Concept
When the Debtor Relocates
Perfection of security interests in multiple state transactions (§ 9-301)
When the Debtor Relocates
Section 9-301(1) is written in the present tense: while a debtor is located in a jurisdiction, that jurisdiction's local law governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and the priority of a security interest in the collateral.1 The word "while" does the work. The rule does not point to the debtor's location when the security interest attached or when the secured party filed. It follows the debtor's location for as long as the debtor stays there. A debtor who changes location therefore changes the governing law, and the filing office that was right last month may be the wrong one today.
The lender's difficulty is easy to see. A secured party that filed in the right place has done what the rule required, and a later move is the debtor's act. The lender may never hear of it. A secured party cannot treat a filing as finished business. The place of filing depends on a fact, the debtor's location, that the debtor can change without the lender's knowledge.
The hypothetical shows what the location rule settles and what it leaves open. It settles that Indiana law now governs. It does not say whether an Ohio filing made before the move still counts under that law, or for how long. Section 9-301(1) does not answer that question, so the next section takes it up under Section 9-316. It covers what becomes of a security interest perfected under the old state's law when the governing law changes. It also covers a second route to the same problem, in which collateral passes to a new debtor who is located in a different jurisdiction.