Concept
As-Extracted Collateral
Perfection of security interests in multiple state transactions (§ 9-301)
As-Extracted Collateral
Oil, gas, and other minerals in the ground are bound up with the land, and Article 9 chooses their governing law accordingly. Section 9-301(4) provides that the local law of the jurisdiction in which the wellhead or minehead is located governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and the priority of a security interest in as-extracted collateral.1 Subsection (3) looks to the place where goods, instruments, and similar collateral are located, but it opens with the words "Except as otherwise provided in paragraph (4)," so paragraph (4) controls whenever the collateral is as-extracted.2
"As-extracted collateral" is a defined term, and the definition has two parts. Section 9-102(a)(6) covers, first, oil, gas, or other minerals subject to a security interest that a debtor having an interest in the minerals before extraction creates and that attaches to the minerals as extracted. It covers, second, accounts arising out of the sale at the wellhead or minehead of oil, gas, or other minerals in which the debtor had an interest before extraction.3 The wellhead state's law governs the accounts as well as the minerals.4 Both parts turn on one fact: the debtor held an interest in the minerals before they were extracted. An operator that holds a working interest in a lease and pledges its future production illustrates the point, because the lender's interest attaches as the minerals come out of the ground and rests on the operator's pre-extraction interest.
The wellhead rule follows from the collateral's tie to real property. Minerals, oil, gas, and the accounts that result from their sale bear a close relationship to real property, as do timber to be cut and fixtures.5 The filing rule reflects that tie: for as-extracted collateral, a financing statement goes to the office designated for filing or recording a mortgage on the related real property, while the usual filing goes to a central state office.6 Placing the governing law at the wellhead keeps the law and the filing office in the same state. The pre-extraction-interest requirement then confines the exception to debtors whose stake in the minerals was tied to the land before extraction.
In re SemCrude L.P. shows where the definition ends. Oil producers there claimed security interests in oil, and the court held that the oil did not qualify as as-extracted collateral: for oil to qualify, a debtor must have a preexisting interest in it before it is extracted at the wellhead.7 Because the exception was unavailable, the court applied the debtor-location rule. SemGroup and its affiliates were registered in Delaware or Oklahoma, and a registered organization is located in the state where it is registered, so Delaware or Oklahoma law governed perfection, not Texas or Kansas law.8 Both states require perfection by filing a financing statement, and because the producers never filed, their interests were unperfected.9
The recurring error is to hear "oil" and "wellhead" and file where the oil comes out of the ground. The exception depends on the debtor's relationship to the minerals before extraction, so identify the debtor first, as the party that granted the security interest, and ask whether that party held an interest in the minerals before extraction. The operator in the Oklahoma example did, and its loan falls under paragraph (4). A debtor with no interest in the oil before extraction does not, as SemCrude held, and Section 9-301(1) then sends perfection to the debtor's location.11
Certificate-of-Title Goods
Most collateral follows the debtor-location rule of Section 9-301(1), but Article 9 sets certificate-of-title goods apart.13 A state agency, such as a department of motor vehicles, issues the certificate. For goods it covers, Section 9-303 provides that "[t]he local law of the jurisdiction under whose certificate of title the goods are covered governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and the priority of a security interest in goods covered by a certificate of title," and that law governs "until the goods cease to be covered by the certificate of title."14 The certificate is the only connecting factor. The rule applies without regard to any other connection of the goods or the debtor to the issuing jurisdiction, so a lender reads the certificate and need not ask where the debtor does business or where the vehicle is parked.15
Coverage begins and ends on defined events. Goods first become covered when a valid application for a certificate and the application fee are delivered to the appropriate authority. They cease to be covered at the earlier of two events: the certificate ceases to be effective under the law of the issuing jurisdiction, or the goods become covered by a certificate issued by another jurisdiction.16 Surrender of the old certificate is not itself an event that ends the old state's law.17
A trucking company with its chief executive office in Iowa shows how far the rule departs from the default. If it registers its trucks in several states, each truck's perfection is governed by the law of the state that issued that truck's certificate, so one debtor can have collateral subject to the title laws of several states. The company's Iowa office plays no part in the analysis for the titled trucks.
The rule reaches only goods that a certificate actually covers. Until an application and fee reach the title authority, a vehicle is not covered, and a lender that perfects by filing against it looks to the debtor's location under the ordinary rule.18
Section 9-303(b) hands the question to a new state as soon as that state's certificate covers the goods, but a lender does not lose its perfection at that moment. The fact that one state's law ceases to apply does not make a security interest perfected under that law unperfected automatically; the gist of Section 9-316(d) and (e) is that in most cases the security interest stays perfected.20 Take a bank that has perfected under a State A certificate. The debtor moves to State B and applies for a State B title, and a year later a creditor obtains a judicial lien on the car. State A stops governing perfection once the debtor delivers the application and fee to State B authorities, and State B law then governs. Under State B's Section 9-316(d), however, the bank's interest remains perfected until it would have become unperfected under State A's law had State B issued no certificate. The bank therefore stays perfected and outranks the judicial lien creditor.21 A later section takes up changes in governing law in more detail.
The first question on titled goods is therefore whether a certificate covers them. If one does, the debtor's location and the goods' physical location drop out of the analysis.
Deposit Accounts
A deposit account is a claim against a bank, and Section 9-304 makes the bank, not the debtor, the reference point: the local law of the bank's jurisdiction governs perfection and priority of a security interest in a deposit account maintained with that bank.23 Deposit accounts are among the collateral that Article 9 sets apart from the debtor-location default of Section 9-301(1).24 The first task on a deposit-account problem is to find the bank and its jurisdiction.
This rule does less work than the debtor-location rule does for filed interests. Most perfection is by filing at the debtor's location,25 and choice of law on the place of filing matters because a filing in the wrong place is no filing at all.26 A lender can perfect a security interest in a deposit account, apart from proceeds, only by taking control, and the same acts are likely to constitute control in every state. A lender that has done what control requires will therefore likely be perfected under the laws of Texas, New York, and Illinois alike, and one that has not will be perfected under none.27
Applying the rule still requires finding the bank's jurisdiction. Article 9 supplies an order of inquiry that starts with the parties' own agreement and falls back to facts about how the account is run.28
The agreement comes first because the bank and its customer can fix the answer in the document that governs the account. The fallbacks look to where the account is actually maintained or serviced, and then to the bank's headquarters, so some jurisdiction is always available. A later section deals with the case in which the bank moves to another jurisdiction after the lender has perfected.29
Students most often go wrong here by reaching for a rule that fits some other kind of collateral. A fact pattern that gives the debtor's home state invites the answer that the debtor's location governs, and for receivables and most other filed collateral it does.30 For deposit accounts it does not. Nor does the possessory-interest rule help. Section 9-301(2) takes a possessory security interest out of the debtor-location rule and sends it to the law of the place where the collateral is located,31 but a lender perfects in a deposit account by control, not by holding the collateral.32
Investment Property
Section 9-305 governs the place of perfection for investment property, and the answer depends on how the secured party perfects as well as on what the collateral is.34 Article 9 defines investment property as a security, whether certificated or uncertificated, a security entitlement, a securities account, a commodity contract, or a commodity account.35
The section works in two layers. The first follows the default: the law of the jurisdiction where the debtor is located governs perfection of a security interest in investment property by filing, and it also governs automatic perfection, including automatic perfection of an interest that a broker or securities intermediary creates.36 The second layer covers every other method of perfection, such as control. For those methods, the local law of a jurisdiction that depends on the form of the property governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and priority:
- For a certificated security, the jurisdiction where the certificate is located.37
- For an uncertificated security, the issuer's jurisdiction.38
- For a security entitlement or a securities account, the securities intermediary's jurisdiction, meaning the jurisdiction of the firm that carries the account.39
- For a commodity contract or a commodity account, the commodity intermediary's jurisdiction.40
Each pairing points to the place or party that holds the relevant record of the property. A certificate is paper that sits somewhere. An uncertificated security has one issuer. An investor who holds through an intermediary has rights against that firm, so the firm's jurisdiction supplies the law, just as the bank's jurisdiction does for a deposit account. Filing, by contrast, follows the debtor, so a lender holding several kinds of investment property can face a different governing law for each asset, depending on the step it took for each.
A fact pattern that names a debtor in one state, a brokerage in another, and issuers in a third invites a guess keyed to whichever state is mentioned most prominently. Start instead with the lender's method of perfection, because only a method other than filing or automatic perfection brings the certificate, the issuer, or the intermediary into play.
International cases add one more source of rules. The Hague Convention on the Law Applicable to Certain Rights in Respect of Securities Held with an Intermediary, to which the United States is a party, entered into force in April 2017, and it provides its own choice-of-law rules for the law governing perfection and priority of security interests in securities held with an intermediary.42
Letter-of-Credit Rights
Letter-of-credit rights are another kind of collateral for which Article 9 supplies its own choice-of-law rule, in Section 9-306, in place of the debtor-location default of Section 9-301(1).44 The collateral is a right to payment from the persons obligated on the letter of credit: the issuer and, if one exists, a nominated person such as a confirmer. The beneficiary of the letter of credit, or the beneficiary's assignee or transferee, holds that right, and when the beneficiary grants a lender a security interest in it, the beneficiary becomes the debtor for Article 9 purposes.45
Section 9-306 then supplies the rule. If the issuer's or nominated person's jurisdiction is a State, that jurisdiction's local law governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and priority of a security interest in the letter-of-credit right. If that jurisdiction is not a State, Article 9's general choice-of-law rule applies, and the local law of the debtor's jurisdiction governs.46 The issuer is the natural reference point for the same reason the bank is for a deposit account: the right is a claim to payment, and the party that must pay is the fixed fact about it. The Code pairs the two kinds of collateral, with a rule for identifying the issuer's jurisdiction and a rule for the case in which the issuer changes jurisdictions, and a later section returns to the second.47
The issuer rule operates only when the issuer's jurisdiction is a State; when the issuer sits abroad, it steps aside. Article 9 then falls back on the debtor-location rule and asks where the beneficiary, the party that granted the interest, is located.48 A beneficiary that is a registered organization is located in the state where it is organized, wherever it ships goods or keeps its bank accounts.49
A fact pattern that gives the beneficiary's home state and the place where its goods were shipped invites the answer that the debtor's location governs, and that default is correct only after the issuer's jurisdiction has been checked. Begin with where the issuer, or a nominated person such as a confirmer, is located and whether that place is a State. A State settles the whole question. A foreign country sends the analysis back to Section 9-301(1), and only then does the beneficiary's location decide.