Concept
Secured Party as Depositary Bank
Does the secured party have control?
Secured Party as Depositary Bank
A bank that lends to its own depositor gets control of the depositor’s deposit account without taking any further step. Section 9-104(a)(1) gives control to a secured party that is the bank with which the deposit account is maintained,1 and the depositary bank has that control automatically.2 A bank that signs a security agreement with its depositor covering the depositor’s account has control of that account ipso facto, and it becomes a perfected secured creditor when it lends to the depositor.3
The other conditions in § 9-104(a) exist to connect an outside lender to the bank. One is a signed record in which the debtor, the secured party, and the bank agree that the bank will comply with the secured party’s instructions directing disposition of the funds without further consent by the debtor.4 Another is that the secured party becomes the bank’s customer with respect to the deposit account.5 A depositary bank already stands where those arrangements would put an outsider, so neither adds anything for it. Commentators expect the practical result to be lopsided: depositary banks that lend to their depositors will routinely become perfected secured creditors in the depositors’ accounts, while the control-agreement route will be little used because banks will hesitate to grant control to third parties.6
Control matters because it is what perfects a security interest in the account itself. A direct security interest in a deposit account as such can be perfected only by control,7 and Article 9 uses “control” here as a technical term that means something different from the dominion possession requires.8 A claim to money in the account as identifiable cash proceeds of other collateral follows a separate route, which the next section, on lenders other than the bank, takes up.
Identifying the Parties
Three roles decide whether the depositary-bank condition is met: the debtor, the secured party, and the bank. The collateral throughout is a deposit account, Article 9’s name for a bank account. It is not an “account” in the Article 9 sense, which is a right to payment that Revised Article 9 no longer limits to payment for goods or services, and the two asset classes are perfected and foreclosed differently.10
The debtor is a person who has an interest in the collateral other than a security interest or other lien, whether or not that person owes the secured debt.11 For a deposit account, that person is the account holder. The status follows the interest in the account and not the liability for the loan, so an account holder who pledges its account to secure someone else’s borrowing is still the debtor as to that account.
Harbor is the debtor as to the account although it owes nothing on the loan, because it holds an interest in the collateral. The supplier owes the debt but holds no interest in the account, so it is not the debtor as to the account. First Bank is the secured party, and because it also maintains the account, it has control without a further step.
The secured party is a person in whose favor a security interest is created or provided for under a security agreement, whether or not any obligation to be secured is outstanding.12 Two features of that definition matter here. Status comes from the security agreement, not from holding the debtor’s money or having lent to the debtor. And status does not wait for a loan, so a bank whose deposit agreement provides for a security interest in each account is a secured party as to that account from the day it opens. The interest itself still has to attach, and for a bank that happens when it lends,13 but the bank has been a secured party throughout.
The bank is an organization engaged in the business of banking, and Article 9 expressly includes savings banks, savings and loan associations, credit unions, and trust companies.14 A bank is the bank with which an account is maintained by virtue of the deposit relationship. Secured-party status comes from a different source, the security agreement, so the two roles travel separately. A bank that maintains an account holds the first role automatically, and it holds the second only if the account holder has agreed to give it a security interest in that account.
Step two is the one most often skipped. A depositary bank looks like a secured party because it holds the money, and the instinct is to assume it has control of every account it maintains. A bank with no security agreement covering the account never reaches step four.
Dalton is the debtor as to his account, and the credit union is a secured party as to it from the signing of the agreement, though nothing is owed.15 Because the credit union also maintains the account, the first control condition is met without another step. Wren’s account is not collateral at all, since no security interest has been created in it. The credit union is not a secured party as to that account, and the control rule has nothing to operate on. The two members, the institution, and the type of account are identical, and the security agreement is the only difference.
A bank without a security interest is not powerless against its customer’s balance. When a depositor owes the bank a matured debt, the bank may, subject to limitations, reduce the debt by charging it to the depositor’s account, a right of setoff that comes from the common law and exists even without express statutory authority.16 Singleton v. American Security Bank of Ville Platte, Inc. states the Louisiana version: a bank may treat funds deposited in an account as belonging to the account’s owner unless the depositor notifies it otherwise, and that right is in addition to any contractual rights of compensation or setoff in the bank’s agreements with its customer.17 That power rests on state law and contract. It does not make the bank a secured party, which still depends on a security agreement, so a bank that wants control and the perfection that comes with it must put the security interest into its deposit agreement. Consumer-financial regulation is a further overlay that this unit leaves aside: the CFPB, created by Title X of the Dodd-Frank Act, enforces most consumer financial services laws, and the ultimate impact on specific issues remains uncertain.18
The Bank-Control Test
The test in § 9-104(a)(1) has two parts, and a claimant must meet both: it is the secured party as to this account, and the account is maintained with that same institution.20 The security agreement identifies the secured party, the account records identify the bank, and control exists when the two answers match. The clause adds no further requirement, so a bank that fits it needs no control agreement, notice, or other step.21
State Bank meets both parts of the test. The deposit agreement makes it a secured party as to the account, and it is the bank with which the account is maintained, so it has control and is perfected by it.22 National Bank is a secured party as to the account, and it is a bank, but it is not the bank with which this account is maintained. The clause asks which bank maintains the account, not whether the lender is a bank in general. National Bank therefore lacks control, and to the extent the balance is identifiable cash proceeds of inventory sales, its only perfection in the account is the automatic perfection that attaches to those proceeds.23 State Bank’s control gives it priority in the account over National Bank.24 Both banks hold the same collateral from the same debtor, and the place where the account is maintained is what separates them.
Control perfects the interest the agreement grants and no more. In a comparable example, a deposit agreement covering the whole $10,000 balance secured a $50,000 advance, but a later $5,000 advance went unsecured because the agreement contained no future advances clause.25
Control also affects attachment. The ordinary route requires the debtor to authenticate a record that constitutes the security agreement and describes the collateral,26 unless the secured party has possession or control of the collateral pursuant to a security agreement.27 The security agreement may be evidenced by an authenticated record, by possession of specified collateral, or by control of specified collateral,28 and for a deposit account the alternative is that the secured party has control under § 9-104.29 A depositary bank can therefore create its security interest under a security agreement the debtor has not authenticated,30 and an oral agreement can suffice. The other attachment requirements, value and the debtor’s rights in the collateral, still apply. Banks can be expected to write the grant into their standard deposit agreements, and commentators predict they will routinely take security interests in their depositors’ accounts.31
A lender that is not the depositary bank fails this test and must satisfy another condition in § 9-104(a), the control agreement or the customer route introduced above. Priority then follows control. A depositary bank with control generally has priority over competing secured parties under §§ 9-327 and 9-340, unless the competing creditor has control by becoming the bank’s customer,32 and a secured party that perfects by becoming the bank’s customer has priority over the depositary bank’s own interest.33
Debtor’s Continued Access
Section 9-104(b) answers a question that the analogy to possession invites: must the secured party shut the debtor out of the account? It need not. A secured party that has satisfied subsection (a) has control, even if the debtor retains the right to direct the disposition of funds from the deposit account.35 A secured party may obtain control in one of three ways, the depositary bank, the control agreement, or the customer route, and none of them requires that the debtor be excluded from the funds.36
The explanation lies in what “control” means here. Possession generally requires dominion and control over the property, but control in Article 9 is a technical term that means something completely different.37 The secured party need not have exclusive control, and an agreement with the bank giving both the secured party and the debtor access to the account is sufficient.38 What the secured party needs is standing with the bank. Under a control agreement, the bank follows the secured party’s instructions without further consent by the debtor.39 A customer holds the right, though not necessarily the exclusive right, to withdraw funds from the account or close it.40 Control thus gives the secured party the power to override the debtor, and subsection (b) says that power need not be exercised in advance.
Lenders often use a joint account: the debtor and the secured party can both withdraw, and on default the secured party simply withdraws the money and applies it to the debt.41 Commentators read the official comment’s “not necessarily the exclusive right” language as treating a joint owner as a customer who has control, consistent with § 9-104(b).42
Crestline has control. As the bank’s customer on the account it satisfies a condition in subsection (a), and Greenway’s continued access does not defeat that control.43 Delta lacks control, however faithfully Marlow keeps its promise. Delta is not the bank, has no control agreement, and is not a customer, so no condition in subsection (a) is met and subsection (b) has nothing to protect. Summit Bank remains free to honor Marlow’s instructions. The covenant restrains the debtor but gives Delta no standing with the bank, and because control is the only way to perfect a security interest in a deposit account as original collateral, Delta’s interest in the account is unperfected.44 In one case the debtor is free and the lender has control; in the other the debtor is fully restrained and the lender does not. The lender’s connection to the bank decides both.