Concept
When the Governing Law Changes
Perfection of security interests in multiple state transactions (§ 9-301)
When the Governing Law Changes
A financing statement filed in the right office on the day a loan closes can sit in the wrong office a few months later. Section 9-301(1) creates the problem with a single word: while a debtor is located in a jurisdiction, that jurisdiction's local law governs perfection, the effect of perfection or nonperfection, and the priority of a security interest in collateral.1 The rule reads the debtor's location as it stands when the question arises, so a change in location changes the governing law.2
Two events change the location that matters. The debtor can move, by changing its residence, its chief executive office, or its state of registration. Or the collateral can pass to a new debtor located elsewhere, as commonly happens in business reorganizations and mergers.3 In either case the old filing no longer reaches the people who deal with the debtor in the new state, because they expect to search there.4
Earlier American law, which varied from place to place, most often honored the first creditor's perfection in the state where the property then sat, so long as the creditor had not consented to the removal and, on discovering it, acted within a reasonable time to perfect in the second state. That approach put the risk of an unknown prior claim on the public and credit system of the second state.5 Article 9 uses fixed periods instead. Under Section 9-316(a), a security interest perfected under the old jurisdiction's law stays perfected until the earliest of three times: the time perfection would have ceased under that law, four months after a change in the debtor's location, and one year after a transfer of collateral to a person who thereby becomes a debtor located in another jurisdiction.6 The periods are meant to be long enough for the secured party to discover the change and re-perfect, typically by filing in the new jurisdiction.7
Each event starts a different clock. A debtor's move starts four months, a transfer to a new debtor starts one year, and a secured party that misses the deadline learns that its lost perfection reaches back in time against some claimants but not others.
Debtor Relocates
When the debtor moves to another jurisdiction, the secured party has four months to refile in the state of the new location, and if it does not, its interest becomes unperfected and unenforceable against third parties who take the property for value.8 Section 9-316(a)(2) supplies the period, and Section 9-316(b) puts the burden on the secured party to chase the debtor to the new state and file there, or take whatever action that state's law requires. A secured party that acts within the period holds a continuously perfected security interest.9
The period assumes the lender may not know about the move. In the standard illustration, a general partnership has its chief executive office in Pennsylvania, and a lender perfects a security interest in its equipment by filing there on May 15, 2002. On April 1, 2005, without the lender's knowledge, the partnership moves its chief executive office to New Jersey. New Jersey law now governs perfection, but the Pennsylvania filing keeps the interest perfected for four months after the move.10 The four months, rather than the filing's remaining life, set the deadline because the grace period ends at the earliest of the listed times. A financing statement runs five years unless continued, so the 2002 filing would not have lapsed until 2007.11 Had the old filing been due to lapse two months after the move, the lapse would have cut the fixed period short.12
The same four months apply to an individual, such as a debtor who moves from Michigan to Ohio.13 What counts as a move depends on how Article 9 locates each kind of debtor. An individual is located at a principal residence, and a sole proprietorship, having no separate legal existence, is located where its owner's principal residence is. When a person has several homes, the principal residence turns on facts such as where the individual pays taxes and registers to vote. A corporation or other registered organization is located in its state of registration.14
Moving the goods alone does not change the law that governs perfection by filing. That was not always so. Former Section 9-103 tied perfection to where goods sat, so a filing made where the goods were became unperfected after they left, and the old section gave the creditor a four-month grace period to catch up in the new state.15 Section 9-301 now directs that the law of the debtor's location governs perfection for the general rule applicable to 99% of all filing. The old distinctions between tangible and intangible collateral and between mobile and non-mobile goods are gone, and so are the rules about continued perfection after goods cross state lines.16
Possessory security interests are the contrast. Section 9-301(2) applies the law of the collateral's location to them, so removing the collateral to another jurisdiction changes the governing law there too, though even then the change does not cause an immediate loss of perfection.17
One event looks like a relocation but is harder to classify: a registered organization that reincorporates in another state. The next subsection takes it up.
Transfer to a New Debtor
When collateral passes to a person who thereby becomes a debtor located in a different jurisdiction, the secured party gets a full year, not four months, to refile.19 Section 9-316(a)(3) states the rule: the old perfection continues until the earlier of the time it would have ceased under the old law and one year after the transfer.20 Reorganizations and mergers are the usual occasions. The new debtor sits in a different jurisdiction, so the financing statement filed against the old debtor in the old jurisdiction remains effective for one year to perfect the interest in the transferred collateral, and the secured party must follow the new debtor and perfect there.21
The extra time suits the lender's position. A merger or reorganization can place the collateral with an entity the lender never dealt with, and nothing in the event need reach the lender. The one-year protection covers the collateral the old debtor transferred. For collateral the new debtor has and acquires within four months after it becomes the new debtor, the old filing also remains effective, but that extension runs only four months.22
The one-year period applies only when the new debtor is in a different jurisdiction. If the old and new debtor are located in the same jurisdiction, the governing law does not change and Section 9-316 never comes into play. The filing against the old debtor remains effective to perfect the interest in the collateral transferred to the new debtor, and in collateral the new debtor acquires within four months after becoming bound to the old debtor's security agreement.23
Reincorporation sits on the line between the two periods. A corporation is located in its state of registration, so reincorporating elsewhere changes its location, which suggests four months.24 One source applies exactly that rule: when Acme, Inc. reincorporates in State C, the lender must file there within four months after the reorganization.25 Another source believes the transfer rule governs. Its reasoning is that a Michigan corporation reincorporating in Delaware is a different juridical person from the Delaware corporation, so there is technically a new debtor even though it has the same name, the same assets, and the same liabilities, and Section 9-316(a)(3) gives a year.26 The individual who moves from Michigan to Ohio shows why that view appeals: the individual is the same person before and after the move, so no collateral passes to a new debtor and four months applies. A lender need not choose between the views. A filing in the new state within four months protects it under either.
The error to avoid is counting four months from a merger or a reincorporation without first asking whether the collateral passed to a new debtor.
Retroactive Unperfection
A secured party that lets the grace period expire without perfecting in the new state loses more than its future position. Its interest becomes unperfected prospectively and, as against purchasers for value, including buyers and secured parties, retroactively, so that the secured party is treated as though it had never been perfected. The retroactive effect does not reach donees or lien creditors.28
The standard illustration shows how much the rule takes from the first lender. A debtor changes its location to State B, and SP-1, which perfected by filing in State A, has four months to file in State B. Two months after the move, SP-2 takes a security interest in the debtor's equipment and files in State B. SP-1 never files there. When the four months end, SP-1's interest is unperfected and is deemed unperfected as against SP-2, a previous purchaser for value. SP-2's filing remains effective, and the rule that perfected interests prime unperfected ones gives SP-2 priority.29
The result surprises students because SP-1 was perfected on the day SP-2's interest attached and the grace period had not yet run. The retroactive rule rewrites that history once the period ends without a new filing. The grace period gives the secured party time to act, not safety if it does not. Had SP-1 filed in State B in the second or third month, it would have held a continuously perfected interest and SP-2 would have faced a senior claim.30
Buyers are protected too. If a debtor sells collateral to a purchaser for value within the four months or afterward, the buyer takes free of the security interest when the lender never files in the new state.31 The buyer must still have given value and received delivery without knowledge of the security interest, so a buyer who knew of the lien takes subject to it.32
The two halves of the rule draw a line at value. Buyers and secured parties who gave value are purchasers, and the first lender could have protected itself by following the debtor and filing in the new state. Donees give no value, so they fall outside the category. Lien creditors are excluded for a policy reason: retroactive unperfection against them would create "substantial and unjustifiable preference risks."33 The Code accepts that its approach creates the potential for circular priorities as the price of avoiding that risk.34 A lapsed financing statement works the same way: the interest is unperfected from the moment of lapse and deemed unperfected against a prior purchaser for value, but the retroactive step does not reach lien creditors.35
The fourth step decides the answer. The same lender, the same debtor, and the same lapse of time can produce opposite results against two claimants who arrive in the same month.