Concept
What Counts as Goods
Classification of goods (§ 9-102)
Classifying Goods Under Article 9
What Counts as Goods
Article 9 defines goods in one phrase: all things that are movable when a security interest attaches.1 The rest of UCC § 9-102(a)(44) adds a handful of assets that qualify by name and subtracts a longer list of property that never qualifies. Each addition and each subtraction refines the same idea. Goods are tangible, movable things, and the definition marks the edges of that idea with care.
The definition comes first because Article 9 begins by dividing collateral into tangible personal property (goods) and intangible property, then subdivides each side into more specific types, and pigeonholing the collateral correctly is the first step in any Article 9 problem.2 The subcategories of goods (consumer goods, farm products, inventory, equipment, and several others) each have their own definitions,3 but an item reaches them only after it clears this threshold. A negotiable promissory note and a tractor can secure the same loan. The tractor is goods and the note is not, so the two part company at the first step.
The four subsections below follow the statute's own order: the core test and the moment at which it applies, the items the definition adds by name, the rule for embedded computer programs, and the exclusions.
Movable at Attachment
The core of the definition is a two-part test. A thing is goods if it is movable at the moment a security interest attaches.4 “Thing” confines the category to tangible personal property,5 and “movable” is the word that separates personal property from real property.6 The first part asks what kind of property the thing is; the second asks when to decide.
Each part does a job. Movability keeps land out of the category, because Article 9 generally does not govern the creation or transfer of interests in real property, with fixtures and certain enforcement rights as the exceptions.7 The timing clause answers a different problem: material changes character as it is used. Lumber and bricks are personal property when delivered to a building site, but once they are used to construct the building they become part of it and are neither personal property nor fixtures.8 The same boards are goods on Monday and part of a wall on Friday, so a question about movability has no answer until someone fixes the moment for asking it. The definition fixes that moment at attachment. What attachment requires is a separate topic.
The second scene applies the statute directly: no security interest arises under Article 9 in ordinary building materials incorporated into an improvement on land.9 Easily movable property marks the other pole. A free-standing refrigerator or stove never takes on any aspect of real property and stays personal property.10 Heft does not matter. A large sculpture that needs heavy machinery to move is still tangible, movable property and therefore goods.11
Article 2 asks the same question at a different moment: whether the thing is movable when it is identified to the contract for sale.12 Each article fixes the moment that matters to what it governs, since a sale ties particular goods to a contract and a secured loan ties collateral to a debt. A thing can therefore be goods under one article and not under the other if its relationship to the land changes between the two moments. The usual error is to measure movability at the wrong time, asking whether the item was movable when sold or is movable today. The only question is whether it was movable when the security interest attached.
Items Treated as Goods
The definition's second sentence adds five kinds of property: fixtures; standing timber that is to be cut and removed under a conveyance or contract for sale; the unborn young of animals; crops grown, growing, or to be grown, even if produced on trees, vines, or bushes; and manufactured homes.15 Each sits on the border between land and personal property, or does not yet exist as a separate object. A bare movability test would leave their status in doubt. The definition removes the doubt by naming them.
Crops show the logic most plainly. Growing plants are part of the real property, and a person with an interest in the land has an interest in the crops, yet crops can be collateral for an Article 9 security interest.16 The definition therefore reaches crops grown, growing, or to be grown.17 A grower who grants a security interest in wheat still in the field has given goods, and so has an orchardist who pledges next summer's apples. Crops resemble fixtures in being tied to the land, but they are not fixtures; they are a subtype of farm products, a subcategory this chapter takes up later.18 Livestock financing follows the same pattern. Because the unborn young of animals are goods by name, a breeder can grant a security interest in a calf before it is born.19
Standing timber is the one inclusion that carries a condition. The timber must be one that is to be cut and removed under a conveyance or contract for sale.20 Trees rooted in the ground are part of the land until someone commits to sever them. When the owner contracts to let another cut the timber, it becomes “timber to be cut.”21 A question about a security interest in trees therefore turns on one fact: does a conveyance or contract call for their cutting and removal?
Okafor's lender has no goods collateral. Article 9 generally does not govern the creation or transfer of interests in real property,22 so trees that remain part of the land are not goods.
Fixtures are goods that have become so related to particular real property that an interest in them arises under real property law.23 A furnace affixed to a house, counters permanently affixed to a store floor, and a sprinkler system installed in a building are the standard examples.24 Ordinary building materials built into a structure are different. They are neither personal property nor fixtures, and no Article 9 security interest arises in them.25 Because a fixture is both goods and part of the land's story, a secured party that wants first priority files a fixture financing statement in the real estate recording office for the land where the fixtures sit. If that filing precedes any other interest in the real estate recorded by someone other than the debtor, the secured party should have first priority over the later-recorded interest.26
A manufactured home is a structure, transportable in one or more sections, built on a permanent chassis and designed as a dwelling, with or without a permanent foundation, once it is connected to the required utilities.27 The definition sets size thresholds, but a structure that misses them can still qualify if the manufacturer voluntarily files the required federal certification and complies with the standards.28 A mobile home intended to sit on a pad as a permanent residence is a manufactured home. A recreational vehicle intended only for vacations is not.29
The common thread explains the usual error with these items. A student who applies the movability test to wheat in the field, an unborn calf, or a manufactured home may conclude that none is movable and call the collateral real property. The second sentence of the definition forecloses that step by admitting each item by name. Only the timber carries a condition of its own: a conveyance or contract for sale must call for the trees to be cut and removed.
Embedded Computer Programs
A computer program embedded in goods is itself goods when one of two conditions holds. Either the program is associated with the goods in such a manner that it customarily is considered part of the goods, or by becoming the owner of the goods a person acquires a right to use the program in connection with the goods.31 The same rule carries any supporting information provided in connection with a transaction relating to the program.32
The two conditions describe two ways a program can belong with a machine. The first looks to how the market regards the program: control software that dealers, buyers, and lenders all treat as part of a combine satisfies it. The second looks to what ownership delivers: an owner who acquires the right to run the program with the machine takes the program along with the goods.
Article 9 draws the same boundary from the other side. “Software” means a computer program and any supporting information provided in connection with a transaction relating to the program, but the term does not include a program that falls within the definition of goods.33 General intangibles, the residual category, take in software.34 A program is therefore either goods or software, and the only question is whether the embedded-program sentence reaches it.
That sentence ends with a limit. The term does not include a computer program embedded in goods that consist solely of the medium in which the program is embedded.35 Without the limit, almost all software would qualify as goods, because almost every program reaches its owner on some physical carrier such as a disk or a drive. When the carrier is all the goods amount to, the program is the thing of value and the medium only transports it. The program is then software and a general intangible. A security agreement that describes only inventory does not reach it, because a description limited to one category does not cover property in another.36
The hardware side raises no difficulty. A smartphone is goods in a sale even though its usefulness depends on software, because the device itself is a movable, physical object.37 The embedded-program sentence matters only for the program.
Exam errors run in two directions: treating every program that touches a machine as goods, and treating every program as a general intangible. A sound analysis asks three questions in order. Is the program embedded in goods? Does either condition apply? Do the goods amount to nothing more than the medium holding the program?
Property Excluded From Goods
The closing sentence of § 9-102(a)(44) lists what the term does not include: accounts, chattel paper, commercial tort claims, deposit accounts, documents, general intangibles, instruments, investment property, letter-of-credit rights, letters of credit, money, and oil, gas, or other minerals before extraction.39 Most of the entries share one logic. Goods are things, and the excluded categories are rights, claims, and paper that evidences or represents value. Money and unextracted minerals are excluded for reasons of their own, taken up below. The list marks the outer edge of the definition, and it holds even where a bare movability test would let an item through.
The residual category confirms the structure. A general intangible is any personal property other than the listed categories, goods among them, so no item is both goods and a general intangible.40
The line matters because misreading the category can cost a lender its protection. Article 9 treats identifying the type of collateral as the first step in analysis,41 and a secured party that fails to perfect loses to a lien creditor and to any secured creditor whose interest attached later but who perfected first. The most common lien creditor is the trustee in bankruptcy, who is treated as holding a judicial lien on all of the debtor's assets on the date the petition is filed, so a creditor that has not properly perfected is treated as unsecured in the bankruptcy.42
Tangible paper that evidences a right shows the line most clearly. An instrument is a negotiable instrument, such as a note, or any other writing that evidences a right to the payment of a monetary obligation, is not itself a security agreement or lease, and is of a type ordinarily transferred by delivery with any necessary indorsement.43 A person can pick up the paper, so a movability test alone would admit it, which is why the definition excludes it by name. The debtor's wealth lies in the right to be paid; the paper only evidences that right, much as a disk only carries a program.
A grant limited to goods does not reach the note, so a lender in Calloway's position needs a description that covers the note as the instrument it is.44
Chattel paper and documents are tied to goods yet are not goods themselves. A dealer sells a tractor to a farmer on a conditional sales contract, and the tractor is goods. When the dealer transfers that contract to a bank, the contract is chattel paper, the category covering a contract that combines a monetary obligation with a security interest in specific goods. Chattel paper appears on the excluded list, so the contract is not goods even though it describes a tractor.45 A document is a document of title or a receipt of the type described in Section 7-201(b),46 and the same exclusion applies: the goods it covers remain goods, while the paper itself does not. In both settings the exclusion separates the thing from the paper about the thing, and the lender must decide which of the two it takes as collateral.
Money fits none of those patterns. Bills and coins can be held and moved, yet goods are defined as tangible or movable personal property other than money.47 Oil, gas, and other minerals in the ground are part of the land, and Article 9 generally does not govern the creation or transfer of interests in real property,48 so they are not goods while they stay in place. The exclusion reads before extraction, so the same oil becomes goods once it is brought to the surface.49 A debtor who grants a security interest in oil still underground, to attach as the oil is pumped, has created as-extracted collateral, a subcategory taken up later in this chapter.50
The usual mistake is to let physical form decide the question. A promissory note, a document of title, and a roll of cash can each be held in the hand, yet each falls on the excluded list, while oil that cannot be touched underground becomes goods when it is pumped. The inquiry is whether the property is a movable thing outside the listed categories when the security interest attaches.
Taken together, the four subsections yield a working sequence. First, check whether the property sits on the excluded list; if it does, it is not goods. Second, check the express inclusions, remembering the condition on timber and the medium-only limit on programs. Third, if neither list settles the question, apply the core test and ask whether the thing was movable when the security interest attached.