Concept
Borderline Classification Problems
Classification of goods (§ 9-102)
Borderline Classification Problems
Only goods are sorted into the four principal classes, and a good is a thing movable at the time the security interest attaches.1 Each class then carries its own test, and the tests are written to hand goods from one class to the next. Inventory begins with the words “goods, other than farm products,” so farm products can never be inventory.2 Equipment collects whatever the other classes leave behind, and the classes are mutually exclusive: the same property cannot be both equipment and inventory at once.3 Disputes arise where two definitions meet, and three seams produce most of them. The first lies between farm products and inventory, the second between inventory and equipment, and the third between consumer goods and equipment.
Holder and use settle all three. A computer is inventory when Best Buy holds it, equipment when a printing business uses it, and a consumer good when a twelve-year-old plays games on it. The machine never changes, but its holder and its purpose do.4 The test therefore asks how the asset is used at the time the security interest is given.5
A wrong answer costs the lender real protection. Classification tells the lawyer how to create and perfect a client’s security interest.6 A seller that assumed its purchase-money interest in a riding mower was automatically perfected as consumer goods found itself unperfected, because the buyer had bought the mower for business.7 Section 9-309 automatically perfects a purchase-money interest only in consumer goods.8 An unperfected creditor loses to a lien creditor and to a secured creditor who perfects first. It also loses to the bankruptcy trustee, who is treated as holding a judicial lien on the date the petition is filed.9 A mislabeled description can sink a lender in a second way, since a grant limited to accounts gives the secured party no interest in the debtor’s equipment.10 Article 9’s rules are principally concerned with the limits of the secured party’s protection against the debtor’s purchasers and creditors, and the class of the goods feeds into each of those limits.11
Farm Products Versus Inventory
The inventory definition removes farm products before it asks whether goods are held for sale, so goods that satisfy the farm products test never reach the inventory test.12 Two questions decide whether goods are farm products. The first asks whether the debtor is engaged in a farming operation with respect to the goods. The second asks whether the goods are crops, livestock, supplies used or produced in farming operations, or products of crops or livestock in their unmanufactured states.13 Livestock covers animals born or unborn and aquatic goods produced in aquacultural operations, and the list of unmanufactured products includes ginned cotton, wool-clip, maple syrup, milk, and eggs.14 Goods that pass both questions are neither equipment nor inventory, even when the farmer holds them to sell.15
The seam draws fire because a farmer’s output looks like stock in trade. Cattle, eggs, and grain all go to market, so each resembles goods held for sale, and without the carve-out the inventory class would pull in much of what a farm produces. The carve-out prevents that by making the debtor’s activity decisive, and milk shows how it works. In a dairy farmer’s hands milk is a farm product, at least before pasteurization. In the hands of a convenience store such as 7-Eleven it is inventory.16 Processing can move milk across the line as well, since milk stays a farm product until it is “manufactured” and becomes inventory after that.17 Feed makes the point from the supply side. It would certainly seem to be inventory, yet it is a farm product when it is used to feed farm animals.18
A decision involving egg production tested how far mechanization can carry the argument. The bank there contended that only conventional farming techniques, which are unmechanized, unsophisticated, and labor intensive, can produce farm products. The court found that view unpersuasive. The Code’s language, it said, is reasonably specific about what farm products are, and it does not distinguish between methods of producing the same product. The court also observed that the bank had made its loan through its own agricultural loan department.19 The opinion quotes a version of the definition that also asked whether the goods were in the possession of a debtor engaged in raising, fattening, grazing, or other farming operations. The definition quoted above asks only whether the debtor is engaged in a farming operation with respect to the goods.20 Under either wording, how the debtor farms does not decide the class. What the debtor does with the goods, and what the goods are, does.
The same logic governs drafting. A farm lender ordinarily requires a signed agreement giving it rights in collateral such as crops, livestock, or equipment.21 A grant limited to inventory would miss a farming debtor’s herd and crops, by the same reasoning that a grant of accounts misses equipment, so the description should name the farm collateral for what it is.22
The class also decides what happens when the debtor sells the collateral. A lender with a security interest in inventory normally intends the debtor to sell the goods free and clear, and a buyer in ordinary course of business who buys inventory takes free of the lender’s interest.23 Farm products follow a federal path. Under the Food Security Act, 7 U.S.C. § 1631(d), notwithstanding any other law, the UCC included, a buyer in ordinary course of business who buys a farm product from a seller engaged in farming operations takes free of a security interest the seller created, even if the interest is perfected and the buyer knows of it.24 The lender keeps its interest against that buyer only by fitting one of three exceptions, and two of them depend on the state’s enacting a central filing system of the kind the federal act specifies.25 The remaining exception is direct notice, which requires that the buyer received written notice of the security interest from the secured party within one year before the sale.26 Where the state has no such system, notice to the buyer is the lender’s only protection, and the notice demands far more than a financing statement. It requires the debtor’s social security or taxpayer identification number and identifies the farm products by type, county, crop year, and amount.27
The reasoning that once justified expecting farm-product buyers to check the files rested on how farm credit works. Farmers typically market their products through agents or sell to financially sophisticated buyers, who could reasonably be expected to check for filed financing statements. Farm lenders, for their part, expect payment when the products are marketed, because cyclical farm operations generate no regular cash flow, so their expectations focus on a single sale of a collateralized crop.28
Inventory Versus Equipment
Goods other than farm products are inventory when a person holds them for sale or lease or to be furnished under a contract of service, while equipment is goods used long term in a business.31 Equipment is also the residual class, taking goods that fit no other category.32 The line between the two is therefore a line of time and use. Goods a business holds for sale or lease, or uses in the short term, are inventory, and goods it keeps and uses over the long term are equipment.33
The same machine can sit on either side. Heavy-duty equipment held for sale by a John Deere dealer is inventory, not equipment.34 A riding lawnmower is likewise inventory in a retailer’s hands and equipment in the hands of a buyer who purchased it for business.35
Time matters as much as the holder. A television is inventory while an appliance store holds it for sale, equipment once a dentist installs it in her office, and a consumer good if she takes it home. Classification depends on when the transaction occurred. A security interest the store gave while the set sat in its warehouse was in inventory, one the dentist gave while it was in her office was in equipment, and one she gave while it was in her home was in consumer goods.36
The line matters because inventory lenders and equipment lenders hold different expectations about sales. A lender with an interest in inventory normally intends the debtor to sell free and clear.37 In the lawnmower illustration, the bank’s perfected interest in the mower as inventory would give way to a buyer who qualified as a buyer in ordinary course of business.38 Whether the buyer so qualifies is a separate question, but classification starts the analysis.
Because goods can fall into different classes at different times, a change of use changes the class.39 Once the dentist installs the set, a financing statement that describes the store’s collateral as inventory no longer describes how the television is held. Whether that costs the store’s lender anything is a perfection question, because the system sometimes lets a filer leave an inaccurate financing statement in place and sometimes requires the filer to fix it.40
The usual exam error is to sort by what the goods are. A tractor, a truck, a television, and a computer can each be inventory in one business and equipment in another, so the physical description of an item never settles its class. The sound approach asks what the holder is doing with the goods at the moment the interest is given. If the holder is selling, leasing, furnishing, or using them up, they are inventory, and if the holder is keeping them for long-term use, they are equipment.43
Consumer Goods Versus Equipment
The definition of consumer goods has two working parts: the goods must be used or bought for use, and the use must be primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.46 A computer bought to browse Netflix, follow social media and the news, and handle personal banking at home meets both parts.47 The same machine in a print shop does not, and it lands in equipment, because goods that fail the consumer test and fit no other class end up there.48
Mixed use forces a choice, because the classes are mutually exclusive. The official comment makes the choice by principal use: in borderline cases, such as a physician’s car or a farmer’s truck that might be either consumer goods or equipment, the principal use to which the property is put is determinative.49 An automobile used partly in operating a business and partly for the owner’s personal activities takes the category of its primary use.50 The evidence is practical and countable. Miles driven and hours per week driven for each purpose count, and so does the extent to which the owner depreciated the car for tax purposes.51 Commuting does not tip the balance toward business, because automobiles used for pleasure or family transportation, driving to and from work included, are consumer goods.52
The words bought for use fix a second variable, which is when the purpose is measured. A lender that finances a purchase takes its interest at the moment of sale, so the buyer’s purpose in buying is the fact the lender can know. A riding mower bought for business purposes was therefore not consumer goods at the time of purchase. The seller’s purchase-money interest was not automatically perfected under § 9-309, and the buyer’s later use of the mower at home did not change that result.53 The wording works in the other direction too. Something originally bought for consumer use but later used in a business stays consumer goods for transactions entered into while it is held as consumer goods.54
Price and size play no part. The assumption behind dispensing with a public filing for consumer goods is that most of them cost little and depreciate quickly, so lenders other than purchase-money lenders seldom rely on them and later creditors are unlikely to be fooled by the absence of a filing.55 Yachts, mobile homes, and diamond rings strain that assumption. The definition nonetheless asks about use or intended use,56 and the commentary rejects any balancing of useful life, size, and value because it would produce a long series of ad hoc judgments. Until legislators say otherwise, mobile homes, yachts, diamond wedding rings, and dining room chandeliers remain consumer goods, along with kitchen salt and Rolling Stones CDs. A purchase-money security interest in each is automatically perfected under § 9-309, except where a certificate of title law applies.57 Purpose can still take an expensive asset out of the class, because a boat bought for use in a business is not bought for personal, family, or household purposes.58
Students most often miss this boundary by sorting on the wrong feature. A student who calls a car, a computer, or a refrigerator consumer goods because families commonly own them has classified by the nature of the item, and one who calls a yacht equipment because it is expensive has classified by cost. The statute asks for the debtor’s primary use, or the buyer’s purpose at purchase, so identical assets owned by different people, or one asset owned by the same person at different times, can carry different classes.