Concept
Collateral Governed by Other Rules
Perfection of security interests in multiple state transactions (§ 9-301)
Collateral Governed by Other Rules
Section 9-301 states its own limits in its first clause: its choice-of-law rules apply "[e]xcept as otherwise provided in Sections 9-303 through 9-306B."1 What follows that clause is the debtor-location default. While a debtor is located in a jurisdiction, that jurisdiction's local law governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and priority.2 Much collateral never reaches the default.
Four categories are sent to sections of their own:
- goods covered by a certificate of title (§ 9-303);
- deposit accounts (§ 9-304);
- investment property (§ 9-305); and
- letter-of-credit rights (§ 9-306).3
Section 9-301 also does not govern possessory security interests, security interests perfected by a fixture filing, timber to be cut, or as-extracted collateral. Its own subsections address those separately, as the earlier parts of this chapter showed.4
Consider a lender whose collateral is a truck covered by a certificate of title issued by State B, while the debtor is located in State A. Reading Section 9-301(1) alone, a student would look to State A. Section 9-303 points elsewhere: the law of the jurisdiction that issued the certificate of title determines the effect of perfection or nonperfection and priority, and it continues to do so until the goods cease to be covered by that certificate.5 The debtor's location does not decide the question. For the other three categories, the answer likewise comes from Sections 9-304 through 9-306 and not from the default.
The 2022 amendments added to this list of reserved sections. New Section 9-306A, not Section 9-301, now governs perfection and priority of security interests in chattel paper. New Section 9-306B supplies the governing law for controllable accounts, controllable electronic records, and controllable payment intangibles.6 That is why the opening clause of Section 9-301 now runs through Section 9-306B.
The working habit follows from this structure. Before applying the debtor-location rule to any collateral, check whether the collateral is reserved to another section. A titled truck or a deposit account calls for the specific section. Only collateral that no reservation reaches falls under the default.