Concept
Reading the Exclusions
Excluded transactions (§ 9-109)
Exclusions From Article 9
Reading the Exclusions
Article 9 defines its reach in two moves, and every exclusion in Section 9-109 attaches to the first. Subsection (a) says that, "[e]xcept as otherwise provided in subsections (c) and (d), this article applies to" six kinds of transactions:1
- a transaction, regardless of its form, that creates a security interest in personal property or fixtures by contract;2
- an agricultural lien;3
- a sale of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, or promissory notes;4
- a consignment;5
- a security interest arising under Section 2-401, 2-505, 2-711(3), or 2A-508(5), as provided in Section 9-110; and6
- a security interest arising under Section 4-210 or 5-118.7
Because the opening clause makes all six subject to subsections (c) and (d), the list states only Article 9's presumptive reach. The exclusions are exceptions cut out of it.
The list is drafted broadly because the form a deal takes does not decide whether Article 9 governs it. A seller who delivers a truck under a twelve-month "lease" with a $1 option to buy at the end can argue that it is a lessor and not a secured creditor, and so did not have to file. Subsection (a)(1) answers that argument by reaching a transaction "regardless of its form."8 Structuring a deal as a lease instead of a sale is common and not illegal. But Article 9 is meant to be a unified national system that creditors can rely on, and creative lawyers who could escape it with artful language would defeat that purpose.9 The remedy is to find departures from Article 9 in the statute and not in the parties' drafting. Subsections (c) and (d) are where the statute lists them, so a deal that falls within subsection (a) and matches none of the listed exclusions stays inside Article 9.
The order matters because an exclusion needs something to subtract from. A transaction that never fit subsection (a) needs no exclusion, and a transaction that did fit stays under Article 9 unless step two or step three removes it.
The two exclusion lists work differently, and the difference lies in their lead-in words. Subsection (c) says Article 9 "does not apply to the extent that" the listed condition exists.11 Subsection (d) says only that the article "does not apply to" the listed transactions.12 The "to the extent" language makes (c) a partial exclusion, and the federal-statute example shows why. A federal act may provide for filing yet leave the creation of the interest, priority, and foreclosure unaddressed, and Article 9 continues to operate on whatever the other law leaves open.13 Subsection (d), by contrast, removes whole categories of transactions, among them landlord's liens, wage assignments, and the others taken up in the rest of this chapter. Several (d) categories carry carve-backs. The landlord's-lien exclusion reads "other than an agricultural lien," which keeps agricultural liens inside Article 9 where subsection (a)(2) put them.14 The tort-claim exclusion has two exceptions of its own: Article 9 still applies to tort claims that are proceeds of other collateral and to commercial tort claims.15
The second scene turns on subsection (d)(3), which excludes an assignment of a claim for wages, salary, or other compensation of an employee.16 Other federal and state statutes regulate those assignments because they raise social concerns that other law addresses.17 The oven stays inside Article 9 because neither list names it.
An exclusion changes which law governs and does not bar the interest. A transaction that falls outside Article 9 can still be used to secure a debt. The only effect of the exclusion is that other law, and not Article 9, controls the creation of an interest in that type of asset to secure a debt.18 Concluding that an excluded asset cannot serve as security is therefore a common error. The correct conclusion is that Article 9's rules do not govern it, and that the subsection (c) exclusions cut Article 9 back only as far as the other law actually reaches.