Concept
True Consignments
Subject matter of Article 9 (§ 9-109)
True Consignments
In a consignment, the supplier and the retailer agree that title to the inventory stays with the supplier while the retailer acts as the supplier’s agent in selling it.1 Article 9 governs that arrangement because a consignment could be used to circumvent the Article and raises problems similar to those of a secured transaction.2 The doorway is § 9-109(a)(4), which lists “a consignment” among the transactions Article 9 covers.3
That doorway opens wider than the substance-over-form rule discussed earlier. Under § 9-109(a)(1), a consignment in form that is in substance a creation of a security interest is already within Article 9. Paragraph (a)(4) adds many true consignments, because it is very difficult to tell whether a transaction is a true consignment or a disguised security interest. Article 9 therefore defines “consignment” and applies to the transactions that would otherwise be true consignments.4 The classic case is a consignment of diamonds with a duty to sell or return them and no duty to pay for any left unsold.5
The Article cares because a person who consigns merchandise for resale runs the risk of losing it to the consignee’s creditors, and the safest course is to file under Article 9.6 Filing is how the consignor protects itself against the consignee’s trustee in bankruptcy and against later perfected secured creditors.7
Three questions organize everything below. Does the deal meet the statutory definition? If it does, what does inclusion do to the parties? If it does not, what governs instead? The table previews the answers, and the three subsections earn each row.8
| Deal | Route into Article 9 | Rules on default |
|---|---|---|
| Consignment that secures an obligation, such as one requiring the merchant to pay the price whether or not it resells | Security interest under § 9-109(a)(1) | The consignor must follow Part 6 |
| Consignment that meets the § 9-102(a)(20) definition | Consignment under § 9-109(a)(4) | The consignor may recover its goods by any method other state law permits |
| True consignment that misses the definition | None | Other law governs: § 2-326(1) and the state’s common law |
Defining a Consignment
Section 9-102(a)(20) defines a consignment as a transaction in which a person delivers goods to a merchant for the purpose of sale and that also satisfies each of several conditions about the merchant, the goods, and the deal itself.9 A deal that misses any one condition is not a “consignment” as Article 9 uses the word.
The parties’ label does not settle the matter. Article 9 has long looked behind form: a bill of sale absolute on its face may be shown to have been given as security.10 A document headed “consignment” gets the same scrutiny, because a consignment in form that is a disguised security interest is not a “consignment” as Article 9 defines it.11
The first four steps ask about the merchant, and they track a single worry: what the merchant’s creditors can see. Goods on a retailer’s shelves look like the retailer’s goods, and an owner’s unseen claim to some of them can pull value out from under the creditors who lent against the stock. That is the risk that makes the consignor file.12 The definition screens out merchants whose creditors have less reason to be misled, such as a consignee that acts in the consignor’s name and a merchant generally known by its creditors to be substantially engaged in selling the goods of others.13 “Merchant” takes the meaning Article 2 gives it in § 2-104.14
Steps five and six concern the goods. The value floor applies to each delivery and is measured at the time of delivery, so deliveries worth less than $1,000 fall outside the definition.15 The consumer-goods condition is tested immediately before delivery. Suppose a consumer delivers used household goods to a store that sells secondhand goods, on terms that the store will sell them, keep a 10 percent commission, remit the rest, and return anything unsold. Even if a court finds a true consignment that secures no obligation, the deal is outside Article 9, because the goods were consumer goods immediately before delivery.16 Goods a manufacturer holds for sale, by contrast, are not consumer goods in the manufacturer’s hands.
The seventh step keeps the definition from overlapping with the disguised-security-interest route. A deal that creates a security interest securing an obligation, as when the merchant must pay the price whether or not it resells, is not a defined consignment.17 Article 9 treats a seller that retains title until the buyer pays the price as holding a security interest for that price.18 Falling out of the definition for this reason does not take the deal out of Article 9: the consignor still holds a security interest that it must perfect under Article 9, and the only difference is that on default it must comply with Part 6.19
An exam stem that says goods were left “on consignment” asks one question: does the delivery clear every condition? The word in the stem proves nothing. The opposite mistake is to assume that a deal failing a condition lands in Article 9 anyway. A true consignment that misses the definition, such as a delivery of consumer goods or of items worth less than $1,000, is outside Article 9 and is governed by § 2-326(1) and the common law of the particular state.20
Effect of Inclusion
A deal that meets the definition changes character in one sentence of the Code: the consignor’s interest in the goods delivered to the merchant is deemed to be a security interest.22 The characterization is deliberate. In an ordinary consignment the merchant owes nothing for goods it fails to sell, so no loan exists, yet Article 9’s rules for secured parties govern the deal.
The Article’s own vocabulary then assigns the roles. The consignor is the secured party, the consignee is the debtor, and the goods delivered are the collateral.23 A manufacturer that delivers $20,000 of furniture to a showroom selling under its own name is therefore a secured party, the showroom is a debtor, and the furniture is collateral, although the showroom’s only duty is to sell or return the goods.
For perfection and priority, the consignor is treated like any other secured creditor, and it must protect its interest by filing a financing statement.24 In most consignment transactions the consignor should file to protect itself against the consignee’s creditors.25 Furniture on the showroom floor looks like the showroom’s property, so the showroom’s creditors may lend against it without ever seeing the consignor’s claim. A consignor that does not perfect cannot protect itself against the consignee’s trustee in bankruptcy or against other and later perfected secured creditors.26
Filing is the first step but not always the last. A consignor competing with an earlier lender on the consignee’s inventory must also give notification. The notification must state that the consignor expects to deliver goods on consignment to the consignee and must describe the goods by item or type, and it must be given within five years before the consignee receives the goods.27 The priority chapters work through the mechanics.
A consignor unsure whether a deal is a defined consignment or a disguised security transaction can file anyway, under § 9-505. The filing is not itself a factor in deciding whether the consignment is intended as security, and if the deal is determined to be intended as security, the consignor’s attached security interest is perfected by that filing.28 The filing is therefore a precaution and not an admission.
Inclusion does not make the consignor a lender at default. A secured party whose interest arises from a true consignment is generally not subject to the duties of Part 6.29 The restrictive repossession and resale rules that bind other secured creditors do not bind the ordinary consignor, who may get its goods back by whatever method state law outside Article 9 permits.30 A consignment that does secure an obligation is different, and its consignor must follow Part 6.31 A student who reads “deemed a security interest” as “the consignor is a lender” will wrongly import Part 6 into an ordinary consignment.
Effect of Exclusion
A transaction that is a true consignment in substance but misses the definition is not governed by Article 9 and is in effect a bailment.33 This is the mirror image of inclusion. The deeming rule that makes the consignor a secured party and the consignee a debtor operates only on a deal that meets the definition, so a deal outside it receives none of Article 9’s roles or rules.
Other law fills the gap. It controls the rights of consignor and consignee against each other and the rights of the consignee’s creditors to the consignor’s goods while those goods sit in the consignee’s hands.34 Section 2-326(1) governs the deal itself, and the rights of the consignee’s creditors must be determined from the common law of the particular state.35 A consignor in this position cannot rely on Article 9’s perfection and priority rules to settle a contest with those creditors, because the Article never reached the deal.
Four kinds of delivery land here: consignments of consumer goods to a consignment store, consignments of items worth less than $1,000, consignments to a person generally known by its creditors to be substantially engaged in selling the goods, and consignments to a consignee that acts in the consignor’s name.36 A delivery to an auctioneer misses the definition for the same kind of reason. The household-goods example shows the result concretely: the consumer’s goods were consumer goods immediately before delivery, so other law controls the rights of the consumer and the store against each other and the rights of the store’s creditors to the goods.37
This exclusion works differently from the express carve-outs in subsection (d), which later sections take up. Subsection (d) removes named transactions from the Article, such as an assignment of an interest in a deposit account in a consumer transaction (unless the account is proceeds of other collateral) and the right of recoupment or setoff (except for certain priority questions).38 A consignment that misses the definition leaves the Article by failing the test in § 9-102(a)(20), and no separate carve-out is needed.
The commission, the return of unsold goods, and the resale setting are the same in the potter’s deal and in the household-goods deal. The character of the goods immediately before delivery does the work, and it alone moves one transaction into Article 9 and leaves the other to other law.
Exclusion from the definition does not always take a deal out of the Article. A transaction that misses the definition only because it creates a security interest securing an obligation stays within Article 9 through paragraph (a)(1), and its consignor is still a holder of a security interest who must perfect it, with the one difference that Part 6 governs default.39 Only a deal that secures no obligation and also misses another condition leaves Article 9 altogether. The usual exam error is to stop at the word “consignment” and apply Article 9, or to spot a failed condition and declare that the consignor has no rights. The excluded consignor does have rights, and they come from bailment law, § 2-326(1), and state common law instead of from Article 9.