Concept
Fixtures and Encumbrances
Is the security interest a purchase-money security interest?
Fixtures and Encumbrances
Every contest in this chapter so far has pitted one personal-property claimant against another: an earlier secured party against a later one, a secured party against a lien creditor, a secured party against a bankruptcy trustee. Fixtures bring in a claimant from outside that world, a person whose right comes from the law of land. Goods attached to real property sit in a kind of never-never land between real and personal property. They carry enough of the character of realty that an interest in them arises under real property law, and they keep enough of the character of personal property that a creditor can take an Article 9 security interest in them.1
Both sides therefore have a real claim to the same furnace. A lender whose recorded mortgage covers the building and its fixtures points to the land; the seller that financed the furnace points to its security interest in the good.2 Section 9-334 decides between them.3 Its starting point favors the land: unless an exception applies, a security interest in fixtures is subordinate to the conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the related real estate who is not the debtor.4 A fixture financier wins only by fitting an exception. When the opponent is another secured party, no special rule is needed, and the ordinary Article 9 priority rules apply.5
This unit takes four steps. It defines the encumbrance, one of the two real estate claimants the default rule names; asks what makes goods a fixture and where a financier must file; and then covers the purchase-money exception and the construction mortgage limit on that exception.
Encumbrance Defined
Article 9 defines an encumbrance as “a right, other than an ownership interest, in real property,” and adds that the term includes mortgages and other liens on real property.6 The definition sorts the claimants in every fixture contest, because the default rule subordinates the fixture financier to an encumbrancer or to an owner of the real estate who is not the debtor.7 Everyday usage is broader. A law dictionary describes an encumbrance as a claim or liability attached to property that may lessen its value, such as a lien or mortgage, or as any property right short of ownership, and it adds that the encumbrance remains after the property is transferred.8 The Code narrows that usage to rights in real property.
The mortgagee is the standard encumbrancer.9 A fixture dispute may involve someone claiming a consensual lien on the building, such as a mortgagee, or someone claiming a judicial lien on the real property, such as a judgment creditor.10 Each holds a right in the land short of title, so each is an encumbrancer.
The ownership carve-out removes a different claimant. A person who holds title holds the very interest the definition excludes, so the owner stands apart from the mortgagee even though the fixture rules name them together. The owner who matters is one other than the debtor,11 and the category includes a purchaser who later buys the land.12 Between them, the two labels cover the claimants the default rule names: title belongs to the owner, and any lesser right in the land is an encumbrance.
The standard illustration shows the sorting at work. Debtor owns a house subject to a recorded mortgage in favor of State Bank, and the mortgage covers fixtures. A seller finances a furnace for the house, and the furnace becomes a fixture on installation. The seller files a fixture financing statement thirty days after installation. State Bank holds a mortgage, so it is an encumbrancer; because no exception helps the seller, State Bank’s interest in the furnace is superior.13
A second financier is a different kind of opponent. A lender with its own Article 9 security interest in the same fixture, but with no mortgage or other lien on the land, holds no right in real property and is not an encumbrancer. The special fixture rule is reserved for a claimant whose right arises under real estate law; two conflicting security interests in fixtures are ranked by the ordinary Article 9 priority rules.14 If neither holds a purchase-money interest, the first to file or perfect prevails.15
The common error is to read “encumbrance” as any claim that touches the property. The definition defeats both versions of the mistake: a security interest created under Article 9 is not a right in the land, and title is the interest the definition excludes.
Fixtures and Their Claimants
A fixture is a good so related to the real estate that an interest in it can be granted under real estate law as well as personal property law.17 A furnace shows both sides. If the owner sells the building, title to the furnace passes to the buyer under the deed; yet under personal property law the furnace is still a movable thing that can be the subject of a contract separate from any contract about the land.18 Because it stays movable, it can carry an Article 9 security interest; because it passes with the land, it draws claims from people who deal only in real estate. Whether an item lands in this middle position depends on the state’s real property law, so the same furnace may be classified differently from state to state.19
Ordinary building materials mark the edge of the category. Lumber, sheet rock, tile, and plumbing pipe built into a house do not keep their character as movable things, so they are part of the real estate and not fixtures, and an Article 9 security interest cannot be created in them.20 A fact pattern that says only that an item was installed in a building therefore settles nothing. The question is whether the item kept its identity as a movable good or was consumed into the structure as ordinary material.
A fixture also belongs to one of Article 9’s usual categories of goods. Had it never been attached, it would be equipment or consumer goods: a heating unit attached to an office building is a fixture and equipment, and the same unit attached to a home is a fixture and consumer goods.21 The personal-property side of the fixture has a practical defender. In a dispute over which limitations period governs a claim about an installed fixture, the argument for the shorter personal-property period was that people should be encouraged to modernize and improve their property with personal property permanently affixed to it, and that a longer period would leave title to the fixtures uncertain for longer.22
Once an item qualifies as a fixture, the next question is who stands against the financier. The claimants whose rights come from real estate law are the owner of the real estate other than the debtor, a mortgagee or other lienholder such as a judgment creditor, and a later purchaser of the land.23 A competing Article 9 secured party is a different opponent, ranked under the ordinary priority rules for conflicting security interests.24 The dividing line follows the source of the right. Two secured parties both claim through Article 9, so one body of rules can rank them. A mortgagee or a buyer of the land claims through real estate law, and § 9-334 supplies the rule that reconciles the two systems.25
A fixture financier has two filing options. It can file a financing statement against the goods in the central filing office for the debtor’s location, or it can file a fixture financing statement in the real estate recording office for the real estate where the fixture is located. The fixture financing statement carries additional requirements, including a description of the real estate on which the fixtures sit.26 It must also be recorded so that someone searching the real estate title can find it.27 The choice matters because, as a general matter, a financier has rights against an owner of the real property or a consensual lienholder such as a mortgagee only if it made a fixture filing.28 A financier that wants first priority in fixtures therefore files in the real estate records for the land where the fixtures are located.29 Other routes to priority exist, such as the one for readily removable factory or office machines perfected by any Article 9 method before they become fixtures, but they lie outside this unit.30
A furnace passes the first three steps and becomes a fixture. Lumber and drywall fail at step three because they have been absorbed into the structure.
Purchase-Money Priority in Fixtures
The default rule runs against the fixture financier. Unless an exception applies, a security interest in fixtures is subordinate to the conflicting interest of an encumbrancer or owner of the related real estate who is not the debtor.35 The default reflects where real estate claimants look. A buyer or mortgagee searches the real estate title, and a financier whose only filing sits in the central office has given that searcher nothing to find; as a general matter it has no rights against the owner or the mortgagee.36 The principal exception rewards the financier whose money put the fixture in the building, provided the financier then makes its claim visible where those searchers look.
Section 9-334(d) states that exception. A financier holding a purchase-money security interest in a fixture takes priority over the conflicting interest of an encumbrancer, or of an owner of the real estate who is not the debtor, if three things are true. First, the financier perfected by an effective fixture financing statement in the real estate records before the goods became fixtures or within 20 days afterward. Second, the owner’s and the encumbrancer’s interests in the real estate predate the goods’ becoming fixtures. Third, the debtor has an interest of record in the real estate or is in possession of it.37
Purchase-money status is the threshold. A security interest in goods is purchase-money when it secures value given to enable the debtor to acquire rights in the goods, and the value must actually be used for that purpose.38 The status can also outlast a payment: in one inventory example, a loan against cars that the dealer’s accounting treated as satisfied still remained a purchase-money loan.39
The exception borrows a familiar idea. For goods that never attach to land, a purchase-money security interest perfected when the debtor receives possession of the collateral, or within 20 days afterward, outranks a conflicting security interest in the same goods.40 Against a lien creditor, the holder of a purchase-money security interest has 20 days after the debtor receives delivery in which to file; if it files in time, its interest outranks a lien creditor whose rights attach between the time the security interest arose and the time of filing.41 The fixture version changes two things. The 20 days run from the moment the goods become fixtures, not from delivery or sale, and the filing must be a fixture filing in the real estate records, not a central filing.42 Real property law rewards the same position: in most states a purchase-money mortgage can take priority over other liens, even those recorded beforehand, such as a judgment lien.43
The furnace illustrations show how sharply the 20-day line cuts. State Bank holds a recorded mortgage that covers fixtures, and SP-1 afterward finances the debtor’s new furnace, which becomes a fixture on installation. If SP-1 files its fixture financing statement in the real estate records 15 days after installation, its purchase-money interest outranks the mortgage.48 If SP-1 files 30 days after installation, on otherwise identical facts, State Bank prevails.49 Both filings were fixture filings in the right office, and both followed the mortgage; only the day count moved the result. A late filer loses to the earlier recorded mortgage, and also to an assignee of that mortgage even when the assignment is recorded after the fixture filing.50
Missing the window costs a financier its ranking against interests already in place, not against every claimant. In another illustration, SP-1 files its fixture financing statement 25 days after installation, outside the window, and five weeks later the debtor gives a bank a mortgage that covers fixtures. SP-1 prevails over the bank.51 The identical filing would have lost to a mortgage already of record when the furnace was installed.52 The example shows that a fixture filing already of record can outrank a mortgage that arrives later, even when the filing missed the 20-day window.
The clock starts when the goods become fixtures. For goods that never attach, it starts when the debtor receives possession,53 so a problem that supplies a sale date, a delivery date, and an installation date is asking which one begins the period. For a fixture, the grace period follows installation.54
The condition that the debtor have an interest of record in the real estate or be in possession keeps a financier from defeating real estate interests by taking a security interest from someone with no tie to the title. A contractor with no interest of record who is not in possession cannot serve as the debtor for this purpose, but a lessee in possession can if the filing names a record owner.55
Filing before the goods become fixtures is the safer course, because it satisfies the first clause of the rule and leaves no grace period to count.56 Wherever the financier files, the fixture filing belongs in the real estate recording office for the land where the goods are located,57 because as a general matter a central filing alone gives no rights against an owner or mortgagee of the realty.58 A student who credits a financier with the 20-day window on the strength of a central filing alone has applied the exception to a filing it does not recognize.
Construction Mortgage Exception
The purchase-money exception has an exception of its own. A financier with a purchase-money interest in fixtures is not entitled to priority over a construction mortgagee if the mortgagee recorded its mortgage before the fixture financing statement was filed and the goods became fixtures before the construction project was complete.60 Three facts decide the contest: the claimant is a construction mortgagee, it recorded before the financier’s fixture filing, and the goods became fixtures while the project was still under construction.
The reason is double financing. A debtor can draw funds from the construction mortgagee to buy goods and then buy the same goods on credit from a supplier who takes a security interest for the price, so the fixtures are financed twice. Priority for the construction mortgagee prevents that result. A supplier who sells on credit for installation in a building under construction can protect itself by checking the real estate records before it extends the credit.61
The rule has edges. It applies only while the project is under construction, and it does not reach additions made after the improvement is complete and financed under an open-end clause of a construction mortgage or under a refinancing mortgage.62 Timing therefore decides the contest, and the next case shows how much.
Lienholders can also reorder priority by agreement. In real property practice, owners negotiate subordination agreements between lenders that reverse the lenders’ priorities on foreclosure.63 A fixture financier that must outrank a construction mortgagee has the same option of asking the mortgagee to agree. Real property law shows why the use of the money matters in such agreements. Sellers of lots who took a purchase-money mortgage containing a subordination agreement with a purpose clause, stating the reason for the subordination and how the disbursed funds could be used, illustrate the point, because where funds are diverted the purchase-money mortgage ordinarily should be restored to priority to the extent of the diverted funds.64 Other routes to priority in fixtures, such as the one for readily removable factory or office machines, rest on different facts and fall outside this unit.65
Steps two and three are where a fact pattern varies the facts, since a mortgage can be recorded early while the boiler arrives only after the project is finished. A stem that mentions a construction loan invites an automatic subordination answer, and that answer fails when the goods became fixtures after completion.