Concept
Defining an Account
Is the collateral an account?
Identifying an Account
Defining an Account
Article 9 gives “account” a narrow, technical meaning: a right to payment of a monetary obligation, whether or not performance has yet earned it, that is owed for one of eight listed kinds of transaction and falls outside seven listed exclusions.1 The paradigm is the ordinary business receivable. A seller delivers goods or a firm performs services, and the customer owes the price. The word does not mean what a layperson expects. The definition withdraws it from phrases in which it means something else, such as “statement of account” and “customer’s account,” and it treats “deposit account” as a separate term that it then lists among the excluded rights.2 A reader who hears “account” and pictures a bank balance has started from the wrong collateral.
Two phrases carry most of the definition. “Right to payment of a monetary obligation” says what an account is: a claim to be paid money. “Whether or not earned by performance” says when the claim qualifies: before the seller or service provider has finished, as well as after.3 Suppose Northside Print ships $50,000 of paper to a customer on thirty days’ credit. Northside’s claim for the price is an account, because it is a right to payment for property sold. Suppose Northside then signs a contract to print the customer’s catalog next quarter for a fixed fee. Northside has not begun the work, yet its right to the fee is already an account, because the definition reaches services “to be rendered” and does not require that the right be earned.4
The definition names eight sources for the obligation. A right to payment is an account when it is owed:
- for property that has been or is to be sold, leased, licensed, assigned, or otherwise disposed of;
- for services rendered or to be rendered;
- for a policy of insurance issued or to be issued;
- for a secondary obligation incurred or to be incurred;
- for energy provided or to be provided;
- for the use or hire of a vessel under a charter or other contract;
- arising out of the use of a credit or charge card or information contained on or for use with the card; or
- as winnings in a lottery or other game of chance operated or sponsored by a State, a governmental unit of a State, or a person licensed or authorized by either to operate the game.5
The term also includes health-care-insurance receivables.6
Seven kinds of right fall outside the term: chattel paper, commercial tort claims, deposit accounts, investment property, letter-of-credit rights and letters of credit, rights to payment for money or funds advanced or sold, and rights to payment evidenced by an instrument.7 The sixth exclusion has an exception that matches the card item on the inclusion list. A right to payment arising out of the use of a credit or charge card, or of information on or for use with the card, is an account. A right to payment for funds advanced, without that card connection, is not.8 The next section turns to what the definition leaves out.
The label matters because Article 9’s rules for creating, perfecting, and enforcing a security interest, and its priority rules among competing claimants, all depend on the type of collateral.9 A lender that misidentifies the type risks applying the wrong rules, and the cost can be severe. The bankruptcy trustee is treated as holding a judicial lien on all of the debtor’s assets on the date the petition is filed, so a creditor that has not properly perfected is treated as unsecured in the debtor’s bankruptcy.10 The definition of account therefore has to be applied as the statute states it, not by lay intuition.
Article 9’s definitions fall into three groups: collateral types, transaction types, and actor types. The collateral types are the first and most important group, and all three must be mastered to understand this area of law.11 The account is one collateral type. This chapter marks its edges first by examining what the definition excludes, then takes up general intangibles, then turns to the actors in a receivable transaction: the debtor, the account debtor, and secondary obligors. It closes with the practical task of classifying a right to payment.