Concept
Control Defined
Does the secured party have control?
Control of Deposit Accounts
Control Defined
A secured party has control of a deposit account when it satisfies one of the conditions listed in Section 9-104(a), and that list is the whole test.1 The secured party is the person in whose favor the security interest is created, usually the lender.2 A lender that meets a listed condition has control, and a lender that meets none lacks it, however much practical leverage it holds over the debtor. The consequence is perfection. Control is how a security interest in a bank account becomes perfected, and a perfected secured party generally outranks an unperfected one and takes priority over a later lien creditor, a category that includes the trustee in bankruptcy.3
Control is a term of art, and it does for intangible collateral what possession does for goods. A lender that possesses the debtor's tractor perfects its interest in the tractor, and a lender with control of the debtor's account perfects its interest in the account.4 Deposit accounts share the control method with letter-of-credit rights, electronic chattel paper, and investment property.5 For a deposit account, however, the method is mandatory. Control is the only route to perfection, while for investment property and electronic chattel paper it is permitted but not exclusive.6
The statute offers three ways to achieve control, and every one of them runs through the bank. The secured party may itself be the bank with which the deposit account is maintained, which is the first and most common route.7 Alternatively, the debtor, the secured party, and the bank may agree in an authenticated record that the bank will comply with instructions originated by the secured party directing disposition of the funds, without further consent by the debtor. Or the secured party may become the bank's customer with respect to the account.8 A promise made only between lender and debtor appears nowhere on this list. The relationship must also last, because a security interest perfected by control remains perfected only while the secured party retains control.9
The test examines the secured party's relationship with the bank and never asks whether the debtor has been shut out. A secured party that has satisfied subsection (a) has control even if the debtor retains the right to direct the disposition of funds from the deposit account.10 Control and the debtor's continued use of the account therefore coexist. Possession of goods works the other way, since a debtor who hands over the tractor no longer has it. The instinct to ask whether the debtor can still reach the money points at the wrong fact.
Harbor lacks control, because nothing in its facts connects Harbor to the bank. The promise is a term of the manufacturer's contract with Harbor, and Third National remains free to honor whatever the manufacturer directs.11 Since control is the only route to perfection for a deposit account, Harbor's security interest in the account is unperfected.12 Third National stands differently. It is the bank with which the savings account is maintained, so it has control without taking any further step, and the depositor's continued deposits and withdrawals do not disturb that result.13 In the first scene the debtor has promised to stay away from the account and the lender still lacks control. In the second the depositor keeps full use of the account and the bank has control. The deciding fact in both scenes is the secured party's relationship to the bank.
The sections that follow ask three questions in order. The first is whether the collateral is a deposit account or an Article 9 account. The two sound alike, but the statute defines an account as a right to payment, for property sold or services rendered, for example, and expressly excludes deposit accounts from the term.14 The second is whether the secured party is the bank with which the account is maintained, and if it is not, what further step it must take. The third is how perfection by control differs from perfection by filing a financing statement.