Concept
Why Classification Matters
Classification of goods (§ 9-102)
Why Classification Matters
Article 9 recognizes only one kind of security interest, but the rules that govern it change with the type of collateral.1 Suppose a consumer gives a retailer a security interest in a home entertainment system to secure the price over three or four years, and the retailer then gives its bank a security interest in its inventory and accounts. Article 9 covers both transactions, yet they have so little else in common that a single set of rules could not serve both. Which set applies usually depends on the type of collateral, and § 9-102(a) defines the types of goods one at a time: consumer goods in paragraph (23), farm products in (34), inventory in (48), and equipment in (33).2 Classification is therefore the first question in most Article 9 problems, and the sections that follow define each class so that you can answer it accurately.
The type of collateral matters because Article 9’s rules are principally concerned with the limits of the secured party’s protection against purchasers from, and creditors of, the debtor; between the immediate parties, freedom of contract prevails except for procedure on default.3 The classes therefore do their work where outsiders appear. Three consequences show how. Each receives a full reading later, so this section gives each a short statement and a pointer.
The first consequence is perfection, and the class of collateral decides whether the secured party must file anything. Filing is by far the commonest method of perfecting a security interest, and for goods it is a permissible method, though not the only one.4 A few narrow situations dispense with it, so that perfection occurs automatically as soon as the security interest attaches. The most important is a purchase-money security interest (PMSI), one taken to secure the price of the very goods it covers, in consumer goods.5 A seller who finances a stereo for a buyer’s living room need file nothing. The policy is practical: public filing for a great many small credit sales of low-value collateral would clutter the files and produce fees out of proportion to the credit given.6 Both elements of the rule must be present. A PMSI in equipment is not automatically perfected, neither is a non-PMSI in consumer goods, and the rule does not apply to a motor vehicle or other property covered by a certificate of title statute.7
The gap carries real risk. An unperfected secured creditor loses to a lien creditor and to any secured creditor whose interest attached later but who perfected first, and the most common lien creditor is the trustee in bankruptcy.8 Every creditor who fails to perfect properly is treated as unsecured in its debtor’s bankruptcy.9 The classic slip is to call goods consumer goods when they are not, which leads straight to the false conclusion that the interest is perfected.10
The second consequence is whether a buyer from the debtor takes the goods free of the lender’s security interest. A buyer of goods that are not inventory is not ordinarily a buyer in ordinary course of business and so takes subject to a perfected security interest created by the seller.11 That principle has been applied to a buyer of an automobile that a repair garage, which was not a dealer, had used as equipment. It has also been applied to a company that rents cars, even though the company from time to time sells the cars it replaces.12 Ordinary-course protection therefore does its work chiefly on inventory.
Farm products form a special case for buyers, and the reason is practical. Farmers typically market farm products through agents or sell to financially sophisticated buyers, so it was deemed reasonable to expect those buyers to check for filed financing statements. Farm lenders, for their part, commonly look for repayment to a single sale of the collateralized crop.13 Federal law then adds a layer of its own. Under the Food Security Act, 7 U.S.C. § 1631(d), notwithstanding any other law, a buyer in ordinary course who buys a farm product from a seller engaged in farming operations takes free of a security interest created by the seller, even if the interest is perfected and the buyer knows of it. The Act gives creditors three exceptions, and a creditor who fits one keeps its interest against the buyer.14 The later treatment of priorities takes up those exceptions. For now, note that a dispute between a buyer and a lender is governed by different rules depending on whether the goods are inventory or farm products.
The third consequence is that Article 9 attaches special rules to consumer goods, to consumer goods transactions, and to consumer transactions.15 The three labels are not interchangeable. The first describes the collateral, the other two describe transactions, and the later section on consumer goods takes up the difference. These rules operate alongside the three basic requirements for attachment, which apply both to interests securing a debt and to sales of rights to payment within Article 9: the debtor must agree to grant the security interest, value must be given, and the debtor must have rights in the collateral, subject to some limited exceptions.16
None of these consequences can be reached until the collateral has a class.
Mutually Exclusive Classes
Equipment closes the scheme, and it does so by subtraction: § 9-102(a)(33) defines it as goods other than inventory, farm products, or consumer goods.18 A residual class needs no test of its own, since it collects whatever the other three leave behind. Those three carry affirmative tests. Consumer goods are goods used or bought for use primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.19 Farm products are goods, other than standing timber, with respect to which the debtor is engaged in a farming operation and which fall within the listed groups.20 Inventory is goods, other than farm products, that are, among other things, held for sale or lease or to be furnished under a contract of service.21 Together the four definitions give every good one class at a time.
Exclusivity matters because the rules keyed to each class do not agree with one another. As the last section showed, the class decides whether a purchase-money interest is perfected automatically and whether a buyer takes free. If a stereo set could be both consumer goods and equipment, the seller’s interest would be perfected on attachment under one rule and unperfected until filing under the other, and the seller could not know which was true. The residual definition of equipment adds a second guarantee: no good falls outside the four classes, so the question of classification always has an answer.
The definitions secure exclusivity in two ways. First, they carve out: inventory begins with goods other than farm products, so a farmer’s crop cannot be both farm products and inventory, and equipment excludes all three other classes. Second, the affirmative tests ask different questions. Consumer goods turn on personal, family, or household use; farm products turn on whether the debtor is farming; inventory turns on whether the debtor holds the goods for sale, lease, or service, or consumes them in the business. When two tests do seem to fit, as with a physician’s car or a farmer’s truck that might be either consumer goods or equipment, the official comment supplies the answer. The classes of goods are mutually exclusive, the same property cannot be both equipment and inventory, and in a borderline case the principal use to which the property is put is determinative.22 The later treatment of borderline classification problems develops that tie-breaker in full.
A single business shows how the classes divide goods without overlap. In a hardware store, a riding mower held for sale is inventory.23 The cash registers, computers, and desks that run the store are equipment, because no other class claims them.24 Even the paper, pens, and toner the staff use up are inventory, as materials used or consumed in the business.25 The mower cannot also be equipment, because equipment is what remains once inventory is removed. The store holds goods in several classes, yet each item sits in exactly one.
That arithmetic matters most when a security agreement describes its collateral by class, and an exam stem can test it with a single word.
Because inventory carves out farm products and equipment collects what the others leave, apply the classes in that order of exclusions:
The last step invites a common error. Students tend to treat equipment as a class with a description of its own, usually heavy machinery, and then ask whether the goods look like machinery. The definition supplies no such test. A store’s desks and cash registers are equipment as surely as a factory’s presses are, because no other class claims them.31
Exclusivity governs the four principal classes only. Article 9 also defines subcategories of goods (fixtures, manufactured homes, accessions, and as-extracted collateral), and those subcategories cut across the principal classes instead of competing with them.32 A furnace in a family’s home is the standard fixture and can also be consumer goods; the same furnace in a machine shop is a fixture and can also be equipment. The labels answer different questions, since fixture describes how the goods relate to real property while the principal class describes how the debtor uses them. An overlap with inventory is hard to imagine, because goods held for sale are not normally affixed to real estate, and crops, though related to land, are farm products but not fixtures.33 Accessions, manufactured homes, and as-extracted collateral each receive their own treatment in the section on other goods subcategories.
Classification at the Time of Transaction
A class label attaches to goods in a particular hand at a particular time, because each definition describes someone doing something with the property. Consumer goods are goods used or bought for use for personal, family, or household purposes, and inventory is goods held for sale, lease, or service.35 Neither definition can be applied to a thing in the abstract; each needs a holder and a use. The same item may therefore carry different labels as it moves along the distribution chain, or as its owner finds a new job for it.
The statute sorts goods by the use to which they are put, and a new use or a new holder changes the class. Once a lawn mower that is inventory in the hardware store’s hands is sold to a consumer, that very same mower becomes a consumer good.36 The official comment gives the same lesson with a radio, which may be inventory in a dealer’s hands and consumer goods in a consumer’s.37 The class is a statement about one holder at one time, and a single television can carry the point through three such statements.
A television held for sale in an appliance store’s warehouse is inventory, so a security interest the store grants in it is a security interest in inventory. If a dentist buys the set and installs it in the office, the set becomes equipment, and a lender who takes an interest from the dentist while the set sits in the office has taken an interest in equipment. Should the dentist later decide that patients dislike the set and carry it home, the television becomes a consumer good, and an interest granted while it sits in the living room is an interest in consumer goods.38 The set never changes. The holder and the use change, and the correct classification is the one that fits the time at which the interest was granted.39 The question for every such problem is who holds the goods, and for what use, at the moment the security interest is created.
A common error looks forward to where the goods are headed. A bank takes a security interest in the stock of a chain of hardware stores, nearly all of it meant for household buyers, and never files a financing statement. When the stores enter bankruptcy, the bank claims automatic perfection on the theory that the goods are consumer goods. The claim fails. In the stores’ hands the mowers, shovels, and hand tools are inventory, because the stores hold them for sale when the bank’s interest is created.40 A mower becomes a consumer good only after a household buys it, and it would become equipment if a landscaping business bought it, but neither sale has happened when the bank takes its interest. Inventory falls outside the automatic perfection rules, so the bank is unperfected and the trustee in bankruptcy can avoid its interest.41 The bank classified the goods by their destination; the statute asks who holds them when the interest is created.
The same timing governs a seller who finances goods. The words bought for use in the consumer goods definition let the class be fixed at the moment of purchase, before any use has occurred, so the buyer’s purpose at that moment is the fact that counts.42
The contractor’s household use came after the interest was created, and a later consumer use does not change the analysis of an interest that arose while the goods were equipment. The store therefore remains unperfected until it files.43 The homeowner’s purchase gives the store the one setting in which a purchase-money interest is perfected without a filing, and that result depends on the household purpose at the time of the purchase.44
A change of use after the interest exists raises a separate question from the classification of the original grant. If a dealer moves a copier from the showroom into its own office, the copier has gone from inventory to equipment in the dealer’s hands, and a financing statement filed when it was inventory has become inaccurate as to it. Whether that matters depends on how the Code treats inaccurate financing statements: sometimes the filer may leave one in place, and sometimes the filer must correct it.45 A sale to a new owner reclassifies the goods in the new owner’s hands in the same way. Whether the lender’s interest survives that sale is a priority question for the later treatment of priorities.
Because the class depends on facts that can change from one transaction to the next, anchor the analysis to the date of the grant: