Concept
Farm Products
Classification of goods (§ 9-102)
Farm Products
Farm products are defined in two stages. Section 9-102(a)(34) first fixes whose goods qualify and what is left out: goods, other than standing timber, with respect to which the debtor is engaged in a farming operation.1 It then lists what the goods must be: crops, livestock, supplies used or produced in a farming operation, or products of crops or livestock in their unmanufactured states.2
Because the first stage looks to the debtor, the same goods can fall into different classes in different hands. The inventory definition confirms the point from the other side. It begins with goods “other than farm products,” so goods that fit the farm-products definition cannot also be inventory.3 A rancher’s cattle are farm products; cattle that a dealer who raises nothing holds for resale are inventory.
The subsections follow the definition’s own order. The farming-operation threshold comes first, because every later question assumes the debtor has cleared it. The four groups of goods follow. Standing timber closes the unit: the definition of goods counts it as goods when it is to be cut and removed under a conveyance or contract for sale, yet the farm-products definition leaves it out.4
The Farming Operation Requirement
The farm-products class begins with the debtor. Goods qualify only if the debtor is engaged in a farming operation with respect to them, and § 9-102(a)(35) defines a farming operation as raising, cultivating, propagating, fattening, grazing, or any other farming, livestock, or aquacultural operation.5 The verbs cover the ordinary work of growing crops and tending animals, and the catch-all leaves room for activities the list omits. A debtor who does none of that holds no farm products, whatever the goods are.
Because the test attaches to the debtor, goods can change class when they change hands. To be farm products, the goods must belong to a debtor engaged in farming, such as an individual farmer or a farming corporation. Once they are transferred to a broker, for example, they stop being farm products and usually become inventory.6 Inventory occupies the other side of the line, since it consists of goods, other than farm products, that a person holds for sale or lease.7
The definition is broad about what counts as farming. A business that raises fish in an aquacultural operation qualifies, so its stock stands on the same footing as a rancher’s cattle.8 Courts have been less sure about intensive operations. Some have resisted calling confinement poultry production, with hens kept in caged production buildings, farming at all, a dispute the later treatment of farm products versus inventory takes up.9
The two lenders therefore deal with different classes, although a bushel from one bin cannot be told from a bushel in the other. Clearing the farming-operation threshold is only the first stage, because the goods must still fall within one of the four listed groups before they are farm products.10
The older definition also made possession part of the test: it reached only goods in the possession of a debtor engaged in farming.11 Revised Article 9 dropped that element, and the current text asks only whether the debtor is engaged in a farming operation with respect to the goods.12 Harvested crops and livestock are therefore farm products when the debtor is farming, whether or not the debtor keeps physical control of them.13 A grower can haul grain to a storage facility, or a rancher can ship cattle to a stockyard, without the class changing at the farm gate.
One question survives the change. The statute does not settle whether harvested crops stored off the farm, such as grain sitting in an elevator, remain farm products or become inventory, although a nonfarmer’s holding of crops for sale clearly yields inventory.14 A lender facing that uncertainty protects itself by describing such crops as both farm products and inventory, because a description reaches only property of the type it names.15 An exam question that places a farmer’s harvest in an elevator wants both classes named and the uncertainty noted.
Crops
The first listed group is crops, and the statute describes them by stage: crops grown, growing, or to be grown.17 A harvested crop is grown, a crop standing in the field is growing, and a crop not yet planted is to be grown. The class therefore follows the goods from before the seed goes into the ground until the harvest sits in the bin. The opening words of § 9-102(a)(34) still apply, and a crop qualifies only if the debtor is engaged in a farming operation with respect to it.18
Reaching crops that do not yet exist fits how farm credit works. A lender who advances money for seed and fertilizer in the spring is repaid from a crop the autumn will produce, and a class limited to harvested crops would leave that lender without farm products when it needs them. The general definition of goods also lists crops grown, growing, or to be grown.19 Crops resemble fixtures because they are part of the real property, and a person with an interest in the land has an interest in the crops. Yet crops are not fixtures, and they can serve as collateral for an Article 9 security interest.20
The crop’s stage never changes its class, but it does bear on a separate question. Classification tells the lender which Article 9 rules govern the soybeans. Attachment tells whether the lender’s interest exists yet, and among its elements is that the debtor have rights in the collateral.21 In March the debtor has no rights in a crop that does not exist, so the interest cannot attach until there is a crop, though it will be an interest in farm products when it does. Classification also controls description. Inventory means goods other than farm products, so a security agreement that describes only the farmer’s inventory does not reach the crop.22
The crops clause expressly includes crops produced on trees, vines, and bushes.23 The 1999 revision added that language, along with aquatic goods, to the 1972 definition.24 A debtor who owns an apple orchard and grants a security interest in the apples the trees produce has therefore given farm products. The trees themselves are a different matter: they are standing timber, which the definition leaves out.25 The standing-timber subsection below returns to that line.
Aquatic goods produced in aquacultural operations complete the crops clause.26 The phrase covers fish raised on a fish farm or in a hatchery and cultivated oysters.27 The livestock clause repeats the phrase, so a fish farm’s output is farm products whichever clause a court applies.28
These descriptions say what the goods are; the debtor’s activity still decides whether they join the class. Soybeans, apples, or farmed fish held for resale by a broker who conducts no farming operation are inventory, because the opening words of the farm-products definition are unmet and inventory covers goods, other than farm products, held for sale.29
Livestock
The second group is livestock, born or unborn, including aquatic goods produced in aquacultural operations.31 Like crops, livestock qualifies only through the opening words of the definition, so the debtor must be engaged in a farming operation with respect to the animals.32 Cows and their calves, chickens, and catfish raised on a farm are the familiar examples.33
The words born or unborn reach young animals still carried by their mothers. The general definition of goods lists the unborn young of animals, so a calf in the womb is goods before the farm-products clause assigns it a class.34 A lender who finances a herd of pregnant cows expects repayment from the calves the coming season will produce, and the clause keeps those calves in the same class as the cows. The aquatic-goods language repeats the crops clause, so a catfish farm’s output is farm products under either clause.
Whether laying hens are livestock reached the court in In re K.L. Smith Enterprises, Ltd. A bank argued that only conventional farming techniques, unmechanized, unsophisticated, and labor intensive, can produce farm products, so the debtor’s mechanized egg operation held inventory rather than farm products. The court found that view unpersuasive, because the Code’s language is reasonably specific about what farm products are and does not distinguish between methods of producing the same product.35 Eggs are products of livestock, so the hens that lay them are livestock, and a debtor engaged in a farming operation holds both as farm products. The decision applied the pre-revision definition, so its discussion of possession is superseded, but its reasoning about methods of production still teaches.
A purchase-money security interest in livestock, a subcategory of farm products, is treated much as a purchase-money security interest in inventory.36 To gain priority, the purchase-money secured party must perfect before the debtor obtains possession of the livestock and must give notice within the six years preceding the debtor’s receipt of possession. The notice must state that the party has or intends to take a security interest in the livestock and must describe the livestock.37 The farm-products classification is what triggers these steps.
The same animals land on either side because the livestock clause describes goods of a farming debtor. Goods that fail the farm-products definition are free to be inventory when a seller holds them for sale.38 Livestock that passes from a farming debtor to a broker or another nonfarmer generally stops being farm products and usually becomes inventory.39 The usual exam error is to ask only whether the collateral is cattle or hens, when the question also asks who holds the animals and whether that holder is engaged in a farming operation.
Farm Supplies
The third group is supplies used or produced in a farming operation.41 Supplies reach the class by the same route as crops and livestock: the debtor must still be engaged in a farming operation with respect to the goods.42 Feed and seed are the standard examples.43
Feed shows how much work the debtor’s activity does. Feed would certainly seem to be inventory, and it is inventory when it is not used in a farming operation, but it becomes a farm product when it is used to feed farm animals.44 The shift follows from the definitions: inventory covers only goods other than farm products, so supplies that meet the farm-products definition leave inventory.45 The result keeps a dairy’s feed and the herd it feeds in one class.
The two lenders deal with different classes of collateral even though the sacks are indistinguishable. A lender to the dairy farmer whose security agreement describes the collateral only as inventory has not described the feed, because inventory excludes farm products.46 The store’s lender holding a grant of inventory does reach the feed, because goods held for sale or lease are inventory when the farm-products definition is unmet.47 On an exam, ask what the debtor does with the supply and whether the debtor is farming. The supply’s physical nature settles neither question.
Unmanufactured Products
The fourth group is products of crops or livestock in their unmanufactured states.49 The Official Comment’s examples are ginned cotton, wool-clip, maple syrup, milk, and eggs.50 As with the other groups, the debtor must be engaged in a farming operation with respect to the goods, and the goods cannot be standing timber.51 The open question is how much handling a product can receive before it stops being unmanufactured.
Products of crops or livestock lose their status as farm products when they are subjected to a manufacturing process, even if the farmer still holds them. After the process they become inventory if held for sale.52 Manufacture is thus a second way out of the class, alongside the absence of a farming operation. Inventory takes over, because it covers goods, other than farm products, held for sale.53
Article 9 does not say what counts as manufacturing. The Official Comment marks the two ends of the scale and leaves the line to the courts. At one end are processes so closely connected with farming that they do not rank as manufacturing, such as pasteurizing milk or boiling sap into maple syrup or maple sugar. At the other end is an extensive canning operation.54 Pasteurized milk is still milk, while a canning line turns the farm’s raw output into a different packaged commodity. Disputes in the middle turn on decided cases near the line.
In re K.L. Smith Enterprises, Ltd. is the clearest illustration. The debtor washed its eggs, candled them, sprayed them with oil, and packed them in cartons, and the bank argued that the eggs had become inventory. The court answered that pasteurizing milk and boiling sap treat the raw product at least as heavily as washing, candling, and oiling treat an egg, and that the internal structure of the egg did not change. It also held that packing eggs in cartons is not analogous to the extensive canning operations the Official Comment describes.55 The eggs stayed in the farm-products class.
Cheese shows the other result. A dairy farmer who turns the herd’s milk into cheese and holds the cheese for sale no longer holds an unmanufactured product of livestock. The cows and the milk are farm products, and the cheese is not; it may be the farmer’s inventory.56 Set beside pasteurized milk and cartoned eggs, the contrast shows what moves the answer. Heating milk to ready it for market leaves milk, and washing and oiling an egg leaves an egg, but making cheese produces a different food.
Students tend to err in two directions on this clause. Some stop at the source of the product and treat milk, eggs, and wool as farm products whatever processing they receive. Others treat any handling as manufacturing, which would push pasteurized milk and cartoned eggs out of the class. The sound analysis confirms that the debtor is farming, places the process on the Official Comment’s scale, and classifies a product that has crossed into manufacturing as inventory if it is held for sale.
Standing Timber Excluded
The farm-products definition opens by limiting itself to goods, other than standing timber, with respect to which the debtor is engaged in a farming operation.58 Those opening words operate before any of the four listed groups comes into play, so a debtor can satisfy the farming-operation requirement completely and still hold no farm products when the collateral is standing timber. The exclusion is narrower than it first looks, because the general definition of goods includes standing timber that is to be cut and removed under a conveyance or contract for sale.59 Timber under such a contract is goods, yet it is not farm products.
The carve-out separates the trees from what the trees produce. An orchard owner who grants a security interest in the apples the trees bear gives farm products, because crops produced on trees, vines, and bushes are crops.60 A Christmas tree farm points the other way. The farm may well be engaged in a farming operation, yet its trees are standing timber and not farm products.61 Both owners farm; the difference is whether the collateral is the produce the plant bears or the plant itself. A student who sees a farming debtor and a tree and answers farm products has skipped that question, and a student who reads the crops-on-trees language as covering the trees has stretched it too far.
That result follows from a general feature of attachment: a description by type reaches only property of that type, so a grant limited to farm products leaves other property outside it.62 The 1999 revision states that standing timber is not a farm product, and it presumably makes standing timber that is to be cut inventory.63 Where the debtor holds the timber for sale, that presumption fits the inventory definition, which covers goods other than farm products held for sale or lease.64 As with every other class, the answer depends on who holds the goods and for what purpose when the security interest is created.
State law adds one variation. Many state statutes treat Christmas trees as crops, so whether a tree farm’s trees fall within the Code’s timber exclusion or within a state’s crop treatment can turn on local law and on the facts of the operation.65 Under such a statute, a lender who takes the trees as collateral must identify them well enough that a third party could locate where they are growing.66