Concept
Security in Secured Obligations
Subject matter of Article 9 (§ 9-109)
Security in Secured Obligations
Subsection (b) of § 9-109 closes the scope analysis with a rule for layered financing: “The application of this article to a security interest in a secured obligation is not affected by the fact that the obligation is itself secured by a transaction or interest to which this article does not apply.”1 A secured obligation is a debt that already has collateral behind it, such as a loan backed by a mortgage. The subsection speaks to a second creditor, one step removed, who takes an interest in that debt to secure a different loan. Subsections (c) and (d) remove transactions from the Article, and subsection (b) stops an exclusion that fits the lower financing from traveling upward to a separate financing of the debt it supports.
Three parties make the layers visible. A owns land, borrows from B, signs a promissory note, and gives B a mortgage on the land. The transaction in which A issues the note and mortgage to B is not governed by Article 9.2 B then borrows from C and grants C a security interest in A’s note and the mortgage. That second transaction is within Article 9, even though a mortgage secures the debt C takes as collateral.3 The mortgage sits behind both deals, so what changes the answer is what each creditor takes.
B takes an interest in A’s land. C takes an interest in B’s contract rights under the mortgage, which is the obligation A owes B, and C is not attempting to get an interest in the real estate. That attempt is subject to Article 9.4 The result follows from the Article’s starting point. Article 9 applies to every transaction that creates a security interest in personal property, and the Code defines a security interest broadly as an “interest in personal property or fixtures that secures payment or performance of an obligation.”5
A note secured by a mortgage invites the argument that the note takes on the character of the land, and In re Maryville Savings & Loan Corp. shows a court sorting the two apart. The court reconciled the real estate exclusion with the general coverage of security interests in personal property (§§ 9-102(3) and 9-104(j) under the older numbering) by holding that Article 9 applied to the promissory notes but not to the deeds of trust.6 That result tracks the Article’s reach over any transaction, regardless of its form, intended to create a security interest in personal property.7
Subsection (b) decides which law governs C’s interest in the payment right, and it leaves the land where it was. For C to enforce its rights as an assignee of the mortgage against the real estate, C must use real property law.8 The comment quoted in Maryville draws the same line. Whether the transfer of the collateral for the note, the mortgagee’s interest in Blackacre, requires further action, such as recording an assignment of the mortgagee’s interest, “is left to real estate law.”9
The split has practical consequences for a lender. Suppose C is asked to lend $1 million to a mortgagee who holds only three mortgages of $400,000 each. If the mortgagee has not recorded a mortgage, C is open to challenge by later purchasers of and lenders against the real estate, and recording in the real estate records is what protects against them.10 C should therefore get the mortgagee’s warranty that the mortgages are properly recorded. With only three mortgages, C might also search the real estate records itself, because the search costs little and all of its eggs are in one basket. A lender buying a hundred or a thousand notes could more reasonably rely on the warranty alone.11
The rule is written in general terms, and nothing in it confines it to mortgages.
Subsection (b) removes only one reason for exclusion, which is the security behind the debt. It does not exempt the transfer of the debt from exclusions that apply to the transfer itself. Article 9 does not apply, for instance, to a transfer of a single promissory note to an assignee in full or partial satisfaction of a preexisting indebtedness.12 If B hands C one mortgage note in payment of what B already owes C, that exclusion governs the transfer, and the mortgage behind the note does not bring it back in.
The third step is where analysis goes wrong. A reader who sees a mortgage in the facts and stops at the real estate exclusion has applied the exclusion to the wrong layer, and a reader who takes subsection (b) to pull the land itself into the Article has erred the other way. The exclusion answers the question about the interest in the land, and subsection (b) answers the question about the interest in the debt.