Concept
Scope Analysis Overview
Subject matter of Article 9 (§ 9-109)
Scope of Article 9
Scope Analysis Overview
Article 9 supplies rules only for transactions that § 9-109 brings within it, so every secured-transactions problem opens with a question of scope. The stakes are practical. Sections 9-308 through 9-316 specify how to perfect a security interest in each kind of transaction the Article covers, and a perfected secured creditor stands nearly as far above an unperfected one in the priority ranking as the unperfected creditor stands above a general creditor.1 Those rules reach only transactions inside the Article.
Section 9-109 works in layers. Subsection (a) lists what the Article covers and makes the list subject to the exclusions in subsections (c) and (d).2 The list has six entries, and each is a separate way into the same body of rules:
- A transaction, regardless of its form, that creates a security interest in personal property or fixtures by contract.3
- An agricultural lien.4
- A sale of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes.5
- A consignment.6
- A security interest arising under the Code's sales provisions, such as a seller's reservation of title to goods delivered to a buyer.7
- A security interest arising under § 4-210 (collecting banks) or § 5-118 (letter-of-credit issuers).8
Entry (1) rests on the definition of a security interest: an interest in personal property or fixtures that secures payment or performance of an obligation. The definition goes on to ask whether a sale of goods with reservation of title in the seller, a lease of goods, or a consignment may create one.9 The definition thus looks past the label to the function, and that explains why the other entries reach transactions that look nothing like a loan agreement. A seller who reserves title to delivered goods obtains, under Article 9, only a reserved security interest. A consignor holds a security interest in the consigned goods. And a sale of rights to payment, long regarded as a financing transaction, has most of the economic characteristics of a personal property financing and is now covered more fully than it was before 1999.10
Article 9 sweeps in these different devices because it was drafted as one scheme. Its aim is a simple and unified structure within which the immense variety of secured financing transactions can proceed at less cost and with more certainty than under pre-Code law, and it supersedes the separate legislation on chattel mortgages, conditional sales, trust receipts, factor's liens, and assignments of accounts receivable.11 A unified structure holds together only if a creditor cannot choose a name that avoids it, and that is why entry (1) reaches a transaction regardless of its form.
Subsections (c) and (d) then take back part of what (a) gave, and they work in different ways. Subsection (c) provides that Article 9 does not apply to the extent that the listed conditions exist, and the words to the extent allow partial displacement.12 A federal statute that addresses only some incidents of a security interest shows the design at work. Such statutes often cover filing clearly but leave open the creation of the interest, priorities, and foreclosure, and when that happens many courts fill the gaps by analogy to Article 9.13
Subsection (d) works by transaction type. It lists transactions to which Article 9 does not apply, and a transaction that fits a listed category leaves the Article altogether.14 The list includes landlords' liens, real-property security interests, statutory and common-law liens, assignments of wages, rights of setoff, and assignments of intangibles made with the sale of a business, for collection only, or where the transferee is to perform the contract. Several entries carry exceptions that pull part of the subject back in. Article 9 still governs the priority of statutory and common-law liens. It covers commercial tort claims even though it excludes personal tort claims. And it reaches health-care insurance obligations owed to a health-care provider even though it excludes insurance generally. Each exclusion is taken up later with its own exception.15
Subsection (b) runs the other way. When a transaction outside Article 9 secures an obligation, such as a real-estate mortgage securing a promissory note, a lender who takes a security interest in the obligation itself still holds an interest that Article 9 governs.16 The mortgage stays outside the Article, and the interest in the note stays inside it.
An exclusion changes which rules apply, and it leaves the validity of the interest to those other rules. A transaction outside Article 9 is governed by other law, so the common law or another statute decides whether a creditor may take an interest in that property and how the creditor protects and enforces it.17 An assignment of wages, one of the listed exclusions, is a case in point.18 Whether the assignment is permitted at all, and on what terms, is a question for that other law and not for Article 9.
The sections that follow take the entries of subsection (a) in turn, then the exclusions in subsections (c) and (d), and finally the carve-back in subsection (b).