Concept
The Three Underlying Purposes
Rules of construction and application (§ 1-101, et seq.)
The Three Underlying Purposes
The liberal construction mandate leaves one question open: liberal in service of what? Section 1-103(a) answers by naming three purposes that a court reading the Code should keep in view:
- to simplify, clarify, and modernize the law governing commercial transactions;1
- to permit the continued expansion of commercial practices through custom, usage, and agreement of the parties; and2
- to make uniform the law among the various jurisdictions.3
The list gives the mandate something to hold onto. Without it, "liberal" would be a bare instruction with no stated direction. With it, a court can name the purpose a provision serves, test each competing reading against that purpose, and explain its choice in terms both sides can argue about.
It helps to treat the three as yardsticks, each asking a different question of a disputed reading. Does the reading make the rule easier to understand and apply, and does it keep the rule current with how commerce is done? Does it leave room for what parties and merchants actually do, whether that practice comes from custom, from usage, or from the terms the parties agreed on? Does it match how courts in other jurisdictions treat the same enacted text?
The answers need not always point the same way. A reading that welcomes a new commercial practice in one state's courts, for example, can pull that state away from its neighbors. A court therefore has to ask which purpose the provision before it serves, and the answer to that question shapes how broadly or narrowly the language runs.
Each purpose has its own logic and its own typical use in litigation. The sections that follow take them one at a time, starting with simplify, clarify, and modernize.