time to fabricate, and the penal-interest requirement of Rule 804(b)(3) gives a declarant reason to hesitate before saying something damaging. A missing element shows that the usual proxy is absent; it does not show that the guarantee behind the proxy is absent. A statement that misses for an innocuous reason may carry the guarantee some other way, while a statement whose miss is itself a ground for distrust deserves no help from Rule 807. Weighing the reason for the miss avoids both extremes: the failed element opens the door to the residual analysis and then becomes evidence inside it.
A short delay is the plainest harmless miss. Suppose a neighbor with no stake in a dispute tells a landlord, a few minutes after the fact, that she watched a delivery truck back into the landlord’s fence. She spoke too long after the event for a present sense impression. A court weighing the miss asks what the delay signifies, and the answer favors the proponent: a few minutes is a short interval for memory to fade, and a neutral neighbor has no apparent reason to invent the story. Those circumstances can supply much of what immediacy would have guaranteed, so the statement can come in if the court finds sufficient guarantees of trustworthiness and the other conditions of the rule are met. The mother’s statement misses for a reason of the same harmless kind. Rule 804(b)(3) reaches statements against pecuniary or penal interests, and hers is against a social interest.12 The statement is against interest, though not an interest the exception lists, and the miss says nothing about whether she shaded the truth. That makes it a proper candidate for Rule 807 once the near-miss bar is gone.
A miss can also point the other way. Suppose an arrested accomplice tells the police that her partner planned the crime and that she only helped. The accusation points at the partner and shrinks her own role, so it does little to expose her to prosecution. Under Williamson v. United States, a statement made to law enforcement that implicates the accused violates the hearsay rule, and under Crawford it also violates the Confrontation Clause when offered against the accused.13 For Rule 807 purposes, the reason for the miss counts against the proponent. A declarant who speaks to police after an arrest has reason to shift blame and win leniency, so the same circumstances that defeat the exception also undermine trustworthiness. Weighing that reason deepens the doubt instead of relieving it. The Confrontation Clause is a separate limit on criminal prosecutions, taken up in the section on criminal defendants. The neighbor and the accomplice each fail a specific exception, and the difference between them lies entirely in why.
Running the analysis starts with reading the specific exception closely enough to see which element failed. Rule 804(b)(2) shows why precision matters. It admits statements by a person who believes death is imminent about the cause or circumstances that brought about that belief, and the declarant need not actually die.14 A declarant who survives therefore does not miss on that ground. A declarant who instead remarks on an unrelated matter, such as who borrowed his tractor, misses on subject matter, and the court then asks whether that miss says anything about his candor.
The third step does the real work, because it is where the failed element stops being a technical defect and becomes a fact about reliability.