Concept
Possessory Security Interests
Perfection of security interests in multiple state transactions (§ 9-301)
Possessory Security Interests
Section 9-301(2) makes one exception to the debtor-location default: while collateral is located in a jurisdiction, that jurisdiction’s local law governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and the priority of a possessory security interest in the collateral.1 The pledge is the familiar case. Under the 1999 Code, a security interest in collateral that the secured party holds is perfected without filing, and no written record of the security agreement is needed.2 Because possession perfects without a filing, no filing office is at stake, and the law of the place where the collateral sits answers all three questions.3
The situs rule costs a creditor nothing so long as the creditor remains in possession.4 Goods left with the debtor are different: they can cross state lines without public notice, and in most circumstances only the debtor will know.5 That contrast helps explain why the default rule follows the debtor and this exception follows the goods.
The method of perfection, not the kind of collateral, decides whether subsection (2) applies. The subsection selects the law of the goods’ location only for a possessory security interest, so it does not apply when perfection depends on filing or control or when the security interest attaches automatically.6 Possession perfects only some collateral. The 1999 Code allows it for goods, instruments, negotiable documents, money, and tangible chattel paper, but not for accounts, commercial tort claims, deposit accounts, investment property, or letter-of-credit rights.7 A secured party in investment property, for example, either files a financing statement or takes control.8 Had the pawnshop left the necklace with the debtor and relied on a filed financing statement, the debtor-location rule, which governs most nonpossessory security interests, would apply instead.9
Because collateral always sits somewhere, subsection (2) invites misuse, and the first question must be whether the secured party holds the collateral. Consider an Ohio court deciding a secured creditor’s rights against goods in Ohio that belong to a company doing business in Ohio but incorporated in Illinois. The court does not apply Ohio law to perfection. Sections 9-301(1) and 9-307 send it to Illinois law to see whether the creditor filed the proper documents in the proper place, which here is Springfield.10 The goods’ presence in Ohio matters later. If the creditor filed properly in Illinois, Ohio grants it the rights and priority of a perfected secured creditor under Ohio law, and Ohio law decides any priority contest with another creditor or a judicial lien holder.11
In practice the subsection seldom decides anything. Most secured transactions are nonpossessory, so the rule rarely applies,12 and because every state has adopted Revised Article 9, what suffices to perfect by possession in one state does not differ significantly from what suffices in another.13
Subsection (2) is one of several exceptions to the debtor-location default. For nonpossessory interests, the others cover fixture filings, timber to be cut, and as-extracted collateral,14 and Article 9 adds choice-of-law rules of its own for deposit accounts (the bank’s jurisdiction) and for agricultural liens on farm products (the location of the farm products).15 Later sections take these up. Outside the exceptions, the debtor’s location decides, and the rest of this unit shows how the Code fixes that location for individuals, unregistered organizations, registered organizations, and foreign debtors.
Individual Debtors
Except as otherwise provided, Section 9-301(1) sends perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and priority to the law of the jurisdiction where the debtor is located, so the filing state depends on how Section 9-307 locates the debtor.17 For an individual, the answer is the principal residence.18 That test covers business assets as well as personal ones: Comment 2 to Section 9-307 deems an individual debtor located at the individual’s principal residence “with respect to both personal and business assets.”19
The rule matters most for the sole proprietor. A sole proprietorship has no separate legal existence, so the owner is the debtor, and filing belongs in the state of the owner’s principal residence.20 A lender taking a security interest in the inventory and equipment of a Missouri appliance store therefore files in Kansas if the owner lives in Kansas.21 Where the store stands and where its stock sits drop out of the analysis. Former Section 9-103 reasoned differently, building its rules on the premise that filing for goods should normally be where the goods are.22
The Code does not define principal residence, so a debtor with several homes presents a question of fact. An individual who lives most of the year in a Nebraska home and winters in a Florida home is located in Nebraska. If the individual spends about four months a year in each of homes in Colorado, Illinois, and Hawaii, the answer turns on indicators such as where the individual pays taxes and registers to vote.23 A creditor unsure where the debtor is located should file in each candidate state.24
Unregistered Organizations
An organization has no residence, so Section 9-307(b) looks to where it does business: an organization with one place of business is located there, and an organization with more than one is located at its chief executive office.26 The Code’s term organization includes a corporation, an estate, a trust, and a partnership,27 but these two tests reach only organizations that are not registered organizations organized under a State’s law, because the rule for registered organizations takes precedence.28 A general partnership falls within the tests and is located by its chief executive office.29
Without a state of registration to point to, the Code locates such a debtor by where it actually operates. A partnership that operates from one place is located there, and the chief-executive-office test sorts out the partnership that operates from several.
The chief-executive-office test descends from the old chief-place-of-business rule, which usually pointed to the chief executive office and was not always clear. The old rule was hardest to apply to a modern company whose chief executive worked in one city part of the week and another the rest of the week, while the remaining executives sat in a third.30 Registration removes that question for corporations and the other registered organizations,31 but an unregistered organization still turns on where its executive office sits. A creditor who cannot tell which state is correct should file in each candidate state.32
The location can also move. A general partnership with its chief executive office in Pennsylvania is located there, and a lender perfects by filing in Pennsylvania. If the partnership later moves its office to New Jersey, its location changes, but the Pennsylvania filing continues to perfect for four months after the move, a rule a later section develops.33
Because the place-of-business tests are expressly subject to the rule that locates a registered organization in its state of organization, an incorporated debtor never reaches them.34 The sound order of analysis therefore asks first whether the debtor is a registered organization, the subject of the next subsection.
Registered Organizations
Section 9-307(e) fixes the location of a registered organization in one sentence: “A registered organization that is organized under the law of a State is located in that State.”36 Section 9-301(1) then sends perfection to that State’s law,37 so the financing statement goes to that State’s filing office, wherever the borrower keeps its offices, employees, and collateral.
A registered organization is usually an organization organized under the law of a single state, which must maintain a public record of the organization.38 Corporations are the obvious case,39 and limited partnerships and limited liability companies qualify too.40 Because the place-of-business tests are expressly made subject to this rule, a registered organization never reaches them.41
The rule replaces a question that searchers could not reliably answer. Before the 1999 revision, a debtor was located at its chief place of business, and that place was unclear for a modern company whose chief executive worked in one city part of the week and another the rest of the week, while the remaining executives sat in a third.42 Registration turns the question into a lookup, and for corporations and the other registered organizations all the ambiguity about location disappears.43 The location is also stable. It is far less likely to change than the old indicia, and a change of the state of organization usually leaves a trail of public notices, whereas goods can cross a state line with no public notice at all.44
The state of organization controls whatever the entity does elsewhere. A corporation incorporated in Illinois is located in Illinois even if its principal office and all of its business are in California, and an Ohio corporation is likewise located in Ohio.45 A corporation organized under Delaware law with its exclusive or chief offices in New York is located in Delaware.46 Acme, Inc. is incorporated in Delaware but does business and keeps all of its collateral in California. When it grants a security interest to a California bank, the bank must file in Delaware.47 The Ohio court in the earlier example followed the same path: the company did business in Ohio, but Sections 9-301(1) and 9-307 sent the court to Illinois, the state of incorporation, to learn whether the creditor had filed in the right place.48
A dispute over oil sold to the SemGroup entities shows how firmly the rule operates. SemGroup and its affiliates were registered in Delaware or Oklahoma, so the local law of Delaware or Oklahoma governed perfection, not the law of Texas or Kansas.49 The claimants relied on automatic-perfection laws of Texas and Kansas, but the court found that nothing in those laws necessarily displaces the rest of Article 9. The laws apply when the debtor is located in Texas or Kansas, or when the debtor is so closely involved at the wellhead that it has a preexisting interest in the oil before extraction, which makes the oil as-extracted collateral.50 The debtors’ place of registration set the governing law, and the claimants’ home-state statutes did not control.
The rule reaches only an organization registered in a State. A corporation organized under Panamanian law with its chief executive office in Florida is not a registered organization for this purpose, so the place-of-business tests apply and place it in Florida.51 Set beside a Delaware corporation with the same Florida office, whose lender files in Delaware, the Panamanian corporation shows how much work the word State does. Organizations registered under federal law follow separate subsections of Section 9-307, which essentially require filing in the District of Columbia.52 The next subsection explains a further limit: even a place-of-business location abroad can be displaced.
Foreign Debtors
The ordinary location tests do not stop at the border. An individual’s principal residence, a sole place of business, or a chief executive office can lie in a foreign country, and a debtor located there would ordinarily be governed by that country’s law.54 A further rule in Section 9-307 interrupts that result when the foreign location offers searchers nothing to search. If the ordinary tests place the debtor in a jurisdiction that does not “generally require[ ] information concerning the existence of a nonpossessory security interest to be made generally available in a filing, recording, or registration system as a condition or result of the security interest’s obtaining priority over the rights of a lien creditor with respect to the collateral,” the ordinary tests do not apply, and the debtor is deemed located in the District of Columbia.55 Every State has adopted Article 9 and satisfies the condition, so the fallback matters in practice only for a debtor whose ordinary location is in a foreign country that lacks such a requirement.56
The condition asks whether outsiders can discover a security interest. A country that lets a security interest arise in ways third parties cannot ascertain, such as through title retention agreements, fails the condition.57 A country that makes a security interest’s priority over a lien creditor depend on a public record passes it.
The District of Columbia location is a fiction, but its purpose is plain. Full disclosure requires a filing somewhere public, and if the foreign system offers none, the Code supplies one.58 A creditor that files a financing statement with the clerk in the District protects its rights against third parties within the United States.59
The same sequence produces unexpected results for a corporation organized outside the United States. A corporation organized under a State’s law is located in that State, but one organized abroad is not organized under the law of a State, so the registered-organization rule does not apply and the place-of-business tests decide.60 Those tests look to the sole place of business or the chief executive office, and they honor that country only if its law requires public availability. If it does, the corporation is located there, whether or not its country of organization has a registry. If it does not, the corporation is located in the District of Columbia, however good the registry in its country of organization. A corporation organized in a country with a public registry but run from a country without one is therefore located in the District of Columbia; reverse the countries, and the corporation is located where it is run.
Because these results are far from intuitive, a creditor dealing with a foreign debtor in a close case should file in the District of Columbia as well. As with any uncertain location, the prudent course is to file in more than one place.61