Concept
Agricultural Liens
Subject matter of Article 9 (§ 9-109)
Agricultural Liens
Article 9 reaches one kind of nonconsensual lien, the agricultural lien. Section 9-109(a)(2) applies the Article to “an agricultural lien,”1 a lien that a statute gives a farm creditor without any agreement from the farmer. Paragraph (a)(1) covers only interests the debtor creates by contract, so this lien enters on its own footing. The 1999 revision added it as a subset of the statutory lien.2 The Montana Supreme Court has observed that revised Article 9, unlike the original, “also brings within its scope non-possessory agricultural liens.”3
Article 9 takes the lien in only for certain purposes, namely perfection and priority.4 A statute other than Article 9 creates the lien. The lien is perfected once it is effective under that statute and a proper financing statement has been filed centrally.5 Priority follows the ordinary Code rules unless the creating statute says otherwise, because a perfected agricultural lien outranks a security interest or another agricultural lien in the same collateral if its statute so provides.6 Later chapters work through those rules. This section asks the threshold scope question: which liens count as agricultural liens?
Elements of the Definition
The definition in § 9-102(a)(5) has several parts, and a lien must satisfy all of them to come within paragraph (a)(2).7
The first step separates the agricultural lien from everything else. A lien that exists only at common law is not an agricultural lien, however closely it resembles one in other respects.11 A farm lender also fails this step. The lender’s claim rests on a security agreement covering farm products, so it is an ordinary security interest created by agreement, and the lender does not hold an agricultural lien.12
The second step ties the lien to farming. Almost all agricultural liens run in favor of landlords, who are owed rent, and trade creditors who sell goods such as feed and seed or provide services such as custom cutting and veterinary care.13 The debt itself generally arises from a contract between the farmer and the lienholder, while the lien arises from the legislature.14 Suppose S sells feed on credit to A, who keeps a dairy herd. Under state law outside Article 9, A’s obligation to pay for the feed is secured by a lien on the livestock that eat it. The lien arises automatically, and S need not hold the herd to have it, so it is an agricultural lien.15 The same analysis applies when L rents 640 acres to A for soybeans and wheat and a state statute secures A’s rent with a lien on the crops raised on the land.16
The third step asks whether the lienholder must hold the farm products to keep the lien. S’s lien on the herd survives while the cows stay on A’s farm, and L’s lien on the crops survives while the crops stay in A’s fields. A lien that lasts only while the creditor keeps the goods in hand does not qualify.
The feed supplier’s lien and the feedlot’s lien differ on exactly one fact. The supplier’s lien follows the herd and needs no possession, so it falls within paragraph (a)(2). The feedlot’s lien ends when the cattle leave the pens, so it does not.
Farm Products
The lien must be an interest in farm products, which § 9-102(a)(34) defines as goods with respect to which the debtor is engaged in a farming operation. Crops grown, growing, or to be grown qualify, as does livestock, born or unborn. Supplies used or produced in a farming operation and products of crops or livestock in their unmanufactured states qualify as well. Standing timber does not.17 A farming operation means raising, cultivating, propagating, fattening, grazing, or any other activity considered farming, so the debtor must be the one producing the goods in question.18
The boundary falls where the farm’s output stops being raw product. A dairy operator’s cows and the milk they give are farm products. Cheese the operator makes from that milk is not, because it is no longer a product of livestock in its unmanufactured state, and it may be the dairy’s inventory instead.19 A statutory lien on cheese, on standing timber, or on a farmer’s tractor therefore fails at this step even when the statute, the supplier, and the nonpossessory feature are all in place.20 Do not assume that because the debtor is a farmer, everything the farmer owns is a farm product.
Labels and Effect
Once a lien qualifies, Article 9 gives the parties its familiar names. The agricultural lienholder is a secured party, the person with a property interest in the farm products other than a security interest or lien is the debtor, and the farm products are the collateral.21 When L holds a statutory lien on the crops for the rent on the 640 acres, L is the secured party, A is the debtor, and the crops are the collateral.22 The Article has used the same device before. A “sale” of accounts is treated as the creation of a security interest, so the seller is a “debtor” and the buyer a “secured party,” although neither mentioned a security interest.23
The lien is still not a security interest. The Code’s definition of that term does not include an agricultural lien, and Article 9’s provisions directed to security interests do not apply to it.24 The reason is the one that opened this section: Article 9 does not apply to a nonconsensual lien on personal property, and the agricultural lien is a deliberate exception that reaches it for specified purposes.25 Two errors follow from forgetting this. A student who asks whether the farmer signed a security agreement has applied the consensual rules to a lien that needs no signature. A student who assumes Article 9 decides whether the lien exists has given the statute’s job to the Article.
The practical result concerns perfection. A lienholder such as Barley, whose lien qualifies, perfects by filing a financing statement covering the collateral in the jurisdiction where the collateral is located and in the filing office that state designates.26
Liens Outside the Definition
The boundary is easiest to see from the failing side. A repair shop services a farmer’s tractor, and under state law the shop holds a lien on the tractor for the repair bill so long as it keeps possession. A bank also holds an Article 9 security interest in the tractor. The shop’s lien is not an agricultural lien, because the tractor is not farm products and because the lien depends on possession. Article 9 governs only the priority contest between the shop and the bank.27
Two landlords show how much turns on the farming connection. A landlord who leases land to a farmer and holds a statutory crop lien for the rent has an agricultural lien. A landlord of an apartment who holds a statutory lien on a tenant’s personal property for unpaid rent does not, because Article 9 does not apply to a landlord’s lien except for an agricultural lien.28 Both are statutory landlord liens, and what separates them is the farming operation and the farm products.
A farm-lien problem should therefore begin with the lien’s source. If only the common law supports it, the analysis ends there.29 If a statute created it, the analysis moves on to the lienholder, the possession requirement, and the character of the property.