Concept
Control Versus Filing
Does the secured party have control?
Control Versus Filing
In the large majority of cases, a secured party perfects by filing a financing statement, the form practitioners call a UCC-1, in the government office the state has designated for that purpose.1 That office is usually the secretary of state, though some collateral calls for a county filing.2 Article 9 defines "financing statement" as the initial financing statement together with any filed record relating to it.3 Filing is the baseline against which control should be measured.
Perfection matters because of what happens when the debtor fails. A creditor whose security interest has attached can repossess its collateral even if the interest is unperfected, so perfection is not the price of enforcing against the debtor.4 It does its work against other creditors. The most common of them is the trustee in bankruptcy, who is treated as holding a judicial lien on all of the debtor's assets on the day the petition is filed. Every creditor who does not properly perfect is therefore treated as unsecured in its debtor's bankruptcy.5 The word "properly" carries the weight here, because the right method depends on the kind of collateral.
Filing does not fit every kind of collateral. A third method, usable with some intangibles, is control.6 A direct security interest in a deposit account or letter of credit may be perfected only by taking control. For investment property and electronic chattel paper, control is a permissible mode of perfection but not the exclusive one.7 The source's shorthand is worth memorizing: control is to intangibles as possession is to goods.8
| Filing | Control | |
|---|---|---|
| What the lender does | Files a UCC-1 in the state-designated office | Takes control of the collateral, the intangible counterpart of possession |
| Where it fits | The large majority of cases | Some kinds of intangible collateral |
| Deposit account as original collateral | Does not perfect | The only method |
| Investment property and electronic chattel paper | Available | Permissible but not exclusive |
A short hypothetical shows the consequence. Harbor Finance lends $300,000 to Pell Co. and takes a security interest in Pell's checking account at Lakeside Bank. Harbor files a UCC-1 describing the account but never takes control. Pell then files for bankruptcy. Harbor's security interest has attached, but a direct security interest in a deposit account may be perfected only by control. Harbor has therefore not properly perfected, and it is treated as an unsecured creditor in Pell's bankruptcy.9 The filing did nothing for Harbor. Control was the step the collateral required.
The word "direct" marks the reach of this rule. It describes an interest taken in the account itself, and the identifiable-cash-proceeds exception covered above is a separate topic. Before you choose a method of perfection, first ask what kind of collateral the lender holds.