Concept
Good Faith and Knowledge
General definitions and principles of interpretation (§ 1-201, et seq.)
Good Faith and Knowledge
Two requirements in the definition of "buyer in ordinary course of business" test the buyer's mind rather than the transaction. Under § 1-201(b)(9), the buyer must buy goods "in good faith" and "without knowledge that the sale violates the rights of another person in the goods."1 The definition lists them side by side, so a buyer who satisfies one has not yet satisfied the other.
The two requirements ask different questions. Good faith concerns how the buyer dealt in making the purchase. Knowledge concerns a single fact: whether the buyer knew that the sale violated someone else's rights in the goods. Each is a separate inquiry, and the buyer must pass both.
Two buyers at the same dealership show how the knowledge requirement works. Ines runs a farm and buys a used combine from a dealer that sells farm equipment. A week earlier she overheard the dealer's manager admit that the combine belongs to a customer who left it for repair and never agreed to a sale. Ines pays and drives it home. Because she knew the sale violated the owner's rights, she is not a buyer in ordinary course of business, however routine the sale looked. Tomas buys an identical machine from the same lot and has no such knowledge. For him, the knowledge requirement is no obstacle. He must still meet the rest of the definition: he must buy in the ordinary course from a seller in the business of selling goods of that kind, and he must take possession or have a right to recover the goods from the seller under Article 2.2
Later sections of this chapter show what the status is worth. This unit asks only who can claim it. The subsections that follow take up good faith first and then notice and knowledge, so that you can run each inquiry on a set of facts and keep the two apart.