Concept
Security Interests Under Other Articles
Subject matter of Article 9 (§ 9-109)
Security Interests Under Other Articles
Five liens created by other articles of the UCC come within Article 9 through § 9-109(a)(5) and (a)(6). Paragraph (a)(5) applies Article 9 to a security interest arising under § 2-401, § 2-505, § 2-711(3), or § 2A-508(5), “as provided in Section 9-110”; paragraph (a)(6) applies it to one arising under § 4-210 or § 5-118.1 Each section gives a party a lien in one commercial setting. The five holders are the seller who keeps title when it delivers goods on credit, the seller who ships under reservation, the buyer or lessee holding goods it has rightfully rejected, the collecting bank that has advanced credit against an item, and the issuer of a letter of credit that has honored a presentation.2
None of the five rests on the debtor’s agreement. Each arises by operation of law, so the security interest attaches to the collateral even though the debtor has signed no security agreement.3 That is the difference from the ordinary case, since most consensual security interests in goods arise under Article 9 itself and not under Article 2.4
Article 9 takes these interests in because the Code makes the Article 2 interests subject to it as well as to Article 2 on sales, with the exceptions set out in § 9-110.5 The reach is partial: Article 9 governs some of the security interests created under Articles 2, 4, and 5, along with agricultural liens, consignments, and sales of certain intangibles.6 Agricultural liens show how the categories differ, since Article 9 governs them although the Code does not denominate them security interests.7
Section 9-110 relaxes Article 9’s ordinary requirements for the Article 2 and 2A interests, but only until the debtor obtains possession of the goods.8 Until then, the interest is enforceable without a security agreement, needs no filing, and has priority over other security interests the debtor created.9 The reasons follow from how the interests arise. They are non-consensual, so it makes sense to dispense with the security agreement. They also depend on the debtor’s not having possession of the goods, so it makes sense to dispense with filing and to grant priority over the debtor’s other secured creditors.10 The collecting bank and the letter-of-credit issuer find their relief from the agreement requirement in their own sections, § 4-210(c)(1) and § 5-118(b)(1), and paragraph (a)(6), unlike paragraph (a)(5), makes no reference to § 9-110.11
The relief ends because its reasons end. Once the debtor has the goods, the seller’s claim is no different from that of any other consensual creditor and depends on the conventional rules of attachment and perfection.12 A seller who sells goods and purports to retain a security interest, but files no financing statement, is then an unperfected secured creditor—and perhaps less.13 A written security agreement becomes necessary at that point.14 The parties remain free to agree by contract to a security interest in the same assets.15 The subsections below take each interest in turn.
Retained Title
Delivery passes title to the buyer, whatever the sales contract says about title, and what the seller keeps is a security interest in the goods that secures the price.17 Section 9-109(a)(5) brings that interest into Article 9 by naming § 2-401, “as provided in Section 9-110.”18 Article 2 limits the effect of a seller’s retention or reservation of title in goods shipped or delivered to the buyer to a reservation of a security interest, and § 2A-508(5) treats leases similarly.19 A sale of goods in which the seller expressly keeps title until the buyer pays the price is therefore a secured transaction within Article 9.20
The Code reduces the clause to a security interest because a credit seller’s real stake is a claim on the goods if the price goes unpaid, and a security interest describes exactly that stake. Under pre-Code law such a transaction was often treated as a conditional sale; the Code keeps the seller’s protection and drops the ownership label.21 The approach matches the rest of Article 9. The name on a document does not decide whether it is a security agreement, and its substance does.22 A “sale” of accounts is likewise treated as the creation of a security interest in them.23
A store that sells a piano on credit under a document saying “title shall remain in Store until all of the payments are made” has made a secured transaction. Title passes despite the language, the seller is a secured party, and the buyer is a debtor.24 An installment sale with a title clause works the same way: the buyer takes title, and all the seller retains is a security interest in the goods.25 Because the interest secures the price, it protects the seller only while some of the price remains owing.26
Whether the buyer has taken possession decides what the seller must do to protect itself. While the buyer lacks the goods, § 9-110 applies: the interest is enforceable without a security agreement, needs no filing, and has priority over a conflicting security interest the buyer created.27 When the buyer receives possession and the seller has reserved title or a security interest for the price, Article 9 applies fully and a written security agreement is necessary.28 A seller who has delivered, reserved title, and filed no financing statement is an unperfected secured creditor, and perhaps less.29
The relief belonged to the period before delivery, and delivery ends it. A retained-title problem therefore turns on two facts, whether any price is unpaid and whether the buyer has the goods, and it can be run as a short sequence.
Shipment Under Reservation
A seller who ships goods by carrier can reserve a security interest in them, and the form of the bill of lading decides whether it has. Section 9-109(a)(5) brings the interest that arises under § 2-505 into Article 9, as provided in § 9-110.33 The bill of lading is a document of title covered by Article 7. It typically describes the goods and states where they are to be delivered, and it is either negotiable or nonnegotiable.34 Form matters because a carrier follows its document. A bill in the right form requires the carrier to obey the seller’s instructions about the goods, so the seller keeps control of them until it is paid even though it has surrendered physical possession.35 Article 2 treats that retained control as a security interest for the price, and the interest arises by operation of law, so the seller needs no signed security agreement for it.36
Three bills show how the form decides the result.
- A negotiable bill states on its face that the goods are deliverable “to the order of” a named person or “to bearer.” A seller who takes a negotiable bill to its own order, or to bearer, has shipped under reservation. The carrier should not release the goods until the buyer pays the seller and the seller hands over the bill, which the buyer can then present to the carrier.37
- A nonnegotiable bill naming the seller or the seller’s nominee as the person to whom the goods are to be delivered is also a shipment under reservation. If the seller names its agent in the buyer’s city, the carrier should not release the goods until the buyer remits the price and the agent gives the bill to the buyer.38
- A nonnegotiable bill naming the buyer is not a shipment under reservation. The seller has no security interest, Article 2 obliges it to provide the bill to the buyer, and the carrier may release the goods to the buyer on it.39
The sale, the carrier, and the price are identical in all three deals. What changes the result is whom the bill sends the goods to, the seller’s side or the buyer.
A breach of the sales contract does not cost the seller this protection. Even if the shipment breaches the contract with the buyer, the seller’s rights under the documents are not impaired.40 The rule keeps two questions apart: whether the seller performed its contract, and whether the seller controls the goods. While the buyer has not obtained possession, § 9-110 supplies the usual relief. The interest is enforceable without a signed security agreement, needs no filing, and has priority over a conflicting security interest the buyer created.41 Once the seller releases the goods to the buyer, that relief ends and the ordinary rules of attachment and perfection govern.
Two errors recur on this topic. One is to treat any shipment by carrier as a shipment under reservation, when the question is whom the bill names. The other is to assume that a breach by the seller defeats its interest.
Rejected Goods
A buyer who rightfully and effectively rejects delivered goods, or justifiably revokes its acceptance of them, takes a security interest in the goods it holds. Section 9-109(a)(5) brings that interest, which arises under § 2-711(3), into Article 9, together with the lessee’s parallel interest under § 2A-508(5), each “as provided in Section 9-110.”46 The interest covers goods in the buyer’s possession or control and secures the debt the seller owes the buyer: the price already refunded-for and the expenses of transportation, care, and custody.47 Like the retained-title and shipment interests, it arises by operation of law, and no one signs a security agreement to create it.48
The lien answers the position rejection leaves the buyer in. The buyer has usually paid something, and it now holds goods it does not want while the seller owes it a refund and the cost of looking after the goods. A bare contract claim is worth only as much as the seller’s willingness to pay, whereas a security interest lets the buyer look to the goods in its hands.49
In the standard illustration, B pays 25 percent of the price and takes delivery, only to find that the goods do not conform to the contract. B rightfully and effectively rejects them and holds them. B now has a security interest in the goods in its possession that secures the return of the 25 percent down payment, and it secures the seller’s obligation for whatever B spends on reasonable care of the goods. Article 9 governs the interest.50 A lessee who rejects goods delivered under a lease, or justifiably revokes its acceptance, has the same kind of interest. It secures rent already paid, security deposits made, and the lessee’s expenses of transportation, care, and custody.51
The interest lasts only while the buyer or lessee has possession or control of the goods, because the statute grants it in goods “in its possession or control.”52 The lien draws its value from the holder’s hold on the goods, and when that hold is given up, the leverage leaves with the goods.
The roles here run opposite to the retained-title case. The seller owes the refund, so the seller is the debtor and the buyer is the secured party. Section 9-110’s relief lasts until the debtor obtains possession of the goods, and a buyer who holds rejected goods means the seller does not.53 During that period the buyer’s interest is enforceable without a security agreement from the seller, needs no filing, and has priority over a conflicting security interest the seller created.54 The seller’s consent is not at issue, and goods that have left the seller’s hands give its other creditors nothing to be misled by.
Article 9 does not decide whether the buyer or lessee was entitled to reject or revoke. Articles 2 and 2A decide that, and the interest exists only if they decide it in the buyer’s or lessee’s favor.55 Two mistakes follow from forgetting this. One is to give a lien to any buyer who is merely unhappy with the goods, when the interest requires an effective rejection or revocation. The other is to ask for a signed security agreement, when this interest arises without one.
Collecting Banks
A collecting bank that gives its customer withdrawable credit against a deposited item holds a security interest in the item while it keeps the item for collection. Section 9-109(a)(6) brings that interest, which arises under § 4-210, into Article 9.57 During collection, items such as checks and drafts, and accompanying documents such as documents of title, are in the bank’s possession. The bank has a security interest in them until it receives final settlement or releases possession for a purpose other than collection, and the interest secures the amounts the bank has given as withdrawable credit against the item.58 The interest attaches when withdrawable credit is given.59
The lien exists because of the timing of check collection. A customer deposits a check drawn on another bank, and the customer’s bank has not yet been paid. If it lets the customer withdraw the money, it has advanced its own funds against a payment that may never arrive. Where Bank B lets A draw against a check drawn by D on Bank C before collection, B holds a security interest in the check, which it may enforce against the drawer D if Bank C does not pay.60 In Article 9’s terms the bank is the secured party, the customer who drew against the item is the debtor, and the item is the collateral.61
The bank needs no signed paper to have the interest. No security agreement is necessary as long as the bank has not received final settlement for the item or given up possession or control of it for a purpose other than collection.62 That relief comes from § 4-210 itself and not from § 9-110, which paragraph (a)(6) does not mention.63 The standard illustration runs as follows. A deposits a check, the bank gives credit, and A withdraws cash against it. As long as the bank has the check, or has released it solely to collect from the drawee bank, the bank holds a security interest in the check securing the amount withdrawn.64 Forwarding the check to the paying bank does not end the interest, because collection is the very process the lien supports.
The interest lasts only as long as the risk it covers. It ends when the bank receives final settlement for the item or releases possession for a purpose other than collection.65 Final settlement removes the bank’s exposure, and a release for some other purpose gives up the hold that made the lien useful.
A student who asks where the signed security agreement is has applied the ordinary consensual rules to an interest that arises by operation of law. A student who keeps the lien alive after final settlement has forgotten that it protects only a credit that is still exposed.
Letter-of-Credit Issuers
An issuer or nominated person that honors a presentation under a letter of credit holds a security interest in the documents presented, to the extent it has given value for the presentation or paid under the terms of the credit and has not been reimbursed. Paragraph (a)(6) brings that interest, which arises under § 5-118, into Article 9.67 When a presentation of documents is made, the issuer (defined in § 5-102(a)(9)) or a nominated person (defined in § 5-102(a)(11)) takes possession of the documents.68 The interest, like the collecting bank’s, arises by operation of law and not by contract.
The lien follows from what payment does to the parties’ positions. An issuer that honors a complying presentation pays the beneficiary out of its own funds and is entitled to be reimbursed for the payment.69 Until reimbursement arrives, the issuer holds only a promise, and the documents in its hands can include documents of title that control goods. The security interest ties the two together. The debt the issuer is owed and the paper it holds come from the same payment, so the issuer can look to that paper for its money.
The interest needs no signed security agreement. A security agreement is not necessary to attach it as long as the issuer has not been reimbursed for or otherwise recovered the value given under the letter of credit.70 The relief comes from § 5-118(b)(1), and paragraph (a)(6) makes no mention of § 9-110.71 The documents covered are those Article 5 defines, a category broader than documents of title.72
In the standard illustration, a bank issues a letter of credit, the beneficiary presents documents that comply with its terms, and the bank pays the amount due. The bank holds a security interest in the presented documents for as long as it has not been reimbursed, and Article 9 governs that interest.73 The interest has a beginning and an end. It begins when the issuer gives value for the presentation or honors it, so an issuer that has paid nothing has no payment for the interest to secure. It ends when the issuer is reimbursed or otherwise recovers what it gave.74
Students tend to err in one of two ways. Some demand a security agreement that the interest does not require. Others treat the bank’s continued possession of the documents as proof of a continuing lien. The question to ask is whether the issuer has paid and has not yet recovered.