Concept
Inventory
Classification of goods (§ 9-102)
Inventory
Inventory is the class of goods that a business sells, rents out, furnishes to customers, makes into something else, or uses up. Section 9-102(a)(48) defines it as goods, other than farm products, that fit one of four descriptions. Because only goods qualify, an item must be movable at the time the security interest attaches before it can be inventory.1 The four descriptions cover goods leased by a person as lessor; goods held for sale or lease or to be furnished under a contract of service; goods furnished under a contract of service; and goods that consist of raw materials, work in process, or materials used or consumed in a business.2
The opening words of the definition work first. Goods that meet the farm products definition cannot be inventory, and that definition asks whether the debtor is engaged in a farming operation and whether the goods fall within its listed categories, among them supplies used or produced in the operation.3 The answer depends on who holds the goods. Feed that looks like ordinary inventory becomes a farm product when it feeds farm animals, while a business that is not farming has no farm products at all.4 Each clause below therefore assumes that the farm products check has already been made.
Inventory also sorts goods on a different axis from the classes covered earlier. Consumer goods turn on an individual's personal, family, or household purpose, and farm products turn on a debtor's farming operation.5 Inventory turns on what a business does with the goods. Equipment is the catch-all for goods that fit no other class, so the line between the two runs through use: inventory is goods held for sale or lease or used in the short term, and equipment is goods used long term in the business.6 The subsections below take the four descriptions in three groups: goods held for sale or lease, goods furnished under service contracts, and raw materials and consumables.
Goods Held for Sale or Lease
Two clauses put the core of inventory on the showroom floor and in the rental yard: goods that a person leases as lessor, and goods that a person holds for sale or lease.7 The first clause reaches goods already out on lease, and the second reaches goods waiting for a buyer or renter. A lessor's fleet therefore stays in one class whether a given unit is on a customer's job or parked in the yard. The second clause also covers goods held to be furnished under a contract of service, which the next subsection takes up.
What decides the class is the word held. The definition looks past what the goods are and asks what the holder means to do with them, and here the holder means to turn them over to someone else. A John Deere dealer that holds heavy-duty equipment for sale has inventory, not equipment, even though the same machine would be equipment in the hands of a business that uses it.8 A car rental company's automobiles are inventory because the company holds them for lease.9 A business's automobile that a salesperson drives is equipment, as are its trucks, cash registers, tools, bulldozers, and cranes, because the business uses them rather than selling or renting them.10
The two situations share a class because of what happens to the goods next. Goods held for sale are meant to leave the holder's hands, and a lender with a security interest in inventory normally intends the debtor to be able to sell them free and clear.11 Buyers need the same assurance, and the rule that gives it rests on commercial necessity: it permits relatively unhindered buying and selling of inventory property.12 That rule is one instance of what Article 9's rules are principally concerned with, the limits of the secured party's protection against purchasers from and creditors of the debtor.13 Leasing is treated like selling in this respect, so a lessor's fleet shares a class with goods on a retail shelf, while goods that a business keeps and uses fall into equipment.
The two scenes involve the same kind of machine, and only the holder's purpose moves the answer. A student who sorts by appearance, calling a truck equipment on sight or a pile of costly machinery inventory because it looks valuable, will misclassify the dealer's stock and the lessor's fleet alike. The question is who holds the goods and whether that holder keeps them for use or holds them to sell or rent.14
Inventory status does not settle every question about a buyer from the debtor. In a New York case involving Andy's Car Rental System, Inc., the Appellate Division refused to find the car rental agency “in the business of selling goods of that kind,” even though its cars were classified as inventory under § 9-102.15 Holding the cars for lease made them inventory, and whether a buyer of one takes free is a separate priority question for a later reading. The class also reaches past retail stock: a court treated a buyer of timber cut and sold to mills as a buyer in the ordinary course of business.16
Goods Furnished Under Service Contracts
A business that supplies goods as part of its work, rather than selling them from a shelf, still has inventory. Goods are inventory when a person holds them to be furnished under a contract of service, and they are inventory when a person furnishes them under one.18 The two clauses mark two moments in one movement: the part waiting in the stockroom is held to be furnished, and the part supplied on the job has been furnished. Both clauses sit beneath the farm products carve-out, so they reach only goods that fail the farm products definition.
The clauses ask what the business does with the goods and ignore whether anyone buys them off a shelf. A student who looks for a sale and finds none will be tempted to call a repair part equipment, and the definition forecloses that step by naming goods furnished under a service contract in so many words.
Equipment points the other way. It consists of goods used long term in a business, and a part whose function is to pass to a customer does not fit that description.19 A car dealership's service department shows the contrast in a single room. The parts its technicians install are held to be furnished under service contracts, so they are inventory. The lifts and tools that the shop uses on job after job are goods used in the business for the long term, so they are equipment, like the tools in the standard examples of equipment.20 Touching a customer's work answers neither question. What matters is whether the goods go to the customer or stay with the business.
A lender that wants the analyzer needs a description that reaches equipment, because a grant of one type of collateral does not extend to another.21 Goods that a business uses up in its own operations, such as copier paper, are inventory under a separate clause, which the next subsection takes up.
Raw Materials and Consumables
The last clause of the definition covers goods that consist of raw materials, work in process, or materials used or consumed in a business.23 The earlier clauses describe goods that leave a business by sale, by lease, or by delivery to a customer. This clause describes goods that pass through the business in two other ways: they are made into something else, or they are used up. It sits beneath the same opening words as the rest of the definition, so it reaches only goods other than farm products.24
A manufacturer shows the first two phrases at work. Raw materials held by a manufacturer are inventory, partly finished products are work in process and therefore inventory, and finished goods held for sale are inventory as well.25 A furniture maker's lumber, half-assembled tables, and finished sofas therefore belong to one class, and a grant of inventory follows the stock from the day it arrives until the day it sells. Naming raw materials and work in process keeps the whole production line in that class instead of leaving the middle of the line unclaimed.
The third phrase, materials used or consumed in a business, carries inventory past anything the debtor intends to sell. A lawyer's copier paper and the toilet paper in a car dealership's bathroom are inventory even though neither is held for sale.26 What these goods share is a short working life in the business. Equipment, by contrast, is goods used or held for long-term use, and it is the catch-all class for goods that fit nowhere else.27 Without the consumables phrase, the supplies a business goes through every week would drop into equipment by default, beside desks and machinery that stay for years.
A hardware store shows both sides of the line. The copier paper its staff use up is inventory, while the cash registers that stay in place for years are equipment.28 A factory draws the same line: the lumber and other raw materials consumed in making the product are inventory, and the machinery that shapes them, used for years rather than used up, is equipment. The test asks how long the business uses the goods in its work, so an item that is never sold can still be inventory. Because the class depends on who holds the goods, a ream of paper that is inventory in a law office would be a consumer good if a householder bought it for use at home.29
Feed marks the edge of this clause. In an ordinary business, goods used up in the work are inventory, and cattle feed looks like a textbook case. Yet feed becomes a farm product when it is used to feed farm animals.30 The farm products definition reaches supplies used or produced in a farming operation, and the inventory definition begins with goods other than farm products, so goods that satisfy the supplies clause leave inventory through the definition's own opening words.31
The farm lender in that scene needs a description that reaches farm products, because a grant of one type of collateral does not extend to another.32 The result also depends on who holds the goods: a business that is not farming has no farm products, so its consumed supplies stay in inventory.33
Two instincts go wrong on this clause. One treats inventory as goods the debtor means to sell and so sends copier paper to equipment. The other treats consumption as decisive and so sends a farmer's feed to inventory. The consumed-materials phrase answers the first instinct, and the farm products opening words answer the second. The working question has two parts: whether the debtor is farming with these goods, and, if not, whether the goods are made into products or used up rather than kept for long-term use.